WEBVTT 00:00.429 --> 00:05.586 Ingxelo yokuqala yale ngokuhlwa kufuneka ivele kuzo zonke iiphepha zangaphambili zamajelo eendaba kwihlabathi 00:05.586 --> 00:11.360 jikelele. Izitofu zeCovid ziye zahlulwa njengezixhobo zentshabalaliso enkulu ngunjingalwazi ophezulu wezomthetho. 00:11.360 --> 00:19.141 Oku kuyamangalisa. UGqr. Francis Boyle, unjingalwazi waseHarvard nomyili womthetho ka-1989 wokulwa nobunqolobi obusebenzisa 00:19.141 --> 00:25.719 izixhobo zebhayoloji owatyikitywa nguBush, wenze ingxelo efungisiweyo echaza iijekhwe ze-mRNA zeCovid-19 00:25.719 --> 00:30.730 njengezixhobo zebhayoloji nezixhobo zentshabalaliso enkulu. 00:30.730 --> 00:38.719 UGqr Joseph Sansone ngowokuqala ukunika ingxelo ngale nto. Isibhambathiso sikaGqr. Boyle, esifakwe njengenxalenye yesicelo 00:38.719 --> 00:45.725 esingxamisekileyo eFlorida, sixoxa ngelithi ukusasazwa kwezitofu zeCovid-19 kuphulaphula imithetho eliqela, 00:45.725 --> 00:52.700 kuquka uMthetho weZixhobo zeBhayoloji wase-US kunye nemithetho yezixhobo nemipu yaseFlorida. 00:52.700 --> 00:59.889 Le petishoni, ebhalelwe ngqo iRhuluneli uRon DeSantis kunye noMtshutshisi Jikelele uAshley Moody, ifuna ukuba kuyekwe 00:59.889 --> 01:08.540 kwangoko ukusasazwa kwezitofu zeCovid eFlorida kwaye ifuna ukuba kuthathwe naziphi na izitokhwe eziseleyo zezi zitofu. 01:08.540 --> 01:14.379 NgokukaGqr. Sansone, isicelo sokuqala esingxamisekileyo senkqubo ye-mandamus safakwa kwiNkundla 01:14.379 --> 01:18.142 Ephakamileyo yaseFlorida ngomhla wesi-3 kuMatshi 2024. 01:18.142 --> 01:23.118 Kamva, ngomhla wama-20 kuMatshi, yadluliselwa kwiNkundla yaseSilkwood eLeon County. Kwaye emva kokuba 01:23.118 --> 01:28.475 iNkundla yaseSilkwood iyirhoxisile ityala ngomhla we-9 kuTshazimpuzi, yaya kwiNkundla yeZibheno. 01:28.475 --> 01:35.343 Isibheno sifakwe ngoSuku lweSikhumbuzo, umhla wama-27 kuMeyi 2024. UGqr Boyle, enye yeengcali eziphambili 01:35.343 --> 01:42.860 zezomthetho zehlabathi kwezixhobo zebhayoloji, unike ubunzima obukhulu kweli tyala ngesifungo sakhe esibhaliweyo. 01:42.860 --> 01:49.473 Ityala sele linobungqina obubanzi obufakwe kwingxelo yesimangalo, kubandakanywa nee-affidavits ezivela kumcebisi 01:49.473 --> 01:56.026 wezomthetho kwezonyango kunye nomhlalutyi we-biotech uKaren Kingston kunye noGqr. Anahme Haidja. 01:56.026 --> 02:03.718 NgokukaGqr Sansone, isibheno sommangalelo sixoxa ngelithi ukusasazwa kwezi zitofu kuyaphula imithetho eliqela ngaxeshanye. 02:03.718 --> 02:09.478 Ngezantsi, siza kufunda kuphela ezona ngongoma zibalulekileyo: - UMthetho weZixhobo zeBhayoloji - Ulwaphulo-mthetho lweFederal 02:09.478 --> 02:14.826 lokungcatsha elukhulu - Ubuchasa-zwe Basekhaya - Ukubulala noTsabe-hlobo - Ubuqhophololo phantsi koMthetho weZiyobisi 02:14.826 --> 02:21.040 neZithambiso waseFlorida - Ukunceda nokuxhasa emva kokuba kwenzekile kunye noMthetho weMvume yezoNyango waseFlorida. 