WEBVTT 00:00.429 --> 00:06.170 Umbiko wokuqala walobu busuku kufanele uvele kuwo wonke amakhasi okuqala ezinkampani zezindaba emhlabeni wonke. 00:06.170 --> 00:11.360 Imijovo ye-Covid ibekwe njengethuluzi lokubhubhisa okukhulu ngumprofesa omkhulu wezomthetho. 00:11.360 --> 00:18.708 Lokhu kumangalisayo. UDkt. Francis Boyle, uprofesa eHarvard nomklami womthetho wokulwa nobugebengu bokwesabisa wango-1989 00:18.708 --> 00:25.995 mayelana nezikhali eziphilayo owagunyazwa nguBush, wenze isitatimende esiqinisekisiwe echaza imijovo ye-mRNA ye-Covid-19 00:25.995 --> 00:30.730 njengezikhali eziphilayo nezikhali zokubhubhisa okukhulu. 00:30.730 --> 00:37.412 UDkt. Joseph Sansone wayengowokuqala ukubika ngalokhu. Isitatimende esifakwe ngaphansi kwesifungo sika- uDkt Boyle, 00:37.412 --> 00:44.385 esifakwe njengengxenye yesicelo esiphuthumayo eFlorida, siphikisa ukuthi ukusatshalaliswa kwezitofu zokugoma ze-Covid-19 00:44.385 --> 00:52.700 kuphulwa imithetho eminingana, kuhlanganise noMthetho Wezikhali Zobhayoloji wase-US nemithetho yezikhali nezibhamu yaseFlorida. 00:52.700 --> 00:59.016 Isicelo, esibhalwe ngqo kuGobernela uRon DeSantis noMmeli-Jikelele u-Ashley Moody, sifuna ukumiswa 00:59.016 --> 01:08.540 ngokushesha kokusatshalaliswa kwemijovo ye-Covid eFlorida futhi sifuna ukuthathwa kwanoma yiziphi izitoko ezisele zale mijovo. 01:08.540 --> 01:14.664 NgokukaDkt. Sansone, isicelo sokuqala esiphuthumayo senqubo ye-mandamus safakwa eNkantolo 01:14.664 --> 01:18.142 ePhakeme yaseFlorida ngomhlaka 3 Mashi 2024. 01:18.142 --> 01:24.210 Kamva, ngomhlaka 20 Mashi, kwadluliselwa eSilkwood Court eLeon County. Futhi ngemva kokuthi iSilkwood Court 01:24.210 --> 01:28.475 ikhansele icala ngomhlaka 9 Ephreli, laya eNkantolo Yezikhalazo. 01:28.475 --> 01:35.941 Isicelo sokuphikisa safakwa ngosuku lweMemorial Day, mhla ziyi-27 kuMeyi 2024. UDkt Boyle, omunye wezazi zomthetho ezihamba 01:35.941 --> 01:42.860 phambili emhlabeni kwezikhali eziphilayo, unikeze isisindo esikhulu kuleli cala ngesitatimende sakhe esibhaliwe. 01:42.860 --> 01:49.003 Leli cala selinobufakazi obubanzi obufakwe esitatimendeni sesimangalo, kuhlanganisa nama-affidavit avela kumeluleki 01:49.003 --> 01:56.026 wezokwelapha kwezomthetho nomhlaziyi wezobuchwepheshe bezinto eziphilayo uKaren Kingston nodokotela uAnahme Haidja. 01:56.026 --> 02:00.981 NgokukaDkt. Sansone, isitatimende sesimangalo siphikisa ukuthi ukusatshalaliswa kwalezi zifutho 02:00.981 --> 02:03.718 kuphula imithetho eminingana ngasikhathi sinye. 02:03.718 --> 02:08.385 Ngezansi, sizofunda kuphela amaphuzu abaluleke kakhulu: - Umthetho Wezikhali Zobhayoloji - Ubugebengu be-Federal 02:08.385 --> 02:13.386 bokungcatsha okukhulu - Ubuphekula basekhaya - Ubugebengu bokubulala kanye nokubhujiswa kwezinhlanga - Ukwenza inkohliso 02:13.386 --> 02:17.678 ngaphansi koMthetho Wezidakamizwa Nezithako Zokuhlobisa waseFlorida - Ukusekela nokubamba iqhaza ngemva 02:17.678 --> 02:21.040 kwesenzo kanye noMthetho Wemvume Yezokwelapha waseFlorida. 