WEBVTT 00:02.976 --> 00:10.162 A farkon watan Maris na shekarar 2024, an wallafa wasu fayiloli da suka zubo daga Environmental Progress, wata ƙungiya 00:10.162 --> 00:14.370 marar riba da Michael Shellenberger ya kafa kuma yake jagoranta. 00:14.370 --> 00:21.066 Takardu da bidiyo sun bayyana yadda ake gudanar da harkokin cikin Kungiyar Kwararru ta Duniya don 00:21.066 --> 00:24.873 Lafiyar Transgender, wadda aka fi sani da WPATH. 00:24.873 --> 00:34.610 Kla.TV ta taƙaita kuma ta yi sharhi kan wallafar German Epoch Times a gare ku, tare da ɓangarori daga fayilolin WPATH. 00:34.610 --> 00:41.778 Ana ɗaukar ƙungiyar WPATH a matsayin babban ƙwararren hukuma a fannin kula da maganin mutanen da ke bayyana kansu a matsayin 00:41.778 --> 00:47.906 transgender ko kuma ke fama da rashin daidaiton jinsi (gender dysphoria), wanda ke nufin bambanci tsakanin 00:47.906 --> 00:51.904 jinsinsu na halitta da ainihin jinsin da suke ji a zuciyarsu. 00:51.904 --> 00:59.259 A cewar bayanan da ta fitar da kanta, WPATH tana wallafa ƙa'idodin kulawa da ake amincewa da su a duniya, waɗanda ke 00:59.259 --> 01:07.616 wakiltar yarjejeniyar ƙwararru kan maganin kwakwalwa, na tunani, na likitanci da na tiyata na rashin jin daɗin jinsi. 01:07.616 --> 01:13.260 Masana ya kamata su gane waɗannan ƙa'idodin a matsayin shawarwari mafi kyau don jagorantar su 01:13.260 --> 01:16.802 wajen kula da marasa lafiya masu canjin jinsi. 01:16.802 --> 01:24.352 Amma ku duba da kanku, masu kallo na ƙauna, irin waɗannan "ka'idoji" da gaske. 01:24.352 --> 01:27.715 Aikin sauya jinsi ba tare da cikakken bayani ba 01:27.715 --> 01:33.440 Yawancin "marasa lafiya" gabaɗaya ba su san abin da suke shiga ba idan suka amince da 01:33.440 --> 01:37.456 magungunan hana balaga ko tiyatar sauya jinsi. 01:37.456 --> 01:44.511 Fayilolin da suka zube sun nuna cewa likitocin WPATH da sauran kwararrun lafiya suna amincewa a bayan ƙofofi 01:44.511 --> 01:51.146 masu rufewa cewa ba za su iya samun cikakken izinin sani daga iyaye da yara ba kwata-kwata! 01:51.146 --> 01:59.411 Domin, kamar yadda Rahoton Shellenberger ya bayyana: "WPATH na goyon bayan a fili cewa 'yan ƙasa ƙasa da shekaru da 01:59.411 --> 02:08.350 iyalansu su yarda da waɗannan magungunan hormone da tiyata bisa ga wani ra'ayi na ciki da ba a fayyace ba." 02:08.350 --> 02:15.504 A cikin sirri, duk da haka, wasu mambobi sun amince cewa ba zai yiwu a samu amincewa mai cikakken sani ba kwata-kwata. 02:15.504 --> 02:21.577 A cikin harshe mai sauƙi, wannan yana nufin cewa matasa ko iyaye sun amince da magani da ba su fahimta ba. 02:21.577 --> 02:27.881 Ba za ka iya kimanta sakamako da girman abin da zai faru ba, misali rashin haihuwa har abada, ciwo, murya da ba za ta sake 02:27.881 --> 02:31.907 dawowa ba, rashin ikon sarrafa fitsari da sauran abubuwa da dama. 02:31.907 --> 02:38.534 Bayanan da suka zubo sun nuna cewa Dr. Daniel Metzger, wani likitan endocrinologist na Kanada kuma babban memba na WPATH, ya 02:38.534 --> 02:44.573 ce a tsakanin abokan aikinsa cewa likitocin jinsi "suna yawan bayyana irin waɗannan abubuwa ga yara waɗanda ba su 02:44.573 --> 02:49.024 ma ɗauki darasin ilmin halittu a makarantar sakandare ba ". 