WEBVTT 00:00.429 --> 00:06.152 Tlaleho ea pele mantsiboeeng ana e lokela ho hlaha maqepheng ohle a pele a mekhatlo ea litaba lefatšeng ka bophara. 00:06.152 --> 00:11.360 Liente tsa Covid li hlalositsoe e le libetsa tsa timetso e kholo ke moprofesa e moholo oa molao. 00:11.360 --> 00:18.961 Tsena ke litaba tse makatsang. Ngaka Francis Boyle, moprofesa oa Harvard le moqapi oa molao oa 1989 o khahlanong le bokhukhuni 00:18.961 --> 00:25.778 mabapi le libetsa tsa baeloji o saennoeng ke Bush, o entse polelo e hlapantseng a hlalosa liente tsa Covid-19 tsa 00:25.778 --> 00:30.730 mRNA e le libetsa tsa baeloji le libetsa tsa timetso e kholo. 00:30.730 --> 00:38.549 Ngaka Joseph Sansone e bile eena oa pele ho tlaleha ka sena. Boipolelo ka hloohong ba Ngaka Boyle, bo kenyelelitsoeng e le 00:38.549 --> 00:45.279 karolo ea kopo ea tšohanyetso Florida, bo pheha kgang ea hore kabo ea liente tsa Covid-19 e tlola melao e 00:45.279 --> 00:52.700 'maloa, ho kenyeletsoa Molao oa Libetsa tsa Baeloji oa US le melao ea libetsa le lithunya ea Florida. 00:52.700 --> 00:59.748 Boipiletso bona, bo lebisitsoeng ka kotloloho ho 'Musisi Ron DeSantis le 'Muelli-Kakaretso Ashley Moody, bo kopa hore kabo 00:59.748 --> 01:08.540 ea liente tsa Covid e emisetsoe hang-hang Florida, hape bo batla hore setoko sefe kapa sefe se setseng sa liente tsena se huloe. 01:08.540 --> 01:14.295 Ho ya ka Ngaka Sansone, kopo ya pele e potlakileng ya ts'ebetso ya taelo ya tlamo e ile ya kenngwa 01:14.295 --> 01:18.142 Lekgotleng le Phahameng la Florida ka la 3 Hlakubele 2024. 01:18.142 --> 01:23.332 Hamorao, ka la 20 Hlakubele, nyeoe e ile ya fetisediwa Lekgotleng la Silkwood Court, Seterekeng sa Leon. Mme kamorao 01:23.332 --> 01:28.475 hore Lekgotla la Silkwood Court le hlakole nyeoe ka la 9 Mmesa, e ile ya ya Lekgotleng la Boipiletso. 01:28.475 --> 01:35.551 Boipiletso bo kentsoe ka Letsatsi la Sehopotso, ka la 27 Mots'eanong 2024. Ngaka Boyle, e mong oa litsebi tse ka sehloohong 01:35.551 --> 01:42.860 tsa molao lefatšeng ka bophara mabapi le libetsa tsa baeloji, o matlafalitse nyeoe ena haholo ka polelo ea hae e hlapantseng. 01:42.860 --> 01:49.332 Nyeoe ena e se e na le bopaki bo bongata bo fumanehang polelong ea qoso, ho kenyeletsa le lipolelo tse hlapantseng tse 01:49.332 --> 01:56.026 tsoang ho moeletsi oa tsa molao oa bongaka le mohlahlobi oa biotech Karen Kingston le Ngaka Anahme Haidja. 01:56.026 --> 02:03.718 Ho ya ka Ngaka Sansone, polelo ya qoso e pheha kgang ya hore kabo ya meento ena e tlola melao e mmalwa ka nako e le nngwe. 02:03.718 --> 02:09.293 Ka tlase, re tla bala feela lintlha tsa bohlokoahali: - Molao oa Libetsa tsa Baeloji - Tlōlo ea molao ea 'muso oa kopanelo ea 02:09.293 --> 02:14.779 bohlōka-naha bo boholo - Bokhukhuni ba kahare ho naha - Polao le Polao ea Morabe - Bomenemene tlas'a Molao oa Lithethefatsi 02:14.779 --> 02:21.040 le Litlolo tsa 'Mele oa Florida - Ho thusa le ho khothaletsa kamorao ho ketso le Molao oa Florida oa Tumello ea Bongaka. 