WEBVTT 00:00.125 --> 00:02.117 Ba ga masu rauni zuciya ba 00:02.117 --> 00:08.687 Epstein, Dutroux, Teichtmeister – sunaye da ke wakiltar mummunan laifuka da aka yi wa yara. 00:08.687 --> 00:14.033 Shin da gaske su ne kaɗai masu aikata laifi – ko kuwa akwai cibiyoyin masu cin zarafin yara 00:14.033 --> 00:17.182 na duniya baki ɗaya da har yanzu ke aiki a nan? 00:17.182 --> 00:19.416 Menene rawar da hukumar shari'a ke takawa? 00:19.416 --> 00:26.337 Shin ikirarin da shaidu marasa adadi suka yi gaskiya ne cewa alkalai, masu gabatar da kara da masu bincike ba kawai 00:26.337 --> 00:30.378 suna ɓoye waɗannan laifuka ba, har ma suna da hannu a cikinsu? 00:30.378 --> 00:33.190 Kla.TV ta fallasa abubuwan mamaki. 00:33.190 --> 00:38.995 Amurka, Jamus, Ostiriya, Netherlands, Bèljiyam, Faransa, Switzerland: 00:38.995 --> 00:48.085 Haɗin gwiwar kotu a shari'o'in cin zarafin yara masu tsanani da kisan kai a ƙasashe bakwai da ake bincike a kansu. 00:48.085 --> 00:54.736 Gabatarwa: : "Ina ba kowa shi a rubuce. Mafi muni, mafi banza cin zarafin yara da na taɓa gani kuma aka ba ni 00:54.736 --> 00:58.617 bayani a rayuwata, daga bakin waɗanda abin ya shafa kansu, 00:58.617 --> 01:04.734 Masu aikata laifi mafi muni da rashin kunya sune masu gabatar da kara da alkalai kansu. 01:04.734 --> 01:09.932 Ina faɗin hakan da gaske. Mafi munanan masu laifi da na taɓa haɗuwa da su a rayuwata su ne 01:09.932 --> 01:12.945 masu gabatar da ƙara na gwamnati da alkalai. 01:12.945 --> 01:17.355 Kuma babu wanda ke ɗaukar mataki kan waɗannan mutane. 01:17.355 --> 01:23.410 Kuma ba ka san abin da zai faru idan mai fallasa labarai ya yi magana a fili ba. 01:23.410 --> 01:29.865 Kuma abin da ya fi ban mamaki game da waɗannan waɗanda ake azabtarwa a bautar ibada shi ne cewa ana yawan ba 01:29.865 --> 01:33.918 jarirai, ƙananan yara da yara maganin sa barci kafin a kashe su. 01:33.918 --> 01:41.446 Kuma wannan shi ne abin da nake ƙoƙarin faɗa. Tsawon shekaru ina cewa ina da hujjoji masu ƙarfi na zargin 01:41.446 --> 01:46.067 cewa akwai laifukan tsari a cikin ma'aikatar shari'a. 01:46.067 --> 01:52.676 Kuma shi ya sa nake cewa, zan rubuta shi ga kowa, mafi mummunan masu laifi suna cikin tsarin shari'a. 01:52.676 --> 02:06.403 Kuma idan wani abu ya same ni, za ka iya ɗaukar abin da na faɗa a matsayin shaida, a matsayin shaida da aka rantse. 02:06.403 --> 02:10.872 Ƙwazon Dorothea Thul da bayaninta sun haifar da mummunan sakamako: 02:10.872 --> 02:17.215 Abokiyar aikinta, Dr Jette Limberg-Diers, ta wallafa kiran neman agaji, tana bayyana cewa an kai hari kan 02:17.215 --> 02:21.316 likitar yara aka duka ta, kuma an tura ta sashen kwakwalwa. 02:21.316 --> 02:29.042 An soke lasisin tuƙinta kuma an ɗora jinginar tilas a kan gidanta, wanda hakan zai kai ga tilastaccen sayar da gidan. 02:29.042 --> 02:33.074 An shigar da tuhumar laifi a kanta saboda yaɗa ƙarya a intanet. 02:33.074 --> 02:38.339 A cewar tashar Telegram ɗinta, an yanke mata hukuncin daurin wata tara a kurkuku a shekarar 02:38.339 --> 02:41.308 2021, wanda aka dakatar na tsawon shekaru uku. 02:41.308 --> 02:44.792 Dr Dorothea Thul ta faɗi a cikin kotu. 02:44.792 --> 02:50.183 A watan Afrilu na shekarar 2023, an tsare ta a gidan yari kan tuhumar tayar da kiyayya. 02:50.183 --> 02:56.521 Tun daga lokacin, ta ɓace daga gani; babu wanda ya san inda take ko yadda take. 02:56.521 --> 03:00.599 Me ya sa ake kai wa Dr. Thul hari da ƙarfi sosai? 03:00.599 --> 03:06.068 Shin hakan na iya kasancewa da alaƙa da maganarta cewa mafi munin masu laifi suna cikin ma'aikatar shari'a kanta? 03:06.068 --> 03:11.005 Shin akwai wata hujja da ke nuna cewa alƙalai sun shiga cikin cibiyoyin masu cin zarafin yara? 03:11.005 --> 03:16.685 Kla.TV ta binciki waɗannan tambayoyin kuma ta gano wasu gaskiyoyi masu girgiza. 03:16.685 --> 03:22.736 Da yawa daga cikin waɗanda suka tsira da shaidu na tashin hankali na jima'i da aka tsara bisa addini sun shaida cewa 03:22.736 --> 03:29.068 manyan alkalan kotu, masu gabatar da kara, lauyoyi da jami'an 'yan sanda suna da hannu a cikin waɗannan laifuka. 03:29.068 --> 03:34.419 Da yawa daga cikinsu su ne masu aikata laifuka, wasu kuma suna ɓoye hanyoyin sadarwar masu cin zarafin yara, suna kare masu 03:34.419 --> 03:37.439 aikata laifuka, sannan suna tsananta wa shaidu da masu fafutuka. 03:37.439 --> 03:41.408 Ku saurari wasu misalai a ƙasa. 03:41.408 --> 03:43.150 1. Amurka 03:43.150 --> 03:50.718 Hannun jari na tsarin shari'ar Amurka a cikin skandal ɗin Epstein . Mai ba da jari na Amurka kuma mai laifin cin zarafin jima'i, 03:50.718 --> 03:56.394 Jeffrey Epstein, ya jagoranci wata ƙungiyar safarar mutane don cin zarafin jima'i wacce ta shafi 03:56.394 --> 04:00.136 yara ƙasa da shekaru na tsawon kusan shekaru 20. 04:00.136 --> 04:07.173 Mabukata sun ba da rahoton safarar jima'i da cin zarafin jima'i da ake zargin sun faru tun a shekarar 1996. 04:07.173 --> 04:10.923 Ana kiyasta cewa jimillar adadin wadanda abin ya shafa ya kai aƙalla 100. 04:10.923 --> 04:14.714 Duk da haka, adadin lamuran da ba a ruwaito ba tabbas ya fi yawa sau da yawa. 04:14.714 --> 04:21.400 Maria Farmer, ɗaya daga cikin waɗanda Epstein ya yi wa fyade, wadda aka tilasta mata yin aiki a teburin karɓar baƙi 04:21.400 --> 04:28.074 na gidan baƙi inda Epstein yake zaune a lokacin, ta lura da abubuwa masu zuwa a cikin tsawon shekara guda: 04:28.074 --> 04:36.042 Kowace rana, ana kawo mata daga biyar zuwa goma ga Epstein, abin da ya kasance abin tsanani ga yaran. 04:36.042 --> 04:41.003 Ta yi magana game da dubban 'yan mata da suka isa gonar Epstein. 04:41.003 --> 04:49.521 A Florida kadai, ba a sake samun 'yan mata 500 da Maria Farmer ke son tuntuɓa don su bayar da bayanai kan Epstein ba. 04:49.521 --> 04:52.753 Ba za ta iya fahimtar abin da ya faru da duk 'yan matan ba. 04:52.753 --> 04:57.222 Tana matuƙar zargin cewa sun rasa rayukansu. 04:57.222 --> 05:01.328 Virginia Roberts Guiffre, wata daga cikin waɗanda Epstein ya yi wa cin zarafi wadda ta 05:01.328 --> 05:03.739 kasance ƙarƙashin ikon sa na tsawon shekaru, ta ce: 05:03.739 --> 05:09.763 Na ga daruruwan 'yan mata suna shiga ta ƙofar juyawa ta Jeffrey, ƙofarsa wadda ke juyawa koyaushe. 05:09.763 --> 05:14.845 Virginia Roberts Guiffre ta kasance a wurin lokacin da Epstein ya karɓi 'yan triplets masu shekaru 12 daga 05:14.845 --> 05:18.217 Faransa, waɗanda mai binciken 'yan samfurin, Brunel, ya kawo. 05:18.217 --> 05:22.621 An tilasta wa 'yan matan su aikata ayyukan batsa tare da Epstein. 05:22.621 --> 05:30.513 Epstein ba wai kawai ya yi cin zarafi da fyade kan 'yan matan ba, har ma ya miƙa su ga mashahurai don jima'i. 05:30.513 --> 05:33.770 An tashi da 'yan matan a jirgin sama zuwa ko'ina a duniya don wannan manufa. 