WEBVTT 00:00.195 --> 00:03.640 Akwai rashin kwanciyar hankali mai yawa a cikin watsa shirye-shirye na jama'a. 00:03.640 --> 00:10.446 Har zuwa bazarar 2024, ma'aikata sama da 100 na ARD, ZDF da Deutschlandradio sun yi korafi a cikin wata 00:10.446 --> 00:17.580 sanarwa cewa kusan babu 'yancin faɗar albarkacin baki a wurin kuma ana toshe duk wata ra'ayin adawa. 00:17.580 --> 00:19.189 Babu kunya! 00:19.189 --> 00:23.438 Duk da haka, yawan 'yan ƙasa da ba su gamsu ba na ƙaruwa, kuma ana ƙara hukunta tashoshin watsa 00:23.438 --> 00:26.080 labarai na jama'a a ƙididdigar ra'ayin jama'a. 00:26.080 --> 00:31.699 Shin abin mamaki ne cewa waɗannan masu watsa shirye-shirye, waɗanda ake ɗaukar kuɗin tilas don tallafawa su, ke bayyana 00:31.699 --> 00:35.487 ra'ayi ɗaya a kowane rikici, suna yi wa mutane wa'azi ta gefe ɗaya, suna toshe muryoyin masu 00:35.487 --> 00:38.539 adawa kuma suna ɓata waɗanda ke tunani daban? 00:38.539 --> 00:44.610 Tun da dadewa ba a iya fahimtar dalilin da ya sa waɗannan kafofin watsa labarai na haraji tilas ba za su iya sarrafa kusan euro 00:44.610 --> 00:48.553 biliyan 8.6 a kowace shekara ba, kuma suna ƙara neman ƙarin kuɗi. 00:48.553 --> 00:53.256 Jamus tuni tana da tsarin watsa labarai na jama'a mafi tsada a duniya. 00:53.256 --> 00:55.771 Biliyoyin suna kwarara cikin hanyoyi masu tayar da hankali. 00:55.771 --> 01:00.071 Ana kashe manyan kuɗaɗe wajen sayen kayan daki na alfarma masu tsada ba tare da buƙata ba 01:00.071 --> 01:03.043 domin gyaran studio na fim na WDR a Cologne kaɗai. 01:03.043 --> 01:09.264 Kudin gyaran ya tashi daga euro miliyan 130 zuwa miliyan 240. 01:09.264 --> 01:13.860 Kasa da kashi 10% na kuɗaɗen lasisin watsa shirye-shirye na ARD sun je ga tsare-tsaren fansho na kamfani. 01:13.860 --> 01:22.499 A cikin ƙididdiga: €564 miliyan a cikin shekara guda don fansho da fa'idodin ritaya ga tsofaffin ma'aikatansa kaɗai. 01:22.499 --> 01:30.999 An ce ZDF ta ware €5.8 miliyan don biyan fansho ga tsohon daraktan ZDF Thomas Bellut kadai. 01:30.999 --> 01:36.053 Yana karɓar sama da euro 30,000 a kowane wata a ritaya. 01:36.053 --> 01:45.035 Ina ma'anar daidaito idan mai gabatarwa kamar Markus Lanz yana karɓar albashi na shekara kimanin fam miliyan 1.9, alhali 01:45.035 --> 01:49.653 mai ritaya sai ya dogara da matsakaicin fam 16,440 a shekara? 01:49.653 --> 01:56.995 Me ya sa wani barkwanci mai cike da shakku kamar Oliver Welke ke samun kusan €1.2 miliyan a shekara, alhali 01:56.995 --> 02:01.674 ma'aikacin kudi mai aiki tukuru ke samun €32,500 kawai? 02:01.674 --> 02:06.197 Muna sha'awar jin abin da talakawan jama'a a titi ke faɗa game da waɗannan yanayi. 02:06.197 --> 02:09.479 A'a, ban san cewa ya samu haka ba. To, shikenan... 02:09.479 --> 02:11.541 ... Ban yi tunanin hakan adalci ba, a'a. 02:11.541 --> 02:16.107 miliyan 1.9 a kowace shekara 02:16.107 --> 02:21.143 An cika shi da kuɗaɗen GEZ, wanda kowane ɗan ƙasa dole ne ya biya, har ma a Jamus. 02:21.143 --> 02:29.073 ... To, ba kasafai wani abu ke sa ni rasa magana ba, amma wannan abin birgewa ne. 02:29.073 --> 02:34.040 Ina tsammanin idan bai yi nasara ba, za a kore shi nan take, sannan kuma ba za a sake ganinsa ba. 02:34.040 --> 02:38.018 Saboda haka, lallai yana yin abubuwa da yawa don samun hakan. 