02:21.040 --> 02:30.030 Setaetemente se saennweng ke Ngaka Boyle se bolela, ho ya ka 28 U.S.C. 1746: "Nna, Francis A. Boyle, ke tiisa tlasa kotlo ya 02:30.030 --> 02:39.240 ho hlapanya ka leshano hore dipolelo tse fumanehang mona ke tsa nnete ebile di nepahetse ho ya ka tsebo le tumelo ya ka." 02:39.240 --> 02:46.183 Ebe o thathamisa mangolo a hae a thuto: Moprofesa wa Molao wa Matjhaba Kolecheng ya Molao ya Univesithi ya Illinois, lengolo la 02:46.183 --> 02:52.634 A.B. la Saense ya Dipolotiki ho tswa Univesithing ya Chicago ka 1971, lengolo la J.D. ka tlotla e phahameng (magna cum 02:52.634 --> 03:00.198 laude) ho tswa Sekolong sa Molao sa Harvard, le lengolo la Ph.D. la Saense ya Dipolotiki ho tswa Univesithing ya Harvard. 03:00.198 --> 03:05.627 O re: Ke eletsitse dikomiti tse ngata tsa matjhaba makaleng a ditokelo tsa botho, ditlolo tsa molao tsa ntwa le 03:05.627 --> 03:09.280 polao ya morabe, pholisi ya nyutlelie le dibetsa tsa baeloji. 03:09.280 --> 03:16.131 Ka 1985, ke ile ka ipiletsa phatlalatsa hore ho kenngwe tshebetsong Tumellano ya Dibetsa tsa Bophelo United States, 03:16.131 --> 03:23.939 mme ka qapa molao o tsamaelanang le yona, o tsejwang e le Molao wa 1989 wa ho Lwantsha Bokhukhuni ka Dibetsa tsa Bophelo. 03:23.939 --> 03:30.572 Li ile tsa amoheloa ka ntsoe-leng ke matlo ka bobeli a Lekhotla la Ketsamolao la US mme tsa saenoa ke Mopresidente George Bush ka 03:30.572 --> 03:34.789 tumello ea Lefapha la Toka la United States. Ka har'a eona, o bua ka buka ea hae e 03:34.789 --> 03:38.216 mabapi le ntoa ea likokoana-hloko le bokhukhuni. 03:38.216 --> 03:45.717 O bolela: Ke maikutlo a ka a setsebi hore liente tsa li-nanoparticle tsa Covid-19 kapa liente tsa li-nanoparticle tsa 03:45.717 --> 03:53.409 mRNA kapa liente tsa Covid-19 li fihlella ka botlalo litekanyetso tsa libetsa tsa baeloji le libetsa tsa timetso e kholo 03:53.409 --> 03:57.600 tlas'a Biological Weapons 18, USC 175 Weapons and Firearms. 03:57.600 --> 04:03.439 The Getaway Pundit e se e tlalehile hore Lekgotla le Phahameng la Florida le amohetse kopo ya Mmusi Ron DeSantis 04:03.439 --> 04:09.404 ya ho bitsa lekgotla le leholo la baahlodi ho etsa dipatlisiso ka bahlahisi ba meento ya Covid-19. 04:09.404 --> 04:16.241 Taba ena e makatsang e latela kahlolo ea bohlokoa ea Lekhotla la Boipiletso la Potoloho ea bo-9, le entseng kahlolo 04:16.241 --> 04:23.520 bekeng e fetileng hore ente ea Covid-19 ea mRNA ha se ente ho latela litlhaloso tse tloaelehileng tsa bongaka. 04:23.520 --> 04:30.001 Ha ho pelaelo hore ntho e phatlohetse. Mme batho ba bangata le ho feta ba se ba qala ho bitsa liente tsena ka seo li leng 04:30.001 --> 04:37.340 sona kannete – libetsa tsa baeloji. Mme, ho latela Ngaka Francis Boyle, ke libetsa tsa timetso e akaretsang. 