05:33.770 --> 05:40.261 Wasu daga cikin waɗanda Epstein ya yi wa fyade sun ambaci sunayen mutanen da suka yi musu fyade lokacin da suke ƙanana. 05:40.261 --> 05:46.351 Baya ga Epstein, Virginia Roberts Guiffre ta zargi wadannan mutane da cin zarafinta: 05:46.351 --> 05:54.593 Yarima Andrew, lauya mashahuri Alan Dershowitz, manajan asusun jari Glenn Dubin, ɗan siyasa Bill Richardson, mai 05:54.593 --> 06:03.472 binciken 'yan kwallon nunin Faransa Jean-Luc Brunel, masanin AI Marvin Minsky, da biloniyaren otal Tom Pritzker. 06:03.472 --> 06:08.133 Maria Farmer ta ruwaito cewa Donald Trump, da kuma Bill da Hillary Clinton, sun kasance 06:08.133 --> 06:10.784 masu shirya laifi tare da Jeffrey Epstein. 06:10.784 --> 06:18.361 Ta ga su duka suna zuwa da fita a gidan Epstein kuma ta san suna da hannu a komai, in ji Farmer. 06:18.361 --> 06:21.351 Epstein ya kiyaye kyakkyawar dangantaka da ma'aikatar shari'a. 06:21.351 --> 06:28.399 Wasu masu kara da suka shigar da kara kan Epstein sun shaida cewa sanannen lauya tauraro na Amurka, Alan M. Dershowitz, 06:28.399 --> 06:32.350 wanda ya kare Epstein sau da dama, yana cikin masu laifi. 06:32.350 --> 06:37.199 Maria Farmer ta bayyana Dershowitz a zahiri a matsayin "abokin makirci". 06:37.199 --> 06:43.148 Virginia Roberts Guiffre – ita ce babban mai kara a shari'ar Epstein – ta kai kara kan lauya a 06:43.148 --> 06:47.129 shekarar 2019 saboda cin zarafin jima'i da bata suna. 06:47.129 --> 06:55.526 Dershowitz sai ya shigar da ƙara ta mayar da martani kan zargin ɓata suna da kuma haifar da damuwar zuciya da gangan. 06:55.526 --> 07:00.879 Har zuwa yau, yana ƙin yarda ƙwarai cewa ya taɓa yin hulɗar jima'i da ƙanana. 07:00.879 --> 07:09.701 An cire zargin cewa lauya ya yi wa Virginia Roberts Guiffre cin zarafi tana ƙarama daga cikin fayilolin shari'a ta hannun alkali. 07:09.701 --> 07:14.340 Dershowitz bai fuskanci hukunci ba, duk da cewa mata da dama sun zargi shi. 07:14.340 --> 07:20.708 Sun bayyana a rubuce cewa an yi masu cin zarafin jima'i ko fyade a kansu tun suna kanana. 07:20.708 --> 07:26.144 Ya kuma ɗauki mataki kan wasu mata masu ƙara ta hanyar neman bayanai masu ƙazantar mutunci 07:26.144 --> 07:29.614 da kuma isar da su ga babban jami'in bincike. 07:29.614 --> 07:36.016 Misali, ya ikirari cewa Virginia Roberts Guiffre ta kasance sananniyar karuwa kuma mai ƙarya. 07:36.016 --> 07:41.598 Ita, daga cikin dukkan mutane, wadda, a cewar kanta, an tilasta mata yin batsa ta hannun 07:41.598 --> 07:45.005 Epstein da Dershowitz lokacin da take ƙarama! 07:45.005 --> 07:50.758 Matsin lamba daga kafofin watsa labarai da na shari'a kan Virginia Roberts Guiffre a ƙarshe 07:50.758 --> 07:54.841 ya sa ta rushe ta janye zarginta kan Dershowitz. 07:54.841 --> 08:02.437 Epstein ya samu wakilci daga Alan Dershowitz karo na biyu a shari'ar kotu a shekarar 2019. 08:02.437 --> 08:09.794 An tuhume Epstein a shekarar 2008 da fyade kan yara ƙanana da tilasta musu yin batsa, wanda a al'ada 08:09.794 --> 08:14.317 zai sa a yi masa hukuncin zaman gidan yari har abada. 08:14.317 --> 08:21.532 Maimakon haka, Jay Levkowitz, wani lauya tauraro mai karɓar kuɗi mai yawa daga cikin tawagar lauyoyin Dershowitz 08:21.532 --> 08:28.691 mai mutane bakwai a lokacin, ya yi sulhu a wajen kotu da lauyan tarayya na Florida, Alexander Acosta. 08:28.691 --> 08:33.598 Sakamakon wannan yarjejeniya, Epstein ya samu hukuncin zaman gidan yari na watanni 18 wanda 08:33.598 --> 08:36.380 bai dace ba maimakon zaman gidan yari har abada. 08:36.380 --> 08:39.743 Ya yi waɗatar watanni goma sha uku kawai na wannan hukuncin. 08:39.743 --> 08:44.785 An masa masauki a bangaren masu zaman kansu na gidan yari, kuma yana da har zuwa awanni 12 na 08:44.785 --> 08:48.161 'yancin kansa a kowace rana don zuwa ofishinsa. 08:48.161 --> 08:54.753 Alƙalin tuhuma Acosta da ƙungiyar lauyoyi karkashin jagorancin Levkowitz da Dershowitz sune ke da alhakin cewa 08:54.753 --> 09:01.907 Epstein ya yi wa'adin zaman gidan yari na watanni 13 kawai bayan shari'arsa a 2008, maimakon hukuncin rayuwa. 09:01.907 --> 09:10.382 Wannan shi ne kaɗai hanyar da ta ba Epstein damar ci gaba da gudanar da ƙungiyar fyade kan yara har zuwa shekarar 2019. 09:10.382 --> 09:15.809 Bugu da ƙari, wannan yarjejeniya ta ba Epstein damar kauce wa gurfanar da gwamnatin tarayya ta shirya masa a 09:15.809 --> 09:19.409 shekarar 2008, wanda hakan ya kare shi daga ƙarin bincike. 09:19.409 --> 09:27.087 Akwai dalili na zargin cewa ga waɗanda ke da alhakin shari'a da manyan masu laifi, ya fi musu dacewa kada 09:27.087 --> 09:30.748 a binciki ƙarin bayani game da skandal ɗin Epstein. 09:30.748 --> 09:35.605 Daga baya an ɗaga Alƙalin tuhuma Acosta zuwa Sakataren Ayyukan Ma'aikata a ƙarƙashin Trump. 09:35.605 --> 09:45.253 Shin wannan wata "ladi" ce saboda halayensa na haɗin kai, saboda kare masu laifi da kuma ɓoye ainihin girman wannan rikici? 09:45.253 --> 09:52.675 Jarumar jarida Julie K. Brown daga jaridar Amurka Miami Herald ta ji daga jami'an 'yan sanda cewa ba a ba su izinin gudanar 09:52.675 --> 09:57.142 da cikakken bincike kan Epstein bisa umarnin manyan jami'ai. 09:57.142 --> 10:04.507 Ta duba takardun kotu kuma a ƙarshe ta wallafa jerin laifukan Epstein a watan Nuwamba 2018. 10:04.507 --> 10:08.859 Ita ce kadai ta gabatar da cikakken fadin zarge-zargen ga jama'a. 10:08.859 --> 10:14.559 "Gaskiya babu wanda ya bi dukkan abin," in ji ɗan jaridan. 10:14.559 --> 10:21.046 Ko FBI , ɗaya daga cikin manyan hukumomin kiyaye doka a Amurka, ba ta gurfanar da Epstein ba, duk da cewa, a cewar Maria 10:21.046 --> 10:28.213 Farmer, wacce Epstein ya yi mata cin zarafi, FBI ta san sosai game da wata ƙungiyar safarar jima'i da ke shafar yara ƙanana. 10:28.213 --> 10:34.971 FBI ma ta san cewa Maria Farmer da 'yar uwarta Annie sun riga sun kasance waɗanda aka yi wa cin zarafin jima'i ta 10:34.971 --> 10:38.944 hanyar ƙungiyar safarar jima'i ta Epstein a shekarar 1996. 