02:38.018 --> 02:41.789 ... ana biyan kuɗinsa ne ta harajin watsa shirye-shirye na jama'a, wato harajin GEZ, wanda 02:41.789 --> 02:43.699 kowa dole ne ya biya, kowane ɗan ƙasa a Jamus. 02:43.699 --> 02:45.367 Shin kana ganin hakan adalci ne? 02:45.367 --> 02:46.262 A'a, ba kwata-kwata. 02:46.262 --> 02:48.056 Rashin gamsuwa na ƙaruwa. 02:48.056 --> 02:52.213 Shin har yanzu ya dace? Shin har yanzu adalci ne? 02:52.213 --> 02:53.361 To, ban yi tunanin haka ba. 02:53.361 --> 03:00.194 Amma kuma saboda ni mutum ne mai imani da adalci, kuma wannan batun albashin shugaban kamfani na miliyoyin 03:00.194 --> 03:04.748 daloli guda bakwai ba abu ne da ya kamata ya wanzu ba. 03:04.748 --> 03:07.840 euro 6,000, 7,000? Bayan cire haraji... 03:07.840 --> 03:12.823 Mutumin yana samun kusan miliyan 1.2 a kowace shekara. 03:12.823 --> 03:14.393 Har haka?! 03:14.393 --> 03:16.823 ... 45 ... 50? 03:16.823 --> 03:20.001 Eh, kusan miliyan 1.2 ne zai zama hukunci. 03:20.001 --> 03:21.758 Yana samun miliyan 1.2?! 03:21.758 --> 03:23.454 Eh. 03:23.454 --> 03:25.797 Sannan muna da Markus Lanz, misali. 03:25.797 --> 03:28.922 Ya kai kololuwa da miliyan 1.9. 03:28.922 --> 03:30.260 Ba shi da ma'ana! 03:30.260 --> 03:34.969 : Ba na samun kuɗi mai yawa. Na yi ritaya, amma har yanzu sai in biya komai. 03:34.969 --> 03:38.480 Mai karbar fansho yana samun kimanin fam £16,000 a kowace shekara. 03:38.480 --> 03:39.340 a duk shekara 03:39.340 --> 03:40.210 Kaɗan kaɗan. 03:40.210 --> 03:42.100 Kaɗan kaɗan, eh. 03:42.100 --> 03:47.684 Yanzu kawai ka duba 16,000 idan aka kwatanta da 1,234,321 (miliyan 1.2) – a ra'ayinka, shin wannan adalci ne? 03:47.684 --> 03:49.559 Ai, wannan kudi ya yi yawa! 03:49.559 --> 03:52.771 Za ka iya raba wani ƙaramin abu ga wasu mutane. 03:52.771 --> 04:01.474 ko inda nauyi ya yi yawa, mutane suna sha wahala sosai... 04:01.474 --> 04:06.263 Da yawa sun rasa aikinsu saboda annobar coronavirus da sauran matsaloli. 04:06.263 --> 04:16.100 ... Kuma a can zai iya ba wa wasu ɗan abu ko ya samu kaɗan kaɗan. 04:16.100 --> 04:18.440 ... Eh, amma ba adalci ba ne. 04:18.440 --> 04:19.897 To, shi mutum ne sanannen sosai. 04:19.897 --> 04:25.135 Kuma abu ne gama gari ga mutane mashahuri su samu kuɗi sosai, kamar 'yan ƙwallon ƙafa, 'yan wasan kwaikwayo da sauransu. 04:25.135 --> 04:30.283 Amma tabbas ya bayyana cewa mu ne muka ba da kudin wannan, kuma da miliyan 1.9 za ku iya yin ayyuka masu kyau sosai. 04:30.283 --> 04:34.072 don ilmantar da mutane ko aiwatar da wasu ayyuka 04:34.072 --> 04:38.353 Shi ya sa nake ganin yana da girman kai sosai, ya wuce kima ga abin da yake samu. 04:38.353 --> 04:44.360 Eh, mutum koyaushe yana mamakin ina adalci yake, ina daidaito yake... 04:44.360 --> 04:48.905 Eh, wannan kuɗin jama'a ne, wannan ma kuɗaɗen shiga ne... 04:48.905 --> 04:51.942 Eh, kudinmu. Kudimmu... da tashin hankali. 04:51.942 --> 04:54.394 ... abin tsoro ƙwarai ... Don haka, 04:54.394 --> 04:58.823 da za ka iya samun arziki sosai da shi... kusan miliyan biyu a shekara. 