02:21.040 --> 02:29.432 Isitatimende esisayinwe nguDkt Boyle sithi, ngokwe-28 U.S.C. 1746: "Mina, uFrancis A. Boyle, ngimemezela ngaphansi 02:29.432 --> 02:39.240 kwesijeziso sokufakaza amanga ukuthi izitatimende ezikuqukethwe lapha ziqiniso futhi zilungile ngokwazi kwami nokukholwa kwami." 02:39.240 --> 02:47.171 Wabe esehluza iziqu zakhe: uProfesa weMthetho Wamazwe Ngamazwe eNyuvesi yase-Illinois eKholeji yoMthetho, i-A.B. kweSayensi 02:47.171 --> 02:53.619 Yezepolitiki evela eNyuvesi yaseChicago ngo-1971, i-J.D. ngenhlonipho enkulu (magna cum laude) evela 02:53.619 --> 03:00.198 eHarvard Law School, kanye ne-Ph.D. kweSayensi Yezepolitiki evela eNyuvesi yaseHarvard. 03:00.198 --> 03:05.985 Uthi: Ngike ngeluleka izikomidi zamazwe ngamazwe eziningi emikhakheni yamalungelo abantu, ubugebengu bempi nokubhujiswa 03:05.985 --> 03:09.280 kwabantu, inqubomgomo yenyukliya nezikhali eziphilayo. 03:09.280 --> 03:16.614 Ngo-1985, ngabiza obala ukusetshenziswa kweSivumelwano Sezikhali Zobhayoloji e-United States futhi ngabhala 03:16.614 --> 03:23.939 umthetho ohambisanayo owaziwa ngokuthi uMthetho Wokulwa Nobugebengu Bezikhali Zobhayoloji ka-1989. 03:23.939 --> 03:30.467 Zamukelwe ngokuvumelana ngokuphelele yizindlu zombili zeCongress yase-United States futhi zasayinwa nguMongameli uGeorge Bush 03:30.467 --> 03:34.853 ngemvume yoMnyango Wezobulungiswa wase-United States. Kuyo, ubhekisa encwadini yakhe 03:34.853 --> 03:38.216 mayelana nempi yezinto eziphilayo nobuphekula. 03:38.216 --> 03:46.246 Uthi: Ngokombono wami wobungcweti, imijovo yama-nanoparticle ye-Covid-19 noma imijovo yama-nanoparticle ye-mRNA noma imijovo 03:46.246 --> 03:53.564 ye-Covid-19 ihlangabezana ngokuphelele nezimfuneko zezikhali eziphilayo nezikhali zokubhubhisa okukhulu ngaphansi 03:53.564 --> 03:57.600 kwe-Biological Weapons 18, USC 175 Weapons and Firearms. 03:57.600 --> 04:04.974 I-Getaway Pundit isivele yabika ukuthi iNkantolo ePhakeme yaseFlorida ivumile isicelo sikaGobernela uRon DeSantis sokubiza 04:04.974 --> 04:09.404 ijuri enkulu ukuze iphenye abakhiqizi bemijovo ye-Covid-19. 04:09.404 --> 04:15.659 Lolu daba olumangazayo kulandela isinqumo esibalulekile seNkantolo Yezikhalazo Yesifunda Sesishiyagalolunye, 04:15.659 --> 04:23.520 eyanquma ngesonto eledlule ukuthi umjovo we-mRNA we-Covid-19 awuyona i-vaccine ngokwezincazelo ezijwayelekile zezokwelapha. 04:23.520 --> 04:29.763 Akudingeki ukuthi ngisho, udonga seluphukile. Futhi abantu abaningi kakhulu sebeqala ukubiza lezi zitofu ngokuthi 04:29.763 --> 04:37.340 ziyini ngempela – izikhali eziphilayo. Futhi, ngokusho kukaDkt Francis Boyle, izikhali zokubhujiswa okukhulu. 04:39.243 --> 04:45.381 Ngithanda ukukubuza ngesinqumo seNkantolo Yesi-9 Yezikhalazo Kazwelonke: Abantu bangakwenza ini manje, 04:45.381 --> 04:51.936 Dokotela Martin? Ngizwe amazwana aphakamisayo ukuthi manje sekuyenzeka kubantu ukufaka icala enkantolo. 04:51.936 --> 04:55.775 Ngisho, ungaya kude kangakanani ngalokho? 