10:38.944 --> 10:46.650 A cewar Maria Farmer, FBI ta san daidai waɗanda suka shiga cikin wannan lamari kuma cewa Epstein yana gudanar da wata dabarar 10:46.650 --> 10:50.776 cin zarafi ta hanyar tsangwama wadda ta shafi batsa na yara. 10:50.776 --> 10:53.829 Duk da haka, ba a ɗauki wani mataki a kan Epstein ba. 10:53.829 --> 11:03.383 Dangane da hujjojin da ake da su, FBI na da alhakin daure Epstein har abada. Duk da haka, bai yi hakan ba. 11:04.925 --> 11:06.412 Sakamako na wucin gadi: 11:06.412 --> 11:12.675 Shari'ar Epstein ta bayyana yadda alƙalai da hukumomin bincike suka yi watsi gaba ɗaya, wanda ya jawo 11:12.675 --> 11:15.585 shekaru na tsananin wahala ga matan matasa da dama. 11:15.585 --> 11:18.383 Abin takaici, ba a samu sauyi mai yawa a wannan fanni ba. 11:18.383 --> 11:23.464 Abokiyar aikata laifinsa Ghislaine Maxwell yanzu an yanke mata hukuncin shekaru 20 a gidan yari. 11:23.464 --> 11:31.032 Duk da haka, Alkalin Alison Nathan bai amince da wata hujja a wannan shari'a da ke ɗauke da sunayen wasu masu 11:31.032 --> 11:34.555 taimako, masu makirci ko masu amfana da ake iya zama ba. 11:34.555 --> 11:41.593 Rajistar tashi-tashin jirgin "Lolita Express" , wanda ke ɗaukar mashahurai zuwa tsibirin Epstein, da kuma "Black Book" na Maxwell, 11:41.593 --> 11:45.416 dole ne a mika su kotu yayin da aka rufe mafi yawan shafukan. 11:45.416 --> 11:54.290 Wannan yana nufin cewa, sai dai Maxwell, duk sauran manyan masu laifi suna nan a tsere. 11:54.290 --> 11:57.250 2. Jamus: Gandun Daji na Saxony 11:57.250 --> 12:02.071 – Shin kotu ta ɓoye laifukan da kuma mambobin masu aikata su? 12:03.966 --> 12:08.980 Kalmar "Sachsensumpf" tana nufin wani skandal da ya shafi manyan mutane a Saxony waɗanda aka samu 12:08.980 --> 12:12.226 suna da hannu a tilastawa yara ƙanana yin batsa. 12:12.226 --> 12:16.049 A matsayin shaida, Mandy Kopp, wadda a lokacin ita ba ta kai shekaru na balaga ba, ta gabatar da 12:16.049 --> 12:18.745 zarge-zargen masu tsanani kan waɗannan manyan mutane. 12:18.745 --> 12:22.534 A shekarar 1989, matsalolin iyali sun sa ta ƙare a gidan batsa na Leipzig da ake kira 12:22.534 --> 12:25.176 "Jasmin" wanda ke karɓar matasa ƙasa da shekaru. 12:25.176 --> 12:31.982 A can, ita da sauran 'yan mata sun sha azabar jiki mai tsanani, an yi masu fyade kuma an yi masu azabtarwa na tsawon shekaru. 12:31.982 --> 12:36.804 A shekarar 1993, abubuwan da suka faru a gidan batsa na Jasmin sun zama sanannun a matsayin lamari na 12:36.804 --> 12:39.686 Sachsensumpf, kuma an kai farmaki kan gidan batsan. 12:39.686 --> 12:44.631 Yayin binciken 'yan sanda, Mandy Kopp ta bayyana wasu daga cikin masu azabtar da ita: 12:44.631 --> 12:50.563 Waɗannan sun haɗa da shahararrun alkalai na Leipzig, lauyoyi, jami'an 'yan sanda da dillalan gidaje. 12:50.563 --> 12:56.475 A cewar Mandy, alkalin da ya jagoranci shari'ar shi ma ɗaya ne daga cikin masu fyade. 12:56.475 --> 13:02.766 Wannan alkalin ya yanke wa mai gudanar da gidan batsa hukuncin shekaru huɗu da watanni biyu a gidan yari cikin sassauci. 13:02.766 --> 13:08.166 Daga baya mai gidan batsa ya shaida cewa an yi masa hukunci mai sauƙi ne kawai saboda bai bayyana sunayen masu laifi 13:08.166 --> 13:11.676 a gidansa na batsa da ke karɓar matasa ƙasa da shekaru ba. 13:11.676 --> 13:17.103 Wannan ƙarin hujja ce ta haɗin gwiwa tsakanin ma'aikatan shari'a da masu laifin cin zarafin yara. 13:17.103 --> 13:23.484 Mandy Kopp da sauran wadanda abin ya shafa an sake tambayarsu sau biyu kafin 2009, kuma suka sake gano lauyoyi biyu masu 13:23.484 --> 13:27.767 matsayi daga hotuna a matsayin masu fyade da suka yi musu fyade. 13:27.767 --> 13:32.854 Duk da haka, babban lauyan gwamnati na Dresden da kwamitin bincike na Saxony ba su amsa ba. 13:32.854 --> 13:36.625 Maimakon haka, suna wallafa sunan wanda abin ya shafa da wurin zama. 13:36.625 --> 13:42.396 An sannan an kai rahoton Mandy Kopp saboda "karya mutunci" ta hannun wadanda aka gano sun aikata. 13:42.396 --> 13:47.712 Tana tsoron rayuwarta da kuma karin matakan shari'a, ba ta bayyana duk abin da ta sani ba. 13:47.712 --> 13:54.054 A watan Nuwamba na shekarar 2012, an dakatar da shari'ar bayan Mandy ta sami tarwatsewar hankali a ranar 13:54.054 --> 13:57.926 huɗu ta shari'ar, bayan sa'o'i bakwai na gudanar da ita. 13:57.926 --> 14:04.292 Ba da jimawa ba, a ranar 28 ga Janairu 2013, wa'adin doka kan waɗannan ayyukan zalunci ya ƙare. 14:04.292 --> 14:10.234 Duk da haka, za a iya hana wannan dokar iyaka. Mandy Kopp ba ita kaɗai ba ce a cikin bayyanarta. 14:10.234 --> 14:16.548 Ofishin Saxony na Kariya ga Kundin Tsarin Mulki ya kuma bincika yankin fitilun ja kuma ya mika muhimman bayanai ga Ministan 14:16.548 --> 14:20.315 Cikin Gida na Saxony, Thomas de Maizière, a shekarar 2005. 14:20.315 --> 14:25.900 A cewar wannan, ana zargin alkalai da masu gabatar da kara na Leipzig da yin haɗin gwiwa da masu laifi, 14:25.900 --> 14:29.615 kuma ana zargin su da aikata cin zarafin yara da kansu. 14:29.615 --> 14:33.475 An san sunayen masu aikata laifin ga Ofishin Kariya ga Kundin Tsarin Mulki. 14:33.475 --> 14:38.087 Ofishin Kariya ga Kundin Tsarin Mulki ya kuma ruwaito cewa unguwar fitilun ja ta yi wa ofishin lauyan 14:38.087 --> 14:41.269 gwamnati matsin lamba da wadannan hujjojin tuhuma. 14:41.269 --> 14:48.521 A madadin haka, ana zargin jami'an da ake magana a kansu da yin gargaɗin hare-hare, toshe bincike da yin tasiri a shari'o'i. 14:48.521 --> 14:52.449 Duk da haka, De Maizière, a matsayin babban iko, bai sanar da Majalisar Dokoki ko 14:52.449 --> 14:55.409 hukumomin binciken laifuka da abin ya shafa ba. 14:55.409 --> 14:59.665 Daga baya an tuhume shi da toshe shari'a a ofis. 14:59.665 --> 15:06.545 Duk da haka, an janye binciken daga baya kuma an yi watsi da tafkin Saxony a matsayin "isasshen iska" da "ka'idar makirci". 15:06.545 --> 15:10.246 An ƙaryata wanzuwar wata cibiyar laifuka. 15:10.246 --> 15:15.334 Maimakon haka, an kai hari kan manyan masu bincike biyu daga 'yan sanda da Ofishin Kariya ga Kundin Tsarin Mulki. 15:15.334 --> 15:22.034 Babban jami'in bincike na sashen binciken laifuka na yankin laifukan tsari, Georg Wehling, an dakatar da shi kai tsaye daga 15:22.034 --> 15:26.319 bakin Sakataren Cikin Gida bisa hujjoji masu tayar da shakka. 15:26.319 --> 15:32.663 Simone Skroch, wadda a da ake kiranta Henneck, wadda a lokacin ita ce shugabar sashen Ofishin Kula da Kare Kundin Tsarin Mulki, 15:32.663 --> 15:38.009 kuma wadda a matsayinta na lauyan gwamnati ta riga ta rushe wata ƙungiyar cin zarafin yara, yanzu an shigar 15:38.009 --> 15:41.605 da ita cikin shekaru na matakan ladabtarwa da bincike. 15:41.605 --> 15:47.950 An tuhume su duka, amma daga baya an wanke su daga manyan tuhuma bayan shari'a mai tsawo. 15:47.950 --> 15:53.657 Thomas De Maizière, a gefe guda, ya hau matakai har ya rike mukamai daban-daban a matsayin Ministan Tarayya. 15:53.657 --> 16:00.185 Mun lura da abu iri ɗaya a shari'ar Epstein, lokacin da mai gabatar da kara Alexander Acosta, wanda ya kare 16:00.185 --> 16:04.398 masu laifi, Trump ya ɗaga shi matsayin Sakataren Ma'aikata. 