04:58.823 --> 05:01.269 Na ga hakan abin firgita ne. 05:01.269 --> 05:04.683 Ina ganin ba daidai ba ne kwata-kwata cewa kowa dole ne ya biya kudin lasisi a waɗannan kwanakin. 05:04.683 --> 05:09.296 Misali, a halin yanzu ban da talabijin a gida ba, amma ban yi tunanin hakan zai yi tasiri 05:09.296 --> 05:12.082 ba a yanzu saboda doka ta canza a nan Jamus. 05:12.082 --> 05:15.140 Duk mutane dole ne su biya, ko suna da talabijin ko babu. 05:15.140 --> 05:18.913 Labaran yanzu suna da matuƙar mummuna. 05:18.913 --> 05:26.120 Wani lokaci ka kunna talabijin da karfe takwas na dare, ko a lokacin hutu a Gasar Zakarun Turai, sai ka ga labarai ne kawai 05:26.120 --> 05:31.627 game da Isra'ila, Siriya, yaƙin Ukraine, da halin da ake ciki a Amurka, sai ka ce a ranka: Ai, 05:31.627 --> 05:34.869 shin waɗannan ne duka labaran da muke da su yanzu? 05:34.869 --> 05:36.166 Ba za ka iya zama mai tsanani ba. 05:36.166 --> 05:43.638 Ra'ayoyi da ba su da shahara sosai ana tallafa musu da hotuna marasa kyau kwata-kwata, sannan 05:43.638 --> 05:47.631 mutanen da ke bayyana su ne ke gabatar da su. 05:47.631 --> 05:54.280 Ban yarda da su kwata-kwata ba, amma kawai ina ganin cewa ya kamata a gabatar da ra'ayoyi daban-daban. 05:54.280 --> 05:59.366 Misali, muna da AfD, wadda a farko ba a taɓa gabatar da ita a shirye-shiryen tattaunawa ba. 05:59.366 --> 06:01.882 Sa'an nan aka gayyace su zuwa shirye-shiryen tattaunawa. 06:01.882 --> 06:08.903 Muddin muka ba su damar shiga Majalisar Dokoki, ya kamata mu kuma yada dukkan ra'ayoyi a bainar jama'a – daidai 06:08.903 --> 06:15.227 yadda aka bayyana su, ba tare da gyarawa ko canza su ba – kuma kowa ya samu damar yin nasa ra'ayi. 06:15.227 --> 06:22.605 Ban yi tunanin mu 'yan ƙasa muna da jahilci har sai an ciyar da mu da komai da cokali ba. 06:22.605 --> 06:23.675 Ba sai mun ji tsoro ba. 06:23.675 --> 06:27.167 Kowa yana yin sa da kansa, sannan za mu sami kyakkyawan hanya ta ci gaba. 06:27.167 --> 06:30.856 Duk sauran abubuwa paternalism ne, ba tare da la'akari da ko sun fito ne daga gefen hagu mai nisa ko 06:30.856 --> 06:33.326 jam'iyyar Greens, ko daga gefen dama ko gefen dama mai nisa. 06:33.326 --> 06:37.873 Masu kallo, Jamus ba wai ita ce kawai ke da tsarin watsa shirye-shirye na jama'a mafi tsada a 06:37.873 --> 06:40.720 duniya ba, kamar yadda Handelsblatt ta ruwaito. 06:40.720 --> 06:46.120 Tare da karuwar haraji na tilas da ke ƙaruwa kullum, muna kuma biyan manyan albashi da biyan fansho. 06:46.120 --> 06:50.640 Muna biyan kuɗin tashoshi masu shakku da kuɗaɗen alatu marasa muhimmanci. 06:50.640 --> 06:52.407 Amma abu mafi muni daga komai shi ne: 06:52.407 --> 06:59.929 Muna biyan kuɗi ne don rahotanni masu son kai gaba ɗaya, masu yaudara da daidaitattu, waɗanda ke haifar da babban rarrabuwar 06:59.929 --> 07:03.990 kawuna a cikin al'umma kuma ke hana kowace tattaunawa a fili. 07:03.990 --> 07:09.749 Kla.TV ta yi rikodin yanayin da ba za a iya jurewa ba a "maballin kafofin watsa labarai na tilas" cikin 07:09.749 --> 07:13.100 cikakken bayani, kuma muna ba da shawarar kallon shirin: 07:13.100 --> 07:18.968 Harajin tilas na makaman yaki kafofin watsa labarai/ Dalilai 40 da yasa ban sake biya ba (ta Ivo Sasek).