02:21.040 --> 02:29.151 Isifungo esibhaliweyo esityikitywe nguGqr. Boyle sithi, ngokungqinelana ne-28 U.S.C. 1746: "Mna, uFrancis A. Boyle, 02:29.151 --> 02:35.352 ndibhengeza phantsi kwesohlwayo sokufunga ubuxoki ukuba iingxelo ezikule nto ziyinyani kwaye 02:35.352 --> 02:39.240 zichanekile ngokokwazi kwam nokukholwa kwam." 02:39.240 --> 02:45.752 Uze aluhluze iziqinisekiso zakhe: uNjingalwazi woMthetho waMazwe ngaMazwe kwiKholeji yoMthetho yeYunivesithi yase-Illinois, 02:45.752 --> 02:51.946 isidanga se-A.B. kwiNzululwazi yezoPolitiko asifumene kwiYunivesithi yaseChicago ngo-1971, isidanga se-J.D. magna cum 02:51.946 --> 02:56.552 laude asifumene kwiSikolo soMthetho saseHarvard, kunye nesidanga se-Ph.D. kwiNzululwazi 02:56.552 --> 03:00.198 yezoPolitiko asifumene kwiYunivesithi yaseHarvard. 03:00.198 --> 03:05.963 Uthi: Ndicebise iikomiti ezininzi zamazwe ngamazwe kwiinkalo zamalungelo oluntu, ulwaphulo-mthetho lwemfazwe nentshabalaliso 03:05.963 --> 03:09.280 yohlanga, umgaqo-nkqubo wenyukliya nezixhobo zebhayoloji. 03:09.280 --> 03:16.210 Ngo-1985, ndabizela esidlangalaleni ukuphunyezwa kweSivumelwano seZixhobo zeBhayoloji e-United States ndaza 03:16.210 --> 03:23.939 ndabhala umthetho ohambelanayo, owaziwa ngokuba nguMthetho wokuLwa noBunqolobi ngeZixhobo zeBhayoloji ka-1989. 03:23.939 --> 03:30.765 Zavunywa ngamxhelo mnye ngamakhaya omabini eNkongolo yase-US, zaza zasayinwa nguMongameli uGeorge Bush ngemvume yeSebe 03:30.765 --> 03:38.216 lezoBulungisa laseUnited States. Kuyo, ubhekisa kwincwadi yakhe emalunga nemfazwe yezinto eziphilayo nobunqolobi. 03:38.216 --> 03:45.607 Uthi: Ngokoluvo lwam lobuchwepheshe, izitofu ze-COVID-19 ze-nanoparticle okanye izitofu ze-mRNA ze-nanoparticle okanye 03:45.607 --> 03:53.186 izitofu ze-COVID-19 ziyahlangabezana ngokupheleleyo nemigqaliselo yezixhobo zobomi kunye nezixhobo zentshabalaliso enkulu 03:53.186 --> 03:57.600 phantsi kwe-Biological Weapons 18, USC 175 Weapons and Firearms. 03:57.600 --> 04:05.066 I-Getaway Pundit sele inike ingxelo yokuba iNkundla Ephakamileyo yaseFlorida isivumile isicelo sikaRhuluneli uRon DeSantis sokubiza 04:05.066 --> 04:09.404 ijaji enkulu ukuze kuphantsiwe abavelisi bezitofu zeCovid-19. 04:09.404 --> 04:16.249 Le ndaba imangalisayo ilandela isigqibo esibalulekileyo seNkundla yeZibheno yeSithili se-9, esagqiba kwiveki 04:16.249 --> 04:23.520 ephelileyo ukuba isitofu se-mRNA seCovid-19 asiyonto yokugonya ngokweengcaciso zonyango eziqhelekileyo. 04:23.520 --> 04:29.858 Akusafuneki kuthiwe, isithiyo siwile. Kwaye abantu abaninzi ngakumbi baqala ukubiza ezi jekhwe ngegama lazo 04:29.858 --> 04:37.340 lokwenene – izixhobo zebhayoloji. Kwaye, ngokukaGqr. Francis Boyle, zizixhobo zentshabalalo-ntlanga. 04:39.243 --> 04:45.471 Ndingathanda ukukubuza malunga nesigqibo seNkundla yeZibheno yeFederal yesi-9: Abantu bangenza ntoni ngoku, 04:45.471 --> 04:51.936 Gqirha Martin? Ndive izimvo ezibonisa ukuba ngoku kunokwenzeka ukuba abantu bafake isimangalo enkundleni. 04:51.936 --> 04:55.775 Nditsho, ungaya kude kangakanani ngaloo nto? 04:55.775 --> 05:00.920 Gqr. David Martin: Ewe, ngoko ke makucace ukuba sithetha ngokusetyenziswa komthetho, hayi ithiyori. 