16:04.398 --> 16:09.572 Shin wannan wani misali ne na tsarin da ke nuna yadda tsarin shari'a ke ɗaukar matakan tsanani kan masu fallasa laifuka, 16:09.572 --> 16:16.586 yayin da ake barin masu aikata laifi a baya ba tare da hukunci ba, kuma ake ɗaga matsayi ga waɗanda ke ɓoye laifukan? 16:16.586 --> 16:25.631 3. Shin kotunan Ostiriya sun kare ɗan wasan kwaikwayo mai cin zarafin yara Florian Teichtmeister? 16:25.631 --> 16:33.764 A shekarar 2023, an yi matuƙar murna game da hukuncin sassauci ƙwarai da aka yanke wa Florian Teichtmeister, ɗan wasan kwaikwayo 16:33.764 --> 16:38.888 na Ostiriya kuma memba na Freemason na Babban Lodge na Ostiriya. 16:38.888 --> 16:48.509 A bayyane Teichtmeister ya yi matuƙar imani da Freemasonry har ma ya gina haikali a kan kadararsa. 16:48.509 --> 16:55.600 An gurfanar da shi a gaban kotu saboda an same shi da babbar adadin miyagun ƙwayoyi a hannunsa, 16:55.600 --> 17:00.099 kuma ya tara fayiloli 76,000 na batsa na yara. 17:00.099 --> 17:07.310 Da yawa daga cikinsu shi ne ya gyara, ya yi musu sharhi ko ya tattara su cikin haɗaɗɗun hotuna. 17:07.310 --> 17:15.154 A cikin maganganunsa, ya bayyana munanan tunanin tashin hankali da ya taɓa yi wa yara. 17:15.154 --> 17:25.081 Daga dukan bel, azabtarwa da fyade masu ban tsoro har zuwa mutuwa, tunaninsa bai san iyaka ba. 17:25.081 --> 17:29.959 Ofishin lauyan gwamnati ya sanya Teichtmeister cikin masu haɗari a ma'auni daga 1 zuwa 10, 17:29.959 --> 17:33.274 inda ya kai mataki na tara, na biyu mafi girma. 17:33.274 --> 17:43.546 Duk da haɗarin da yake yi mai tsanani, kuma duk da cewa dubban yara sun ji rauni, kuma Teichtmeister yana da ɓangare na 17:43.546 --> 17:56.305 laifi a matsayin mai amfani, an yanke masa hukuncin zaman gidan yari na shekaru biyu da aka dakatar, bisa sharadin ya yi jinya. 17:56.305 --> 18:01.974 Don haka ba zai shafe koda rana ɗaya a gidan yari ba saboda abin da ya aikata. 18:01.974 --> 18:07.185 Ba wai kawai hukuncin da ya yi matuƙar rashin dacewa ba, har ma da halayen waɗanda suka shiga 18:07.185 --> 18:10.790 cikin shari'ar suna haifar da tambayoyi masu tsanani. 18:10.790 --> 18:19.885 Ba a yi bincike ba kan wanda Teichtmeister ya yi sharhi a kan fayilolinsa, ko kuma ko shi na cikin wani cibiyar sadarwa. 18:19.885 --> 18:26.500 A cewar masu lura da shari'ar, ba a yi wa wanda ake kara tambayoyi masu muhimmanci ba, kuma ba a 18:26.500 --> 18:31.080 yi tambayar shaidu daga lauyan kara ko alkali ba. 18:31.080 --> 18:36.824 Shin akwai tsoro cewa za a fallasa wasu fitattun mutane? 18:36.824 --> 18:42.964 Ba a taba bincika ko da gaske ya aiwatar da tunaninsa na tashin hankali ba. 18:42.964 --> 18:50.060 Wannan ya kasance duk da hujjoji bayyanannu, kamar jerin kayan sayayya da aka samu a hannunsa don 18:50.060 --> 18:55.495 sayen rigunan 'yan mata da kayan sadomasochistic. 18:55.495 --> 19:02.936 Alƙali Stefan Apostol ya yi nadama kan wariyar da ake yi wa Teichtmeister a cikin al'umma, ya kuma ɗauki zanga-zangar 19:02.936 --> 19:08.498 da aka yi a kansa a matsayin hujja don ba da sauƙin hukunci. 19:08.498 --> 19:16.221 Mai gabatar da kara mai sanyin hali, Julia Kalmar, ta ɓoye muhimman bayanai har sai an kammala sauraron hujjoji. 19:16.221 --> 19:25.681 Duk da cewa an tabbatar da cewa Teichtmeister tana da haɗari sosai, ta yanke shawarar kada ta daukaka ƙara kan hukuncin. 19:25.681 --> 19:32.998 Shaidar ƙwararren da aka gayyata, Farfesa Dr. Peter Hofmann, ya yi magana da ƙarfi yana goyon bayan wanda ake 19:32.998 --> 19:37.926 kara, sannan ya rage muhimmancin haɗarin da yake kawowa. 19:37.926 --> 19:44.828 Hofmann ya riga ya jawo hankali a shari'o'in cin zarafi na baya saboda samar da rahotannin kwararru masu ban mamaki 19:44.828 --> 19:49.487 da ke goyon bayan masu kare kansu da rage girman laifukan. 19:49.487 --> 19:58.588 Ya taɓa cewa: "Rabin yaran da abin ya shafa na iya jimrewa hare-haren batsa da yara sosai." 19:58.588 --> 20:06.849 Suna haɗa shi cikin tarihin rayuwarsu kuma ba sa samun cutar damuwa ta bayan rauni. 20:06.849 --> 20:12.462 Shin haɗari ne da aka zaɓe shi a matsayin ƙwararren shaida a wannan shari'ar? 20:12.462 --> 20:13.873 Zaman ƙarshe na ɗan lokaci: 20:13.873 --> 20:19.864 Hukuncin da halayen ban mamaki na ƙwararren shaida, alkali da lauyan gwamnati suna haifar da tambayoyi. 20:19.864 --> 20:24.579 Shin an yi wa Teichtmeister mu'amala da laushin hali domin kada ya bayyana wasu abokan aikata laifi? 20:24.579 --> 20:28.191 Shin alaƙarsa da Freemasons ta ceci shi daga zaman gidan yari? 20:28.191 --> 20:38.999 Don bin taken da jaridar Der Standard ta yi amfani da shi wajen kwatanta Freemasons: "Yan'uwa suna manne da juna"? 20:38.999 --> 20:45.656 4. Netherlands da Belgium: Lamarin Zandvoort 20:45.656 --> 20:51.953 An sanya wa "kungiyar batsa ta yara ta Zandvoort" suna ne daga sansanin shakatawa na bakin teku na Zandvoort a Netherlands, inda 20:51.953 --> 20:55.573 biyu daga cikin manyan masu laifi suka gudanar da shagon bidiyo. 20:55.573 --> 20:59.911 Mafi munin laifuka an aikata su ne ta wannan ƙungiyar masu cin zarafin yara. 20:59.911 --> 21:08.299 Da aka gano wannan lamari a shekarar 1998, an kwace daruruwan fina-finai da ke nuna ana yi wa yara da ma jarirai fyade. 21:08.299 --> 21:14.977 An gudanar da bukukuwan jima'i a kan jirgin ruwa na ɗaya daga cikin masu laifi, inda 'yan eliti suka halarta, kuma a lokacin 21:14.977 --> 21:21.909 ne aka ɗauki abin da ake kira bidiyon snuff, wanda ke nuna yara ana cin zarafi da azabtarwa har lahira a gaban kyamara. 21:21.909 --> 21:28.634 Daya daga cikin yaran da suka mutu sakamakon haka shi ne Manuel Schadwald mai shekaru 13, wanda aka sace shi daga Berlin 21:28.634 --> 21:32.899 aka tilasta masa yin batsa a gidan batsa na yara a Rotterdam. 21:32.899 --> 21:39.611 Kungiyar taimakon hakkin ɗan adam ta Belgium "Werkgroep Morkhoven" da wanda ya kafa ta kuma darakta, Marcel Vervloesem, 21:39.611 --> 21:43.222 sun taka muhimmiyar rawa wajen fallasa wannan shari'ar. 21:43.222 --> 21:48.471 An tura wa ƙungiyar bidiyo da ke nuna maza suna yin jima'i da yara. 21:48.471 --> 21:55.233 Sun isar da wannan bayanin ga 'yan sanda. Duk da haka, 'yan sandan Belgium ba su yi martani ba na tsawon shekaru biyar. 21:55.233 --> 22:02.808 A shekarar 1997, Ministan Shari'a ya sanar cewa babu wata ƙungiyar masu cin zarafin yara, kuma daga baya an gano cewa wani 22:02.808 --> 22:06.892 mutum a cikin bidiyon yana da alaƙa da 'yan siyasa na Belgium. 22:06.892 --> 22:13.327 Saboda rashin aikin 'yan sanda, Vervloesem ya gudanar da bincikensa da kansa kuma ya samu hulɗa da 22:13.327 --> 22:17.062 ɗaya daga cikin masu laifi ya kuma samu amincewarsa. 22:17.062 --> 22:20.948 Duk da haka, an kashe wannan mai laifi ba da jimawa ba bayan haka. 22:20.948 --> 22:26.594 Duk da haka, Vervloesem ya samu dubban fayiloli masu ɗauke da batsa, kuma a wasu lokuta 22:26.594 --> 22:29.675 abubuwan zalunci, yayin da aka kutsa gidansa. 