02:49.024 --> 02:55.778 Metzger ya ƙara da cewa ko manya ma suna da ilimi kaɗan sosai game da yawancin waɗannan hanyoyin magani. 02:55.778 --> 03:04.361 A cikin wallafinsa, Shellenberger ya lura: "Ba magani ba ne, domin doka ta farko ita ce kada a yi lahani. 03:04.361 --> 03:09.211 Kuma hakan na buƙatar amincewa bisa cikakken sani." 03:09.211 --> 03:15.014 Wannan ba shi da ɗabi'a kuma sakaci ne! Duk da haka, likitocin WPATH suna ci gaba da magungunansu – 03:15.014 --> 03:19.648 waɗanda a gaskiya ya kamata a kira su "yankan jiki". 03:19.648 --> 03:22.525 Bayani kan rashin haihuwa 03:22.525 --> 03:30.017 Ka'idojin WPATH sun ce likitoci dole ne su sanar da marasa lafiyarsu game da yiwuwar rasa haihuwa kuma su ba su 03:30.017 --> 03:34.436 shawara kan zaɓuɓɓukan da ake da su don kiyaye haihuwa. 03:34.436 --> 03:41.399 Sai dai, Dr. Metzger ya bayyana wa kwamitin WPATH a bayan ƙofofi masu rufewa: "Koyaushe ra'ayi ne mai kyau a 03:41.399 --> 03:45.943 tattauna batun kiyaye ikon haihuwa da matashi mai shekaru 14." 03:45.943 --> 03:54.425 Amma na san ina magana da bango mai bulo. Yawancin yara ba su kai matsayin yin magana da gaske game da haihuwa ba tukuna. 03:54.425 --> 04:02.592 Dianne Berg, masanin halayyar yara kuma mai jawabi a WPATH, ta bayyana a fili a kan dandamali cewa masana ba sa sa 04:02.592 --> 04:11.138 ran yara da matasa za su fahimci gaba ɗaya ainihin tasirin matakan da ake ɗauka ga mutane masu canjin jinsi. 04:11.138 --> 04:18.536 Muna bayyana a fili kuma da ƙarfi: yara da matasa suna ba da izini ga magungunan sauya 04:18.536 --> 04:24.087 jinsi, amma ba za su iya kimanta iyakokinsu ba. 04:24.087 --> 04:27.232 tatsuniya cewa "komai ana iya juyawa" 04:27.232 --> 04:32.015 Abin da ake kira "likitocin tabbatar da jinsi" su ne likitoci da ake sa ran za su tallafa 04:32.015 --> 04:34.966 wa kuma su tabbatar da ainihin jinsin mutum. 04:34.966 --> 04:41.843 Waɗannan likitoci da 'yan siyasa masu goyon baya sun yi tallata amfani da magungunan hana balaga a California a bainar jama'a a 04:41.843 --> 04:45.864 matsayin magani mai aminci kuma, sama da komai, mai iya juyawa. 04:45.864 --> 04:52.031 Yana taimakawa wajen rage haɗarin kashe kansu a tsakanin matasa da ke cikin rikici da kansu. 04:52.031 --> 04:58.741 Sai dai, rikicin shari'a da ya shafi Cibiyar 'Yancin Amurka ya nuna cewa shan magungunan hana balaga yana da "gurbatawa 04:58.741 --> 05:01.676 madawwami ba tare da wata shakka ba", a cewar Ms Dhillon . 05:01.676 --> 05:07.708 Wani doka a California har ma tana ba yara masu shekaru 12 damar "gudu daga gida" su nemi 05:07.708 --> 05:12.018 mafaka a gidajen tallafin LGBTQ domin su sami 'yanci. 