WEBVTT 00:00.300 --> 00:08.442 A ranar 3 ga Satumba, 2024, wata kotu ta yanke hukunci a karon farko cewa buƙatar yin allurar rigakafi a wurin aiki a lokacin 00:08.442 --> 00:13.010 annobar coronavirus watakila ta saba wa kundin tsarin mulki. 00:13.010 --> 00:19.479 Wata mataimakiyar jinya daga Lower Saxony ta shigar da ƙara kan haramcin shiga da aiki da 00:19.479 --> 00:23.716 gundumar Osnabrück ta kakaba a shekarar 2022. 00:23.716 --> 00:29.630 An ba ta wannan ne lokacin da ta kasa bin buƙatar wurin na yin allurar rigakafi. 00:29.630 --> 00:36.210 NDR ta ruwaito: "Daga hangen alkalai na Osnabrück, tilastawar yin rigakafi ga ma'aikatan jinya ta karya 00:36.210 --> 00:40.510 hakkin asali na cikakken lafiyar jiki da 'yancin sana'a." 00:40.510 --> 00:46.527 A bazarar shekarar 2022, Kotun Kasa ta Tarayya ta bayyana tilastawar yin rigakafi ga ma'aikatan kula da lafiya a matsayin 00:46.527 --> 00:51.152 abin da ya dace da doka. Duk da haka, Kotun Gudanarwa a Osnabrück ta yanke hukunci yanzu cewa 00:51.152 --> 00:54.250 'yancin yanke shawara na hukumomi abin tambaya ne. 00:54.250 --> 00:59.864 Kamar yadda mataimakiyar jinya mai kara ta jayayya, an riga an sani a lokacin cewa allurar 00:59.864 --> 01:02.596 rigakafin coronavirus ba ta hana kamuwa da cuta. 01:02.596 --> 01:07.156 Wannan ya bayyana daga ka'idojin RKI da aka wallafa a wannan bazara. 01:07.156 --> 01:16.658 Kotun ta ƙara bayyana a cikin sanarwar manema labarai: "Dangane da mintuna na tawagar rikicin Covid-19 ta Cibiyar Robert Koch 01:16.658 --> 01:24.487 (RKI) da yanzu ake da su, da kuma shaidar da Farfesa Dr. Schaade, Shugaban RKI, ya bayar a yau, ana iya 01:24.487 --> 01:29.103 yin shakka kan 'yancin tsarin yanke shawara na hukuma." 01:29.103 --> 01:34.481 Wannan yana da tasiri mai faɗi. Jaridar yanar gizo Tichys Einblick ta rubuta: 01:34.481 --> 01:43.256 A nan gaba, hukumar shari'a ba za ta sake iya nuni ga 'yancin kimiyya na RKI a cikin hukuncin kotu ba. 01:43.256 --> 01:52.355 Kotun gudanarwa mai hurumi ta dakatar da shari'ar a ranar 3 ga Satumba, 2024, ta kuma tura al'amarin zuwa 01:52.355 --> 02:00.276 Kotun Kasa ta Tarayya, domin kotun gudanarwa kanta ba ta da ikon ƙin amincewa da ƙa'idodin doka. 02:00.276 --> 02:08.930 Yanzu, Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya a Karlsruhe dole ta yanke shawara ko buƙatar yin allurar rigakafi a wurin 02:08.930 --> 02:17.437 aiki da haramcin aiki da ke tattare da shi sun keta hakkin asali na cikakken jiki da 'yancin sana'a. 02:17.437 --> 02:24.903 Masani na bayanai Tom Lausen ya halarci zaman kotu a Osnabrück kuma ya yi sharhi kamar haka: 02:24.903 --> 02:34.760 Kotun ta zaɓi wasu sassa daban-daban na mintuna kuma a zahiri tana son tambayar Mista Schaade abin da yake cewa game da su. 02:34.760 --> 02:44.535 Don haka, mintuna na RKI – duka waɗanda Paul Schreyer ya fara cire ta hanyar buƙatar IFG da kuma waɗanda aka 02:44.535 --> 02:49.950 daga baya – an yi amfani da su bisa doka a karon farko. 