22:29.675 --> 22:32.992 Sa'an nan ya mika su ga manema labarai da ofishin lauyan gwamnati. 22:32.992 --> 22:39.169 Duk da haka, CD-ROM guda bakwai da ke ɗauke da hujjoji, waɗanda Werkgroep Morkhoven ta tura wa Babban Lauyan 22:39.169 --> 22:43.759 Jama'a na Kotun a Antwerp, sun ɓace ba tare da wata shaida ba. 22:43.759 --> 22:49.757 Vervloesem ya kuma samu sama da takardu 3,000 da ke ɗauke da adireshin abokan ciniki da takardun biyan kuɗi, wanda ya 22:49.757 --> 22:56.628 bayyana a fili cewa ƙungiyar safarar batsa ta yara tana aiki a duk faɗin duniya, ciki har da Jamus, Amurka da Isra'ila. 22:56.628 --> 23:01.226 Duk da haka, binciken Vervloesem ya sanya shi kansa zama manufa ga tsarin shari'a. 23:01.226 --> 23:07.237 An zargi shi da cin zarafin yara – kuma aka yanke masa hukuncin shekaru da dama a gidan yari. 23:07.237 --> 23:15.042 Bayan ya shafe shekaru biyu a gidajen yari na Belgium, an saki shi a shekarar 2010 bisa waɗannan sharuɗɗa: 23:15.042 --> 23:23.096 1) An hana shi tuntuɓar manema labarai da ci gaba da magance shari'o'in masu cin zarafin yara. 23:23.096 --> 23:31.003 2) Ba a ba shi izinin halartar ayyukan da kungiyoyin da ke yaki da cin zarafin yara suka shirya, kuma ba a ba shi izinin tuntuɓar 23:31.003 --> 23:35.589 abokansa daga Werkgroep Morkhoven, waɗanda suka kasance suna ziyartarsa a gidan yari 23:35.589 --> 23:39.297 kowane mako a lokacin da yake cikin kurkuku. 23:39.297 --> 23:44.415 Shin ba abin mamaki ba ne cewa kotun shari'a, daga cikin dukkan hukumomi, ta kakaba irin waɗannan sharuɗɗa? 23:44.415 --> 23:48.864 Shin an yi ƙoƙarin dakatar da mai fallasa labarai da ba a so a nan? 23:48.864 --> 23:55.602 Kuma – shin kotuna suna da alaƙa da masu aikata laifuka lokacin da suka yi ƙoƙarin hana warware waɗannan shari'o'in? 23:55.602 --> 23:59.552 Amma kafofin watsa labarai sun kuma yi ƙoƙari sosai don lalata martabar Vervloesem da 23:59.552 --> 24:03.644 kuma nuna shi a matsayin mai cin zarafin yara. 24:03.644 --> 24:10.551 5. Faransa: Masu fafutuka Janett Seemann da Stan Maillaud sun ba da rahoto kan yadda alkalai na Faransa ke da hannu 24:10.551 --> 24:14.474 a shari'o'in cin zarafin yara da kisan kai da aka tsara. 24:14.474 --> 24:19.939 Mai fafutuka ta Jamus, Janett Seemann, ta riga ta yi kamfen a Jamus don yakar bacewar yara 24:19.939 --> 24:23.494 da dama cikin cibiyoyin masu cin zarafin yara. 24:23.494 --> 24:30.381 Don haka, ta ƙirƙiri saƙonnin bidiyo guda biyu, da sauran abubuwa: ɗaya ga Pope Benedict XVI na 24:30.381 --> 24:35.212 lokacin, ɗaya kuma ga tsohuwar Chansila Angela Merkel. 24:35.212 --> 24:41.666 Daga baya ta haɗa kai da Stan Maillaud, wani ɗan fafutuka na Faransa kuma tsohon jami'in 'yan sanda. 24:41.666 --> 24:46.399 A matsayin ƙungiya, sun yi bincike musamman kan shari'o'in cin zarafin yara da aka 24:46.399 --> 24:49.948 tsara, inda alƙalai na Faransa suka shiga ciki. 24:49.948 --> 24:54.903 Stan Maillaud ya bayyana cewa matakan shari'a da tsare-tsaren da ya yi bincike a kansu ba 24:54.903 --> 24:58.029 kawai ba su da doka ba ne, har ma laifi ne. 24:58.029 --> 25:05.864 A cewar Maillaud, ba a yanke waɗannan hukunci ba a sunan mutane, sai dai a sunan wata ƙarfin asiri mai laifi. 25:05.864 --> 25:12.112 Shi da Janett Seemann sun binciki wasu lamura a Faransa inda mambobin ma'aikatan shari'a, kamar 'yan sanda, 25:12.112 --> 25:19.688 lauyoyi, alkalai da masu gabatar da kara na gwamnati, suka yi haɗin gwiwa da wasu likitocin kwakwalwa da aka zaɓa. 25:19.688 --> 25:21.945 Haka nan irin wannan tsari koyaushe yana bayyana: 25:21.945 --> 25:27.956 Da zaran an ba da rahoton cin zarafin jima'i da uwaye suka yi wa 'ya'yansu, tsarin shari'a ya fara aiki nan take. 25:27.956 --> 25:33.302 Duk da haka, ba a yi hakan ba – kamar yadda ake tsammani – don kare yaran da aka zalunta da 25:33.302 --> 25:36.680 kuma gurfanar da masu aikata laifin gaban shari'a. 25:36.680 --> 25:42.919 A'a, akasin haka: an yi wa uwa da 'ya'yansu da aka zalunta tsoro ta hannun 'yan sanda da tsarin shari'a. 25:42.919 --> 25:51.001 Dangi masu kare su an gurfanar da su a gaban kotu ba bisa ka'ida ba, an daure su a kurkuku kuma an kai su asibitocin kwakwalwa. 25:51.001 --> 25:56.523 A lokuta da dama, uwa ba su iya yin komai ba don kare 'ya'yansu daga masu fyade. 25:56.523 --> 25:59.890 A wasu lokuta, har ma an kwace haƙƙinsu na kula da su. 25:59.890 --> 26:05.725 Shekaru da dama, sun kasance suna jurewa ba tare da ikon yin komai ba ganin 'ya'yansu suna hannun masu azabtar da su. 26:05.725 --> 26:10.531 A cikin hirarrakin da Stan Maillaud ya gudanar da su da mahaifiyoyin da abin ya shafa, sun ambaci sunayen 26:10.531 --> 26:15.874 mutanen da abin ya shafa kuma sun bayyana ayyukan haramtattu na jami'an shari'a da ke cikin shari'o'in. 26:15.874 --> 26:21.736 A cewar bayanan shaidu, waɗannan ma laifuka ne masu matuƙar tsanani, kamar ɗaukar bidiyo 26:21.736 --> 26:25.471 na kisan yara don samar da bidiyon kisan kai. 26:25.471 --> 26:32.325 Shaidu sun kuma ruwaito manyan taruka inda aka yi wa yara cin zarafi ko fyade ta hannun mutane da dama. 26:32.325 --> 26:41.080 Akwai kuma bayanan shaidu da ke nuna cewa tsohon shugaban Faransa da wasu ministoci da dama sun aikata cin zarafin yara. 26:41.080 --> 26:48.142 Kudurin Maillaud da Seemann ya sa aka mayar da hankali kan wadannan 'yan fafutuka biyu daga hukumomin shari'a da 'yan sanda. 26:48.142 --> 26:56.374 An bi su da 'yan sanda, an tsare su na ɗan lokaci bisa zargin da ba su da tushe, kuma an yi musu tambayoyi marasa ɗan'adam. 26:56.374 --> 27:01.178 An yi musu suka a kafofin watsa labarai, kuma a ƙarshe suka tsere zuwa Venezuela. 27:01.178 --> 27:08.069 A can, Interpol ta gano Stan Maillaud kuma aka mika shi Faransa, inda dole ya yi zaman gidan yari. 27:08.069 --> 27:11.565 Daga cikin sauran abubuwa, an zargi shi da sace yara. 27:11.565 --> 27:18.005 Gaskiyar ita ce Stan Maillaud ya taimaka wa wata uwa wadda ta rasa kulawar ɗanta, domin ta kawo yaron 27:18.005 --> 27:22.320 lafiya, domin mahaifinsa da wasu mutane suna azabtar da shi. 27:22.320 --> 27:30.308 A cewar bayanan shaidu, jami'in tuhuma da ya sa a daure Maillaud shi ne ɗaya daga cikin masu aikata cin zarafi. 27:30.308 --> 27:31.475 Sakamako na wucin gadi: 27:31.475 --> 27:37.565 Binciken da Seemann da Maillaud suka yi ya kuma nuna cewa waɗanda ke da alhaki a tsarin shari'a suna kare masu 27:37.565 --> 27:44.269 laifi kuma suna kai hari kai tsaye ga waɗanda abin ya shafa, danginsu da masu fafutuka kansu. 