05:00.920 --> 05:07.267 INkundla yeZibheno yeSithoba ngokobuchwepheshe ibuyisele eli tyala kwiinkundla ezisezantsi, ichaza ukuba 05:07.267 --> 05:14.600 ootitshala kwiSithili seZikolo esiManyeneyo saseLos Angeles banako ngokwenene ukuphikisa umyalelo wokugonya. 05:14.600 --> 05:22.752 Loo nto yindlela yobuchwepheshe yokubhala umthetho. Uluvo, oluyinxalenye yomzekelo wamandulo, kwaye lulo umahluko obaluleke 05:22.752 --> 05:29.181 kakhulu endifuna ukuwenza, lwenza kucace gca ukuba iNkundla yeZibheno yeSithoba yagqiba kwelokuba 05:29.181 --> 05:32.349 iJacobson ayisetyenziswanga kakuhle kule meko kanye. 05:32.349 --> 05:38.929 Kwaye oko kuthetha ukuba, okokuqala, ingcinga engeyonyani yokuba ummiselo wokugonywa usebenzela 05:38.929 --> 05:42.433 impilo yoluntu yatshatyalaliswa yinkundla yezibheno. 05:42.433 --> 05:49.387 Eli lixesha elibaluleke kakhulu, kuba ukusukela ngoku singenza iingxelo ezixhaswe ngumthetho zokuba abavelisi 05:49.387 --> 05:53.524 bayaphambanisa uluntu ngabom ngeemveliso zabo zokutofa. 05:53.524 --> 05:58.260 Ezi mveliso zifakwe iilebhile ezingachanekanga kwaye azinakubizwa ngokuba ziigonyo. 05:58.260 --> 06:04.947 Ngokwenene, oku kukwaphula uMthetho we-US Federal Trade Commission kunye noMthetho we-Deceptive Medical 06:04.947 --> 06:11.740 Practices, owakhe ekho nakuzo zonke iilizwe eziphucukileyo ezinemiqathango esemthethweni eqinileyo. 06:11.740 --> 06:15.700 Iindaba ezimnandi zezokuba sikwazile ukutyhoboza eli veili. 06:15.700 --> 06:22.374 Kodwa okona kubaluleke kakhulu, kwaye le yeyona ngongoma ibalulekileyo, iNkundla yeZibheno yeSithoba 06:22.374 --> 06:28.606 ithe ngokucacileyo ukuba izikhawulezo zikaJacobson azizukwamkelwa phantsi kwale mbono. 06:28.606 --> 06:36.568 Esinye isiphumo sesokuba ngoku sinamathuba asemthethweni ebesiwadinga ukuze sityhobe ukhuselo lwabo lwetyala abavelisi 06:36.568 --> 06:42.574 lwezitofu zokugonya kunye nabo bantu abanjengabaqeshi, oosokhemesti, oogqirha, abongikazi 06:42.574 --> 06:46.440 nezibhedlele abathi ngokwenene bagonywe abantu. 06:46.440 --> 06:53.570 Okokuqala, ngoku sinethuba lokuthi iNkundla yeZibheno yeSithoba igwebe yathi iJacobson yayisetyenziswe gwenxa. Kuba 06:53.570 --> 06:58.062 ayizange iyinqande usulelo kwaye ayizange ithintele ukosulela. 06:58.062 --> 07:03.497 Uluntu ngoko lwayekhokiswa ngabom, nto leyo eyityala lolwaphulo-mthetho. Kwaye ngokweMigaqo 07:03.497 --> 07:07.296 yoLwaphulo-mthetho, Maria, zonke izikhuseli zoxanduva ziyasuswa. 07:07.296 --> 07:13.920 I-Pfizer ne-Moderna zinoxanduva ngokwezimali nangokwecala lolwaphulo-mthetho ngokukhohlisa uluntu. 07:13.920 --> 07:21.643 Okumangalisayo kukuba, amajelo eendaba aphambili asekhohlo kunye nenxalenye yentshukumo ekuthiwa yeyokukhululeka kwezonyango 07:21.643 --> 07:25.500 baye baqhubeka besithi le nto ngandlel' ithile yeyokugonya. 