04:55.775 --> 05:00.920 UDkt. David Martin: Yebo, ake sicacise ukuthi sikhuluma ngomkhuba womthetho, hhayi ngethiyori. 05:00.920 --> 05:09.425 Inkantolo Yezikhalazo Yesishiyagalolunye ngokobuchwepheshe ibuyisele icala ezinkantolo eziphansi, ithi othisha eLos Angeles 05:09.425 --> 05:14.600 Unified School District bangempela bangaphikisa umyalo wokugoma. 05:14.600 --> 05:21.645 Lena yindlela yobuchwepheshe yokubhala umthetho. Umbono, oyingxenye yomthetho wangaphambilini, futhi yilowo umehluko 05:21.645 --> 05:28.873 obalulekile engifuna ukuwenza, wenza kucace ngokuphelele ukuthi iNkantolo Yezikhalazo Yesishiyagalolunye yanquma ukuthi 05:28.873 --> 05:32.349 iJacobson yasetshenziswa ngokungalungile kuleli cala elithile. 05:32.349 --> 05:39.208 Futhi lokho kusho ukuthi, okokuqala, umbono wamanga wokuthi umyalo wokugoma usebenzela impilo 05:39.208 --> 05:42.433 yomphakathi waphukile yinkantolo yezikhalazo. 05:42.433 --> 05:49.546 Lena yisikhathi esibalulekile, ngoba kusukela manje singakwazi ukwenza izitatimende ezisekelwe emthethweni zokuthi abakhiqizi 05:49.546 --> 05:53.524 ngenhloso bayadukisa umphakathi ngemikhiqizo yabo yokufaka. 05:53.524 --> 05:58.260 Le mikhiqizo ibhalwe kabi futhi ayinakubizwa ngokuthi izitozo. 05:58.260 --> 06:04.586 Ngokungeqondile, lokhu kuwukwephula uMthetho we-Federal Trade Commission wase-United States kanye noMthetho Wokuziphatha 06:04.586 --> 06:08.540 Kwezokwelapha Okukhohlisayo, okutholakala nakuzo zonke izizwe ezithuthukile 06:08.540 --> 06:11.740 ezinokuziphatha okusezingeni eliphezulu kwezomthetho. 06:11.740 --> 06:15.700 Izindaba ezinhle ukuthi sesikwazile ukubhoboza lesi sigqoko. 06:15.700 --> 06:23.933 Kodwa okubaluleke kakhulu, futhi leli yiphuzu elibalulekile, iNkantolo Yezikhalazo Yesishiyagalolunye yathi ngokusobala ukuthi 06:23.933 --> 06:28.606 izixolelo zikaJacobson ngeke zamukelwe ngaphansi kwalesi sibono. 06:28.606 --> 06:36.009 Omunye umphumela wukuthi manje sesinamathuba asemthethweni esasidinga ukuze siphule ukuvikelwa komthwalo wemfanelo 06:36.009 --> 06:42.178 kwabakhiqizi bemijovo yokugoma kanye nalabo bantu abafana nabaqashi, abapharmasisti, odokotela, 06:42.178 --> 06:46.440 abahlengikazi nezibhedlela ababethelela abantu imijovo. 06:46.440 --> 06:51.834 Okokuqala, manje sesinethuba lokusho ukuthi iNkantolo Yezikhalazo Yesishiyagalolunye ithathe isinqumo sokuthi 06:51.834 --> 06:58.062 iJacobson yasetshenziswa ngokungalungile. Lokho akuzange kumise izifo futhi akuzange kuvimbele ukudluliswa kwazo. 06:58.062 --> 07:03.502 Ngakho-ke umphakathi waholwa ngenhloso, okuyicala lobugebengu. Futhi ngokweKhodi 07:03.502 --> 07:07.296 Yobugebengu, Maria, zonke izivikelo zomthwalo ziyasuswa. 07:07.296 --> 07:13.920 I-Pfizer ne-Moderna zibophekile ngokwezimali nangokwecala lokubaxa umphakathi. 07:13.920 --> 07:21.449 Ngokumangazayo, imidiya eyinhloko yezepolitiki yesobunxele kanye nengxenye yomkhankaso obizwa ngokuthi wokuzimela 07:21.449 --> 07:25.500 kwezokwelapha baqhubeka nokuthi lokhu kuyisitofu sokugoma. 