27:47.129 --> 27:54.247 6. Belgium: Shari'ar Marc Dutroux da rawar da alkalai na Belgium ke takawa 27:54.247 --> 28:00.803 Shari'ar Marc Dutroux watakila ita ce shari'ar sace yara, cin zarafin yara, azabtarwa, jima'i da 'yan 28:00.803 --> 28:04.846 uwa da kisan jarirai da aka fi sani da ita a Turai. 28:04.846 --> 28:07.358 Dutroux ya bayyana a kotu sau biyu. 28:07.358 --> 28:12.982 A shekarar 1989, an yanke masa hukuncin shekaru 13.5 a gidan yari saboda tuhumar cin zarafin jima'i guda 28:12.982 --> 28:16.790 biyar, amma bai ma yi shekara ɗaya cikin uku na hukuncin ba. 28:16.790 --> 28:23.764 Tuha a lokacin sake kama shi a shekarar 1996 ita ce cewa ya sace 'yan mata shida masu shekaru na yara da matasa, ya 28:23.764 --> 28:29.611 yi masu cin zarafin jima'i kuma ya kulle su kamar dabbobi a cikin kogo a ƙasa na ɗaya daga gidajensa. 28:29.611 --> 28:33.274 Hudu daga cikinsu sun mutu cikin azaba yayin da suke cikin kurkuku. 28:33.274 --> 28:40.831 Babban jayayya a shari'ar Dutroux ta ta'allaka ne kan tambayar ko shi ne mai aikata laifi shi kaɗai mai lalacewa ko kuma shi 28:40.831 --> 28:45.576 ma mai samar da yara ne ga wata babbar cibiyar maza masu iko. 28:45.576 --> 28:51.484 Wane hujjoji da shaidu suka nuna cewa Dutroux yana aiki a madadin wata cibiyar lauyoyi? 28:51.484 --> 28:54.046 1. Bayyanarsa ta kansa: 28:54.046 --> 29:01.283 A shekarar 2002, Dutroux ya ce a wata hira a gidan yari cewa hakika akwai wata cibiyar laifuka mai reshe da yawa. 29:01.283 --> 29:06.847 Ba wai kawai suna nan domin shi kadai ba, har ma suna nan domin wasu. 29:06.847 --> 29:10.032 2. Halin kuɗinsa: 29:10.032 --> 29:17.075 Dutroux, mara aikin yi mai karɓar tallafin jin kai, yana da gidaje biyar, kullum yana sayen hannun jari, kuma 29:17.075 --> 29:23.814 yana da asusun banki da dama inda aka ajiye manyan kuɗaɗe a daidai lokacin da aka sace 'yan matan. 29:23.814 --> 29:29.033 Da Dutroux ya yi cin zarafin yaran shi kaɗai, ba zai samu kudi daga hakan ba. 29:29.033 --> 29:31.809 3. Bayanan shaidu: 29:31.809 --> 29:38.798 Mai tsira Regina Louf ta kuma bayar da rahoto cewa Marc Dutroux bai aikata shi kaɗai ba, amma abokin laifinsa, 29:38.798 --> 29:45.680 ɗan kasuwar Brussels Michel Nihoul, ne ya shirya bukukuwan jima'i da yara da Dutroux ya samo. 29:45.680 --> 29:50.130 Michel Nihoul ya umarci Marc Dutroux ya kawo masa yara masu shekaru tsakanin goma sha biyu da goma sha 29:50.130 --> 29:53.054 huɗu don bukukuwan batsa da suka shafi yara, in ji ta. 29:53.054 --> 29:57.607 Dutroux kansa ya kuma bayyana cewa Nihoul yana samun kariya "daga matakin sama-sama". 29:57.607 --> 30:04.932 Mutumin yana da alaƙa da manyan mutane a Brussels, ciki har da abokan ciniki da yawa na jam'iyyun sadomasochism da suka dace. 30:04.932 --> 30:10.312 4. Bincike da alkalin bincike Jean-Marc Connerotte: 30:10.312 --> 30:13.939 Ya bi sawun shaidu da suka nuna wata cibiyar sadarwa. 30:13.939 --> 30:20.045 Ya kafa lambar waya inda 'yan ƙasa za su iya ba da bayanai ba tare da bayyana sunansu ba game da shari'ar Dutroux. 30:20.045 --> 30:23.658 Ambaliyar bayanai ta rushe kan masu bincike. 30:23.658 --> 30:29.512 Waɗannan sun haɗa da bayanai daga wasu matasa mata da suka yi iƙirari masu ban mamaki a rubuce: 30:29.512 --> 30:37.755 Sun san game da bukukuwan jima'i a farkon shekarun 1980 a manyan zagaye, inda ake azabtar da yara kuma ake kashe su. 30:37.755 --> 30:43.647 An kuma ga Nihoul da Dutroux a can. Har ma an ambaci Sarkin Belgium Albert II a matsayin 30:43.647 --> 30:47.926 baƙo a irin waɗannan "bikin" masu ban tsoro. 30:47.926 --> 30:49.402 Sakamako na wucin gadi: 30:49.402 --> 30:55.181 Zai kasance da matuƙar ma'ana a bi sahun shaidu da yawa da ke nuna wata cibiyar sadarwa. 30:55.181 --> 31:02.188 Sai dai, idan aka duba ayyukan hukumomin shari'a da tsaro, zai bayyana cewa an yi komai don hana binciken mayar 31:02.188 --> 31:09.125 da hankali kan wata cibiyar laifuka, domin a gabatar da Dutroux a matsayin mai laifi guda ɗaya: 31:09.125 --> 31:15.872 An ba da wasu jagorori da dama daga 'yan sanda amma ba a bi su ba kwata-kwata, ciki har da bayanan shaidu da faifan 31:15.872 --> 31:20.060 bidiyo da aka kwace a gidan Dutroux amma ba a tantance su ba. 31:20.060 --> 31:24.439 Sauran hujjoji an sace ko kuma suka ɓace kawai. 31:24.439 --> 31:27.130 An jinkirta fara shari'ar sosai. 31:27.130 --> 31:33.416 Ya ɗauki cikakkun shekaru bakwai da rabi kafin a gurfanar da Dutroux da wasu mutane uku a gaban kotu. 31:33.416 --> 31:38.824 A wannan lokacin, duk da haka, aƙalla shaidu 27 sun mutu a cikin yanayi mai ban mamaki. 31:38.824 --> 31:45.402 Yawancinsu sun so su shaida game da alaƙa da suka tabbatar da zargin cewa Marc Dutroux ba shi kaɗai ne ke aikata 31:45.402 --> 31:49.668 laifin ba, amma akwai wata cibiyar masu taimako a kusa da shi. 31:49.668 --> 31:57.672 An yi bincike kan yanayin da ya jawo mutuwar waɗannan shaidun 27 ba yadda ya kamata ba ko kuma ba a yi shi kwata-kwata. 31:57.672 --> 32:05.907 Mai tsira Regina Louf ta shaida kusan kisan mutane 60 kuma har ta iya ambaton sunayen mutane 35 daga cikin wadanda aka kashe. 32:05.907 --> 32:10.290 Haka kuma ta iya bayyana sunayen masu laifi, laifukan da wuraren da aka aikata laifukan a takamaimai. 32:10.290 --> 32:17.424 Bayan yin gwajin tunani, kwararru sun shaida cewa an yi mata mummunan cin zarafin jima'i a lokacin yarinta. 32:17.424 --> 32:23.486 Duk da haka, ba a bi sahun bayanan da suka bayar ba, kuma ofishin lauyan gwamnati na Belgium ya bayyana bayanan 32:23.486 --> 32:28.699 shaidu nasu a matsayin marasa gaskiya, yana ikirarin cewa su ne kawai ƙirƙirar tunaninsu. 32:28.699 --> 32:33.868 Sai mai gabatar da kara ya rufe fayil ɗin da ke ɗauke da bayanan shaidu. 32:33.868 --> 32:41.172 Alƙalin bincike Jean-Marc Connerotte, wanda yake nazarin shaidu da ke nuni ga wata cibiyar laifuka, an cire shi daga shari'ar. 32:41.172 --> 32:47.319 Ya yi nuna son rai saboda ya halarci taron agaji na 'yan mata biyu da aka kashe. 32:47.319 --> 32:52.625 Wannan hujja marar ƙarfi ta haifar da guguwar zanga-zanga a tsakanin al'ummar Belgium. 32:52.625 --> 32:57.226 Duk da haka, tsarin shari'a bai yi tasiri ba. 32:57.226 --> 33:02.648 Alƙalin bincike da ya gaji Connerotte, Jacques Langlois, shi ne ɗaya daga cikin manyan 33:02.648 --> 33:05.258 mutanen da suka murƙushe ka'idar cibiyar sadarwa. 33:05.258 --> 33:08.800 Ya dakatar da duk binciken da ake yi kan yiwuwar manyan masu shirya laifuka. 33:08.800 --> 33:16.239 Shekaru daga baya, an gano cewa Langlois bai haɗa bayanan shaidu sama da 600 (!) a cikin shari'ar ba. 33:16.239 --> 33:19.734 Dukkan bayanan shaidu game da cibiyar sadarwa an ɓoye su. 33:19.734 --> 33:23.982 Masu binciken da suka shafi wannan shari'ar an mayar da su a bazarar shekarar 1997. 