07:25.500 --> 07:33.872 Ngoko ke masiqale ngeenyaniso ezicacileyo. Okokuqala, ngo-Epreli 2020, i-Pfizer, i-Biontech kunye ne-Moderna zonke zatsho 07:33.872 --> 07:43.000 ngokungathandabuzekiyo kwiifayile zazo ze-SEC ukuba i-mRNA, kwaye ndicaphula, "lungiselelo lonyango lwemfuza olusavavanywayo". 07:43.000 --> 07:50.625 Oku kucacile ngqo kumaxwebhu e-Securities and Exchange Commission. Le asilulo uluvo lukaGqr. Dave Martin. 07:50.625 --> 07:57.188 Loo nto ayilolvo lomnye umntu kananjalo. Kucacile into abayithethileyo. Okuthetha ukuba xa bebesasaza 07:57.188 --> 08:04.350 isitofu sokugonya, babengasasazi isitofu sokugonya ngokwenene, kodwa unyango lwemfuza olusavavanywayo. 08:04.350 --> 08:10.756 Kwaye ngabom bazibiza ngamagama angachanekanga ukuze bakhohlise uluntu lwamkele. Ngoko 08:10.756 --> 08:14.624 ke, masicacise kakuhle, olu lulwaphulo-mthetho. 08:14.624 --> 08:23.224 Le ngenene yobunqolobi basekhaya, obusetyenziselwe ukunyanzela abantu ukuba bathathe into ababeya kuthi bangayithathi. 08:23.224 --> 08:31.995 Loo nto yinkcazelo yobunqolobi basekhaya. Kwaye yiyo kanye leyo into enjalo. Njengoko usazi, Maria, bendisoloko ndisitsho ukuba 08:31.995 --> 08:38.901 esi sisixhobo sobioloji kuba uRolf Baric wachaza kwinkomfa ye-DARPA-MAITA ngo-2005 ukuba iziqwengana 08:38.901 --> 08:47.180 ze-coronavirus ezenziweyo, kwaye ndicaphula kwi-CV yakhe apha, ziyitekhnoloji eyenza ukuba kubekho izixhobo zobulali. 08:47.180 --> 08:52.860 Maria, andazi nokuba unengxaki na nendlela esetyenziswa ngayo okuqhelekileyo e-Australia, kodwa 08:52.860 --> 08:59.100 itekhnoloji evumela imfazwe yezinto eziphilayo ivakala kum ngathi sisixhobo sokulwa esiphilayo. 08:59.100 --> 09:08.050 Kwaye ngoku kuye kwavela ukuba ukuba awujongi isigwebo senkundla kuphela, kodwa ukwajonga nentsingiselo ye-7 CFR Part 331 09:08.050 --> 09:16.482 yee-arhente neetyhefu ezikhethiweyo, oko kukuthi, uluhlu lwezixhobo zokulwa eziphilayo, kuyavela ukuba iprotheyini 09:16.482 --> 09:25.730 ye-spike enxulumene nalulo lonke uhlengahlengiso lwe-coronavirus eneneni idweliswe njengesixhobo sokulwa esiphilayo. 09:25.730 --> 09:32.746 Leyo yinkcazelo yesigwebo. Ngoko ke ayivuseleli amajoni omzimba kwaphela. 09:32.746 --> 09:40.112 Umjovo onikwa abantu kwihlabathi jikelele, nokuba uvela kwaModerna okanye kwaPfizer, ubangela 09:40.112 --> 09:44.659 ukuba umzimba womntu uvelise ityhefu edwelisiweyo. 09:44.659 --> 09:52.656 Emva koko unethemba lokuba unenkqubo yokuzikhusela esomeleleyo, emva kokucwangcisa umzimba wakho ukuba uvelise 09:52.656 --> 10:01.106 isixhobo sebhayoloji, apho ke ukhuseleko ekufanele lwenziwe nxamnye nantoni na umzimba ocwangciswe ukuba uyenze. 10:01.106 --> 10:10.706 Kwaye kulapho utoliko luka-Aron Ceres luphosakele ngokupheleleyo. Kuba ngokungafaniyo nezinye izinto athetha ngazo ngokunxulumene 10:10.706 --> 10:17.032 neentsontelo, kule meko kanye, ientsontelo yeyokuyalela ukuba kuveliswe ityhefu, hayi 10:17.032 --> 10:20.330 yokuvuselela impendulo yokhuselo lomzimba. 10:20.330 --> 10:30.790 Kwaye yiyo leyo umahluko ongaqaphelekiyo iNinth Circuit, kwimbono yayo yobuninzi, ngokoluvo lwam, iwuchonge ngokuchanekileyo.