04:39.243 --> 04:45.795 Nka kopa ho o botsa ka qeto ya Lekgotla la Boipiletso la Potoloho ya Borobong: Batho ba ka etsang hona 04:45.795 --> 04:51.936 jwale, Ngaka Martin? Ke utlwile maikutlo a bontshang hore jwale batho ba ka kgona ho qosa. 04:51.936 --> 04:55.775 Ke bolela hore, o ka fihla hole hakae ka seo? 04:55.775 --> 05:00.920 Ngaka David Martin: E, kahoo ha re hlaloseng hore re bua ka tšebetso ea molao, eseng ka khopolo-taba. 05:00.920 --> 05:07.420 Lekgotla la Boipiletso la Ninth Circuit, ka tekanyo, le kgutliselitse nyeoe makgotleng a tlase, le bolela 05:07.420 --> 05:14.600 hore matitjhere a Setereke sa Dikolo se Kopaneng sa Los Angeles a ka hlile a phephetsa taelo ya ho enta. 05:14.600 --> 05:22.050 Eo ke puo ea tekheniki ea molao. Maikutlo, ao ha e le hantle e leng karolo ea kahlolo e etelletseng pele, 'me ke lona phapang ea 05:22.050 --> 05:29.093 bohlokoa eo ke batlang ho e hlakisa, a hlakisa ka ho hlaka hore Lekhotla la Boipiletso la Potoloho ea Borobong le ahlotse 05:29.093 --> 05:32.349 hore Jacobson e ne e sebelisitsoe hampe ntlheng ena e itseng. 05:32.349 --> 05:38.951 Mme seo se bolela hore, ka lekgetlo la pele, khopolo e itshetlehileng ya hore taelo ya ente e sebeletsa bophelo bo 05:38.951 --> 05:42.433 botle ba setjhaba e pshatlehisitswe ke lekgotla la boipiletso. 05:42.433 --> 05:49.367 Ena ke nako ya bohlokwa haholo, hobane ho tloha jwale re ka etsa dipolelo tse tsheheditsweng ke molao tsa hore 05:49.367 --> 05:53.524 baetsi ba thepa ena ya ente ba thetsa setjhaba ka boomo. 05:53.524 --> 05:58.260 Dihlahiswa tsena di ngotswe hampe mme ha di ka ke tsa bitswa mekento. 05:58.260 --> 06:04.767 Ka tsela, sena ke tlolo ea Molao oa Khomishene ea Khoebo ea Federale ea US le tlolo ea Molao oa Mekhoa e Qhekellang ea 06:04.767 --> 06:11.740 Bongaka, e leng melao e teng le naheng e 'ngoe le e 'ngoe e tsoetseng pele e nang le litekanyetso tse tiileng tsa molao. 06:11.740 --> 06:15.700 Litaba tse monate ke hore re khonne ho phunya lesira lena. 06:15.700 --> 06:22.124 Empa sa bohlokoa le ho feta, mme ena ke ntlha ya bohlokwa ka ho fetisisa, Lekgotla la Boipiletso la Ninth 06:22.124 --> 06:28.606 Circuit le boletse ka ho hlaka hore ditumellano tsa Jacobson ha di na ho amoheleha tlasa pono ena. 06:28.606 --> 06:37.243 Sephetho se seng ke hore joale re na le menyetla ea molao eo re neng re e hloka ho phunyeletsa tšireletso ea boikarabello 06:37.243 --> 06:46.440 ea bahlahisi ba liente le batho ba kang bahiri, lifaramasiti, lingaka, baoki le lipetlele ba hlileng ba kentelang batho. 06:46.440 --> 06:52.075 Ka lekgetlo la pele, jwale re na le monyetla wa ho bolela hore Lekgotla la Boipiletso la Potoloho ya Borobong le ahlotse 06:52.075 --> 06:58.062 hore Jacobson e ne e sebedisitswe ka phoso. Hore ha e a ka ya emisa tshwaetso mme ha e a ka ya thibela phetisetso. 06:58.062 --> 07:03.950 Ka hona sechaba se ile sa thetswa ka boomo, e leng tlolo ya molao. Mme ho ya ka Molao wa Botlokotsebe, 07:03.950 --> 07:07.296 Maria, ditshireletso tsohle tsa boikarabelo di tlositswe. 07:07.296 --> 07:13.920 Pfizer le Moderna ba ikarabella ka lichelete le ka botlokotsebe ka ho thetsa sechaba. 07:13.920 --> 07:19.981 Ka mokhoa o makatsang, mecha ea phatlalatso e ka har'a leqeleng e tsebahalang le karolo ea seo ho thoeng ke mokhatlo oa 07:19.981 --> 07:25.500 tokoloho ea tsa bongaka ba ikemiselitse ho tsoela pele ho bolela hore ntho ena ka tsela e itseng ke ente. 07:25.500 --> 07:34.186 Kahoo, ha re qaleng ka lintlha tse hlakileng. Pele ho tsohle, ka Mmesa 2020, Pfizer, BioNTech le Moderna kaofela li boletse 07:34.186 --> 07:43.000 ka ho hlaka li-filings tsa tsona tsa SEC hore mRNA ke, 'me ke qotsa, "kalafo ea liphatsa tsa lefutso e ntseng e lekoa". 