33:23.982 --> 33:31.734 An rufe fayilolin da ke ɗauke da duk hujjojin da za a iya tabbatarwa, sunayen mutane da masu zargi a shekarar 1998. 33:31.734 --> 33:37.328 Daga baya, Ministan Shari'a Marc Verwilghen da Babban Lauyan Jama'a Michel Bourlet sun bayar da rahoton cewa 33:37.328 --> 33:43.361 sun yi kiran bincike sabo sau da yawa – amma ba tare da nasara ba, domin Langlois ya toshe binciken. 33:43.361 --> 33:48.955 Tare da Langlois, Ministan Shari'a Melchior Wathelet ma yana taka muhimmiyar rawa. 33:48.955 --> 33:54.300 Wathelet, wanda a cewar bayanan wadanda abin ya shafa shi kansa ya kasance mai shirya kuma mai halartar bukukuwan jima'i da yara, 33:54.300 --> 33:59.999 abin mamaki ya yi masa afuwa ga Dutroux a lokacin hukuncin gidan yari na farko bayan bai kai kashi ɗaya bisa uku na lokacin ba. 33:59.999 --> 34:04.986 Saboda haka, shi na da ɗan alhaki ga gaskiyar cewa Dutroux ya sami damar sacewa, yi wa 'yan mata 34:04.986 --> 34:08.513 matasa fyade da kashe su da yawa bayan an saki shi. 34:08.513 --> 34:18.554 Duk da haka, mummunan hukuncin yafewa Dutroux bai yi wa aikin Wathelet illa ba – a akasin haka: 34:18.554 --> 34:29.991 Ya kasance alkalin Kotun Shari'a ta Turai daga 1995 zuwa 2003 kuma Babban Lauyan Turai daga 2012 zuwa 2018. 34:29.991 --> 34:37.361 Karshe: Harsashin ƙarfi a cikin kotun shari'a da hukumomin bincike sun yi duk mai yiwuwa don tabbatar da cewa ba a warware 34:37.361 --> 34:45.743 shari'ar Dutroux ba, wanda ke nuna cewa su kansu sun kasance cikin waɗannan cibiyoyin ko aƙalla an matsa musu lamba daga gare su. 34:45.743 --> 34:51.140 An tabbatar da shiga ta kotun shari'a ta shaida ta Regina Louf, wadda ta tsira. 34:51.140 --> 34:56.954 Daga baya ta gane mahalartan bukukuwan jima'i na masu cin zarafin yara a hotunan jaridu da talabijin, 34:56.954 --> 35:00.690 inda dole ta yi wa "abokan cinikinta" hidima da gangan. 35:00.690 --> 35:06.887 A cewar bayanan da suka bayar, dukkansu an san su a matsayin manyan mutane masu daraja a cikin al'umma, ciki 35:06.887 --> 35:12.955 har da 'yan siyasa, manajoji, masana'antun masana'antu, har ma da lauyoyi da jami'an shari'a. 35:12.955 --> 35:18.396 A cikin ɗaya daga cikin alkalai masu bincike da ta shaida a talabijin game da shari'ar Dutroux, har ta gane ɗaya 35:18.396 --> 35:24.580 daga cikin masu taimakawa a kisan ibada na ɗaya daga cikin jariranta, wanda ta haifa yayin da take cikin kurkuku. 35:24.580 --> 35:30.621 Bayan wannan bayanin tuhuma da Regina Louf ta yi, an ayyana ta ba ta da cikakken hankali kuma an 35:30.621 --> 35:34.267 soke dukkan shari'ar da ake yi wa Michel Nihoul. 35:34.267 --> 35:38.260 Wannan an yi shi ne ta hannun wannan magistar bincike daidai wadda, a cewar bayaninta, 35:38.260 --> 35:41.327 ita ce ɗaya daga cikin masu kisan jaririnta. 35:41.327 --> 35:47.863 7. Switzerland: Shari'ar Nathalie da kuma shiga hannun jami'an shari'a na Switzerland a cin 35:47.863 --> 35:52.659 zarafin yara, safarar mutane da hadayar shaiɗan 35:52.659 --> 35:57.015 Shari'ar Nathalie ta kasance batun tattaunawa a kafofin watsa labarai na Switzerland tsawon shekaru da dama. 35:57.015 --> 36:03.458 Blick.ch, misali, ta ruwaito a shekarar 2020 game da cin zarafin jima'i da na ibadar shaiɗan da 36:03.458 --> 36:07.551 mahaifinta ya yi wa wata yarinya mai shekaru 8. 36:07.551 --> 36:15.834 Yarinyar kanta ta kuma bayyana cewa mahaifinta ya miƙa ta ga wasu masu aikata laifi. 36:15.834 --> 36:23.018 Ta kuma shaida cin zarafi da azabar danyen zalunci da aka yi wa wasu yara da manya. 36:23.018 --> 36:29.727 Ta shaida safarar mutane, sassan jiki da adrenochrome kuma ta shaida hadayar shaiɗan. 36:29.727 --> 36:36.737 Wannan ya faru a wuraren ibada da kuma cikin tsarin ramuka na karkashin ƙasa da aka ɓoye, da sauran wurare. 36:36.737 --> 36:42.231 Bayanan da Nathalie ta bayar sun yi daidai da tarin sauran bayanai da Kla.TV ta yi magana a kansu a 36:42.231 --> 36:47.620 cikin fina-finan dokumentari na Blood Sects I da II. 36:47.620 --> 36:53.093 A cikin lamari na Nathalie ma, akwai hujjoji bayyanannu na haɗin gwiwa tsakanin shari'a da cibiyar masu aikata laifi. 36:53.093 --> 36:59.555 Nathalie har ta gano wasu mutane daga tsarin shari'ar Switzerland a matsayin masu laifi. 36:59.555 --> 37:07.015 A yayin shari'ar farko ta laifi da ake yi wa mahaifinta, ta gane wasu masu cin zarafi, wani babban alkalin 37:07.015 --> 37:14.666 kotu, masu gabatar da kara guda biyu da wasu 'yan sanda da suka yi bincike a gidan Nathalie. 37:14.666 --> 37:20.301 A yayin shari'ar, Nathalie ta maimaita cewa tuni ta san wadannan mutane. 37:20.301 --> 37:27.576 Sun halarci bukukuwan cin zarafi da kisan da mahaifinsu ya kai su. 37:27.576 --> 37:35.041 Alal misali, an gano tsohon shugaban kariyar yara da manya (KES) a yankin hidimomin zamantakewa na gida na Nathalie, an 37:35.041 --> 37:39.881 kuma bayyana shi a matsayin mai cin zarafi da mai kisan yara. 37:39.881 --> 37:50.377 Nathalie ta ba da rahoton cewa ta ga wannan jagorar KES tana kawo jarirai zuwa tarurruka kuma ita ce ke da hannu a kashe jariran. 37:50.377 --> 37:58.316 KESB, wadda ke sa ido kan KES, ta naɗa wa Nathalie lauya na yara, wanda shi ma ya bayyana Nathalie a matsayin mai laifi. 37:58.316 --> 38:02.961 Wannan lauya bai taɓa yin magana da Nathalie ko mahaifiyarta ba. 38:02.961 --> 38:07.776 Ba ta yi mu'amala ta kai tsaye da Nathalie ba, amma ta fi yin mu'amala da lauya na 38:07.776 --> 38:11.499 mahaifinta, wanda Nathalie ke zarginsa da cin zarafi. 38:11.499 --> 38:18.184 Ta yi masa shawara kan yadda za a fi dacewa a rushe martabar Nathalie ta hanyar ra'ayoyin ƙwararru. 38:18.184 --> 38:23.544 A bayyane tana ƙoƙarin soke haƙƙin kulawar mahaifiyar Nathalie. 38:23.544 --> 38:28.380 Wannan aikin ana kiran sa a doka cin amanar abokin ciniki. 38:28.380 --> 38:30.989 An sanar da KESB game da waɗannan abubuwan. 38:30.989 --> 38:35.536 Ƙungiyar edita tana da shaida ta rubuce game da wannan. 38:37.111 --> 38:41.888 Babban alkalin da ke da alhakin shari'ar ya yi tasiri ga lauyan mahaifiyar Nathalie. 38:41.888 --> 38:46.560 Ya kamata ya shawo kanta ta janye ƙarar da ta shigar kan mahaifin Nathalie. 38:46.560 --> 38:55.566 Lauyan mahaifiyar Nathalie ya shigar da roƙon a cire wannan babban alkalin daga shari'ar, amma har yanzu ba a amince da roƙon ba. 38:55.566 --> 39:00.822 KESB ba kawai ta naɗa wa Nathalie lauya wanda, a cewar Nathalie, shi ne ɗaya daga cikin masu laifi. 39:00.822 --> 39:09.523 Ta kuma umarci yarinyar ta yi magani tare da wani babban likitan kwakwalwa, wanda shi ma ya gane Nathalie a matsayin mai laifi. 