02:49.950 --> 03:00.139 Kotun ta gabatar da waɗannan mintuna, waɗanda suka ƙunshi shafuka 57 gaba ɗaya, sannan ta 03:00.139 --> 03:05.343 ba Mista Schaade da abokinsa damar samun su. 03:05.343 --> 03:09.969 Sannan sai suka yi bayani kan wasu batutuwa, ciki har da annobar da ke addabar wadanda ba su 03:09.969 --> 03:12.510 yi rigakafi ba da kuma sauran batutuwa da dama. 03:12.510 --> 03:15.296 Kuma kotun ta yi aiki mai kyau sosai a kan hakan. 03:15.296 --> 03:20.900 Shugaban musamman ya kasance mai ƙwazo ƙwarai da gaske – ya yi tambayoyi masu matuƙar daidaito. 03:20.900 --> 03:23.916 Wasu abubuwa masu matuƙar ban mamaki sun bayyana. 03:23.916 --> 03:31.384 Babu wanda ya gane wannan, ko ma Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya ba, kuma ina ganin kowa ya yi matuƙar mamaki. 03:31.384 --> 03:40.172 Abin da ya fi ban sha'awa shi ne cewa Mista Schaade ya bayyana cewa batun kimanta haɗari, wato haɓaka matakin haɗari, a fili ba 03:40.172 --> 03:48.269 lallai ne ya kasance ƙarƙashin ƙwararren kimantawa na RKI ba, sai dai ya zama umarnin siyasa, ko watakila abin da ake 03:48.269 --> 03:52.089 kira matsalar gudanarwa, kamar yadda ya dade yana kiran sa. 03:52.089 --> 04:00.107 Don haka akwai matsalolin kimiyya da na gudanarwa, kuma Mista Schaade ya bayyana a fili cewa wannan ya shafi batutuwan 04:00.107 --> 04:07.935 gudanarwa, don haka yanzu mun sani daga wurin Mista Schaade cewa haɓaka haɗari don kulle-kullen a wancan lokacin – kodayake ba a 04:07.935 --> 04:13.500 faɗi hakan kai tsaye ba, yanzu za a iya fahimtar hakan a fili daga bayanin – haɓaka haɗarin 04:13.500 --> 04:17.854 umarnin gudanarwa ne ko umarnin gudanarwar ƙungiya. 04:17.854 --> 04:20.661 To, na karɓi bayanan yanzu. 04:20.661 --> 04:28.911 A gaskiya, majalisar ta yanke hukunci kuma, a cewar rahoton, majalisar ta ɗauki wajibcin da ya shafi cibiyar na samar da 04:28.911 --> 04:35.167 hujja, wato wajibcin yin rigakafi ga ma'aikatan lafiya tun aƙalla daga 7 ga Nuwamba 2022, a 04:35.167 --> 04:38.940 matsayin abin da ya saba wa kundin tsarin mulki. 04:38.940 --> 04:45.187 Bayani ko hujjar a halin yanzu ana sauraron sa a kotu, kuma a bayyane akwai abin da ake kira umarnin turawa. 04:45.187 --> 04:49.288 Wannan na nufin cewa Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya yanzu za ta yi hukunci ne a kan wannan 04:49.288 --> 04:52.863 takamaiman lokaci. Za a biyo da ƙarin bayani daga baya. 04:52.863 --> 04:58.088 Shin Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya za ta ɗauki waɗanda ke da alhaki su ɗauki alhaki 04:58.088 --> 05:01.623 kuma ta amince da rashin adalcin da aka aikata? 05:01.623 --> 05:09.797 Kla.TV, tare da miliyoyin 'yan ƙasa da suka sha matsin lamba mai girma a lokacin annobar coronavirus, za su bi diddigin 05:09.797 --> 05:14.472 hukuncin da Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya ke shirin yanke! 05:14.472 --> 05:22.180 A cikin jerin sunayen ƙarshe, an nuna sassan fashewa daga rubutun sauraron shari'ar kotu na mai nazarin bayanai Tom Lausen. 05:22.180 --> 05:31.680 NiUS ta wallafa mu'amalar bayyana sirri tsakanin alkalin shari'a mai jagoranci da Shugaban RKI Lars Schaade.