07:43.000 --> 07:50.625 Sena se bonahala ka ho otloloha litokomaneng tsa Securities and Exchange Commission. Hase maikutlo a Dr. Dave Martin. 07:50.625 --> 07:57.252 Le eo ha se maikutlo a motho e mong. Ho hlakile seo ba se buileng. Seo se bolela hore ha ba ne ba phahamisa 07:57.252 --> 08:04.350 ente, ha e le hantle ba ne ba sa phahamise ente, empa kalafo ea liphatsa tsa lefutso e ntseng e le tekong. 08:04.350 --> 08:10.955 Mme ba ba file mabitso a fosahetseng ka boomo ho thetsa setjhaba hore se a amohele. Kahoo, 08:10.955 --> 08:14.624 a re hlaloseng hantle, ena ke tlolo ya molao. 08:14.624 --> 08:23.224 Ruri ona ke bokhukhuni ba ka hare ho naha, bo sebedisetswang ho qobella batho ho nka ntho eo ba neng ba ke ke ba e nka. 08:23.224 --> 08:31.710 Eo ke tlhaloso ea bokhukhuni ba lehae. Mme ke sona hantle seo e leng sona. Joalokaha u tseba, Maria, ke 'nile ka bua khafetsa 08:31.710 --> 08:39.245 hore ena ke sebetsa sa baeloji hobane Rolf Baric o boletse kopanong ea DARPA-MAITA ka 2005 hore likaroloana tsa 08:39.245 --> 08:47.180 coronavirus tse entsoeng, 'me ke qotsa ho tsoa ho CV ea hae mona, ke theknoloji e nolofatsang lihlomo tsa baeloji. 08:47.180 --> 08:53.097 Maria, ha ke tsebe hore na o na le bothata le tšebeliso e tloaelehileng Australia, empa theknoloji e 08:53.097 --> 08:59.100 nolofalletsang ntoa ea likokoana-hloko ho 'na e utloahala eka ke sebetsa sa likokoana-hloko. 08:59.100 --> 09:08.046 Mme jwale ho bonahala hore ha o sheba eseng feela kahlolo ya lekgotla la ditsheko, empa hape le tlhaloso ya 7 CFR Karolo ya 09:08.046 --> 09:16.846 331 bakeng sa dibaktheria le ditshefu tse kgethilweng, ke hore, lenane la dibetsa tsa baeloji, ho bonahala hore protheine 09:16.846 --> 09:25.730 ya spike e amanang le phetolo e nngwe le e nngwe ya coronavirus ha e le hantle e ngotswe e le sebetsa sa baeloji. 09:25.730 --> 09:32.746 Eo ke tlhaloso ea kahlolo. Kahoo ha e tsose masole a 'mele ho hang. 09:32.746 --> 09:39.996 Enke e fuoang batho lefatšeng ka bophara, ebang ke ea Moderna kapa ea Pfizer, e etsa hore 09:39.996 --> 09:44.659 'mele oa motho o hlahise chefo e thathamisitsoeng. 09:44.659 --> 09:53.203 Mme ka mora moo o tshepa hore o na le sesole sa mmele se matla, kamora ho laela mmele wa hao hore o hlahise sebetsa sa baeloji, 09:53.203 --> 10:01.106 moo ho neng ho lebelletswe hore mmele o be le boitshireletso kgahlanong le eng kapa eng eo o laetsweng ho e etsa. 10:01.106 --> 10:10.007 Mme ke mona moo tlhaloso ya Aron Ceres e fosahetseng ka ho feletseng. Hobane ho fapana le dintho tse ding tseo a buang ka 10:10.007 --> 10:16.701 tsona mabapi le meento, tabeng ena e itseng, mokento ke taelo ya ho hlahisa chefo, eseng ya 10:16.701 --> 10:20.330 ho tsosa karabelo ya mmele ya ho itwanela mafu. 10:20.330 --> 10:25.999 Mme ke yona phapang e poteletseng eo Lekgotla la Borobong la Boipiletso, ka maikutlo a lona a 10:25.999 --> 10:30.790 bongata, le e lemotseng ka nepo, ho ya ka pono ya ka.