39:09.523 --> 39:12.799 Ba za a iya kiran wannan haɗari ba yanzu. 39:12.799 --> 39:18.789 Nathalie ta ruwaito cewa likitan kwakwalwa ya yi mata bugun wutar lantarki a lokacin hirarraki. 39:18.789 --> 39:23.989 Wannan ya dame ta sosai. Nathalie ta kasance ita kaɗai a lokacin hirarrakin. 39:23.989 --> 39:27.942 Ba a ba mahaifiyarta izinin kasancewa a wurin yayin tambayoyi. 39:27.942 --> 39:35.920 Nathalie ta maimaita cewa hukumomi da mutanen da ke cikin binciken shari'arta suna cikin zagayen masu laifi. 39:35.920 --> 39:43.756 A yayin ci gaba da shari'ar, ya bayyana sau da yawa cewa mutanen da aka ambata ba su da sha'awar bincike 39:43.756 --> 39:47.973 mara son rai, sai dai suna son ɓoye shari'ar Nathalie. 39:47.973 --> 39:53.882 Abin kunya ne matuƙa kuma abin damuwa ne cewa ba ubansa ba ne, wanda ake zarginsa da cin zarafi, sai 39:53.882 --> 40:00.218 mahaifiyar Nathalie, wadda ba ta da wata laifi kwata-kwata, aka tsare ta a tsanaki na yini ɗaya. 40:00.218 --> 40:05.555 A can an tsare ta na tsawon sa'o'i ashirin da huɗu a cikin ƙaramar ɗakin tsare mai sanyi tare da bandaki na waje 40:05.555 --> 40:11.307 mai ƙamshi mara daɗi, tana sanye da tufafi masu siriri kawai, kuma an saki ta ne bayan sa'o'i na tambayoyi. 40:11.307 --> 40:17.829 Wannan mataki da hukumar tuhuma ta ɗauka za a iya kwatanta shi ne kawai a matsayin dabarar "yakin gajiyawa" da aka 40:17.829 --> 40:23.651 tsara don gajiyar da ita da kuma rushe mata kwarin gwiwa. 40:23.651 --> 40:30.282 Balz Bruder, wani mai binciken rahoto mai tsauri a jaridar Solothurner Zeitung, ya yi ƙarfin hali ya gano duk waɗannan 40:30.282 --> 40:38.161 alaƙa tsakanin KESB, ofishin lauyan gwamnati da likitocin ilimin halayyar yara da matasa, ya kuma bayyana su a cikin labaransa. 40:38.161 --> 40:45.507 Wannan babban ɗan jarida na Solothurner Zeitung, wanda ya rubuta game da shari'ar Nathalie, an same shi matacce cikin 40:45.507 --> 40:50.062 tafkin jini bayan wallafa rahotannin jaridarsa masu suka. 40:50.062 --> 40:54.914 Ba a taɓa bayyana ainihin yanayin da ya kewaye mamacin mutumin da ke da sadaukarwa a aikinsa na 40:54.914 --> 40:58.485 ɗan jarida, wanda shekarunsa suka kai 53 kawai ba. 40:58.485 --> 41:04.630 Wannan yana tunasar da shari'ar Dutroux, inda aka kawar da shaidu 27 da suka so su yi 41:04.630 --> 41:08.603 shaida game da waɗannan alaƙa cikin ban mamaki. 41:08.603 --> 41:14.334 Don hana wannan sake faruwa a lamari na Natalie da sauran lamura, da kuma tabbatar da cewa ba za a iya ɓoye 41:14.334 --> 41:20.595 laifukan ba, waɗanda abin ya shafa da masu ba da shaida sun riga sun ɗauki matakan kariya. 41:20.595 --> 41:28.672 Idan wani abu ya faru da su, sun riga sun yi kwafi da yawa na dukkan hujjoji kuma sun adana su a wurare masu 41:28.672 --> 41:37.979 tsaro a duk faɗin duniya – har sai kotu mai nuna rashin nuna son rai ta ɗauki waɗannan laifuka. 41:37.979 --> 41:43.480 Karshe: Misalan da aka fayyace a cikin wannan shirin su ne kawai saman kankara. 41:43.480 --> 41:47.946 A cewar bayanan shaidu, wahalhalun da waɗanda abin ya shafa ke sha da zaluncin masu 41:47.946 --> 41:51.047 azabtar da su sun bayyana kamar ba su da iyaka. 41:51.047 --> 41:56.679 Idan waɗanda abin ya shafa suka yi nasarar tserewa daga waɗannan zagaye kuma suka ba da rahoton waɗannan laifuka, sau da yawa suna 41:56.679 --> 42:00.726 tsinci kansu cikin wani yanayi – wanda yake musu matuƙar tashin hankali – inda tsarin shari'a ke kare 42:00.726 --> 42:03.794 masu laifi kuma ke kai hari kan waɗanda abin ya shafa. 42:03.794 --> 42:11.778 A kusan kowane ɗayan waɗannan lamura, akwai hujjoji bayyanannu cewa wannan wata babbar cibiyar labarai ce ta 42:11.778 --> 42:16.322 ƙetare-ƙasa wadda ta haɗa manyan mambobin al'ummarmu. 42:16.322 --> 42:21.958 Haka kuma, abu ɗaya da ke haɗa kusan duk shari'o'in shi ne an ɗauki bidiyo na waɗannan manyan jami'ai 42:21.958 --> 42:25.271 da masu yanke shawara yayin da suke cin zarafin yara. 42:25.271 --> 42:30.105 Wannan yana sa su zama masu rauni ga fitar da su a matsayin barazana kuma yana sa su bi umarnin ƙungiyoyin da ke 42:30.105 --> 42:35.609 sarrafa waɗannan cibiyoyin, yana ba su damar yin tasiri kan yanke shawarar siyasa da na shari'a domin amfaninsu. 42:35.609 --> 42:40.488 Wannan kuma yana bayyana dalilin da ya sa ake kwace nan take duk kayan batsa na yara da 42:40.488 --> 42:43.462 aka gano su ta hannun ƙungiyoyin musamman. 42:43.462 --> 42:48.398 Ba a bayyana kowanne daga cikin hujjojin ba ga jama'a, amma ana riƙe su ƙarƙashin makulli da maɓalli. 42:48.398 --> 42:54.257 Ana iya ɗauka cewa wannan ɗaya ne daga cikin dalilan bankarotsin doka da Ivo Sasek ya bayyana 42:54.257 --> 42:58.100 dalla-dalla a cikin jawabin sa a taron AZK na 19. 42:58.100 --> 43:04.903 Tunda wasu muhimman bangarori na siyasa da na shari'a suna cikin matsewar wannan cibiyar, ya zama matuƙar muhimmanci a dawo da 43:04.903 --> 43:09.546 kafofin watsa labarai a matsayin jiha ta huɗu, wadda ita ma wannan tsarin cin hanci da 43:09.546 --> 43:12.940 rashawa ya mamaye kusan gaba ɗaya har zuwa yanzu. 43:12.940 --> 43:20.115 Shi ya sa muke roƙonku: Ku raba wannan shirin ku kuma ku zama ɓangare na cibiyar sadarwa ta Kla.TV, domin a haskaka 43:20.115 --> 43:27.841 waɗannan munanan laifukan shari'a kuma a ƙara tsananta bincike kan waɗannan masu laifi a gaban jama'a masu kulawa. 43:27.841 --> 43:33.974 Dukkanin shari'o'in da aka ambata suna nuna cewa da wuri ko daga baya ba za mu da wani zaɓi sai mu koma ga hanyoyin 43:33.974 --> 43:41.208 dimokuradiyya na doka domin ba wa hukumomin shari'a marasa son rai iko su magance irin waɗannan shari'o'in masu tsanani. 43:41.208 --> 43:46.085 Duk da haka, wannan takardar ba a nufa ta ba don ta ba da tunanin cewa duk jami'an 'yan sanda, alkalai da 43:46.085 --> 43:49.556 ma'aikatan shari'a suna da hannu a cikin waɗannan laifuka. 43:49.556 --> 43:56.335 Da yawa daga cikinku kuna gudanar da muhimman ayyukanku da zuciya ɗaya kuma kuna da gaske wajen sadaukarwa ga adalci. 43:56.335 --> 44:01.124 Don haka muna so mu yi kira gare ku musamman, waɗanda kuke hidima wa al'umma da gaske: 44:01.124 --> 44:06.443 Kada ku ji tsoron bincika da kanku waɗannan munanan ƙetare iyaka a cikin jerin ku, ku fallasa 44:06.443 --> 44:09.877 su kuma ku yi yaƙi da su ba tare da sassauci ba. 44:09.877 --> 44:13.791 Sai ta wannan hanya kaɗai ne za a iya hana ƙasar mu mai tsarin mulki da kuma 44:13.791 --> 44:17.183 dimokuradiyyarmu ci gaba da raunana da lalacewa sosai. 44:17.183 --> 44:21.591 Ka karɓi wannan aiki ne don tabbatar da adalci! 44:21.591 --> 44:30.042 Ku haɗu da juna, ku nuna jarumta, ku fito fili, ku kawo ƙarshen wannan cin zarafin iko gaba ɗaya!