07:25.500 --> 07:33.784 Ngakho-ke masiqale ngamaqiniso acacile. Okokuqala, ngo-Ephreli 2020, i-Pfizer, i-Biontech ne-Moderna zonke zathi 07:33.784 --> 07:43.000 ngokusobala ezifakazweni zazo ze-SEC ukuthi i-mRNA iyi, futhi ngizocaphuna, "ukwelashwa kwezofuzo okusemazivivinyweni". 07:43.000 --> 07:50.625 Lokhu kuyabonakala ngqo emibhalweni ye-Securities and Exchange Commission. Lokhu akuyona umbono kaDkt. Dave Martin. 07:50.625 --> 07:59.347 Lokho akuyona futhi umbono womunye umuntu. Kuyacaca abakushilo. Okusho ukuthi lapho bekhuthaza umuthi wokugoma, babengakhuthazi 07:59.347 --> 08:04.350 ngempela umuthi wokugoma, kodwa ukwelashwa kwezofuzo okuhlolwayo. 08:04.350 --> 08:10.569 Futhi ngenhloso yokukhohlisa umphakathi ukuze bawamukele, bawabiza ngokungeyikho. 08:10.569 --> 08:14.624 Ngakho-ke ake kucace kahle, lokhu kuwubugebengu. 08:14.624 --> 08:19.805 Lokhu ngempela ubuqili basekhaya, obusetshenziselwa ukuphoqa abantu ukuthi bathathe 08:19.805 --> 08:23.224 into abangeke bayithathe ngaphandle kwalokhu. 08:23.224 --> 08:31.650 Lena incazelo yobuphekula basekhaya. Futhi yilokho ngempela. Njengoba wazi, Maria, ngivame ukusho ukuthi lokhu kuyisikhali 08:31.650 --> 08:38.763 esibhayoloji ngoba uRolf Baric wathi engqungqutheleni ye-DARPA-MAITA ngo-2005 ukuthi izingcezu ezenziwe 08:38.763 --> 08:47.180 ngokwenziwa ze-coronavirus, futhi ngicaphuna lokhu ku-CV yakhe lapha, ziyobuchwepheshe obuvumela izikhali ezibhayoloji. 08:47.180 --> 08:54.573 Maria, angazi noma unenkinga ngokusetshenziswa okuvamile e-Australia, kodwa ubuchwepheshe obuvumela impi yezinto 08:54.573 --> 08:59.100 eziphilayo kubonakala kimi njengesikhali sezinto eziphilayo. 08:59.100 --> 09:08.724 Futhi manje sekubonakala ukuthi uma ungabheki nje kuphela isinqumo senkantolo, kodwa futhi nencazelo ye-7 CFR Ingxenye 331 09:08.724 --> 09:16.848 yezithako ezikhethiwe neziyingozi, okungukuthi uhlu lwezikhali eziphilayo, kubonakala ukuthi iphrotheni 09:16.848 --> 09:25.730 ye-spike ehlotshaniswa nazo zonke izinguquko ku-coronavirus empeleni ibhaliswe njengesikhali esiphilayo. 09:25.730 --> 09:32.746 Lokho kuyincazelo yokwahlulela. Ngakho-ke akukhiqizi ukumelana nomzimba nhlobo. 09:32.746 --> 09:39.933 Umjovo onikezwa abantu emhlabeni wonke, noma ngabe uvela kwaModerna noma kwaPfizer, ubangela 09:39.933 --> 09:44.659 umzimba womuntu ukukhiqiza itokisini ebhalwe ohlwini. 09:44.659 --> 09:52.765 Futhi-ke uthemba ukuthi unohlelo lokuzivikela lomzimba oluqinile ngemva kokuhlela umzimba wakho ukuthi ukhiqize 09:52.765 --> 10:01.106 isikhali sebhayoloji, lapho ngempela kulindeleke ukuthi umzimba uthole ukumelana nanoma yini owuhlelelwe yona. 10:01.106 --> 10:11.142 Futhi lapha incazelo ka-Aron Ceres iphutha ngokuphelele. Ngoba ngokungafani nezinye izinto akhuluma ngazo maqondana 10:11.142 --> 10:20.330 nemijovo, kulokhu umjovo uyiyalelo lokukhiqiza itokisini hhayi lokuvusa impendulo yokuzivikela komzimba. 10:20.330 --> 10:30.790 Futhi yilowo umehluko omncane iNinth Circuit, ekuboneni kwami, iwubonile ngokuchanekileyo ekuboneni kwayo kwabaningi.