05:12.018 --> 05:20.079 Ana iya aiwatar da matakan kiwon lafiya, kamar amfani da magungunan hana balaga, maganin maye gurbin hormones da tiyata, 05:20.079 --> 05:24.721 ba tare da izinin iyaye ba, kuma wannan ya kasance cikin doka. 05:24.721 --> 05:31.452 An yi watsi gaba ɗaya da sakamakon irin waɗannan matakan da ba za a iya mayar da su ba (kamar rashin haihuwa har abada, 05:31.452 --> 05:38.428 sauye-sauyen muryar da ba za a iya mayarwa ba, matsalolin lafiya na yau da kullum, da sauransu) a cikin doka. 05:38.428 --> 05:49.088 Likitocin WPATH sun amince (wasu a sirri, wasu a fili) cewa ba su san duk tasirin dogon lokaci na tiyatar sauya jinsi ba. 05:49.088 --> 05:56.384 Maimakon wajibcin kulawa da aka saba yi a fannin kiwon lafiya – tare da cikakken bayani ga marasa lafiya – 05:56.384 --> 06:00.678 an fi rinjayar "gwajin jima'i" a nan, in ji Ms Dhillon. 06:00.678 --> 06:07.500 Domin kawo ƙarshen waɗannan ayyuka, suna ganin cewa likitocin da suka yi ƙarya ga marasa lafiyarsu da gangan ya 06:07.500 --> 06:11.648 kamata a tuhume su da laifin sakaci a aikin likitanci. 06:11.648 --> 06:19.736 Erin Friday, lauya kuma mataimakiyar darakta na Our Duty , ta kuma shaida cewa fayilolin WPATH sun nuna 06:19.736 --> 06:24.469 cewa hanyoyin sake fasalin jinsi "babban gwaji ne". 06:24.469 --> 06:30.455 A ranar Juma'a, an ambaci batun wata yarinya mai shekaru 16 wadda ta samu manyan kumburin hanta bayan ta 06:30.455 --> 06:34.297 sha testosterone (hormones na namiji) da wasu magunguna. 06:34.297 --> 06:39.268 Likitan cutar daji da likitan tiyata sun danganta wannan ga maganin hormone. 06:39.268 --> 06:47.250 Takardun WPATH da suka zubo sun kuma tattauna sauran matsaloli da dama da aka sani ko kuma masu yiwuwa. 06:47.250 --> 06:56.896 Rashin bincike mai muhimmanci daidai haka, musamman ma rashin nazarin dogon lokaci, yana girgiza fuskar karya ta "WPATH". 06:56.896 --> 07:06.472 A cewar Erin Friday, fayilolin WPATH ba kawai bayyanar wata ƙungiya ce da ta ketare iyakokinta ba; sama da komai, suna bayyana 07:06.472 --> 07:12.600 mummunan sakaci a aikin likitanci da ƙarya da aka bazu sosai. 07:12.600 --> 07:15.025 Siyasa da yin lobi 07:15.025 --> 07:22.129 Masanin halayyar ɗan adam na Amurka, Shannae Anderson, ta jaddada cewa ƙa'idodin WPATH su ne kaɗai maganin da ake yarda 07:22.129 --> 07:26.240 da shi a ƙasashe da dama, abin da take ganin abin damuwa ne. 07:26.240 --> 07:30.943 Babban matsalar ita ce 'yan siyasa suna hana masu ba da maganin tunani su yi magana cikin 07:30.943 --> 07:33.757 'yanci da marasa lafiya game da damuwar jinsi . 07:33.757 --> 07:39.055 Wannan yana takura wa 'yancin faɗin albarkacin baki kuma yana hana duk wani yunƙuri na taimako. 07:39.055 --> 07:45.434 Kamar sauran masu suka, Anderson na sa ran cewa bayyanar fayilolin WPATH zai haifar da zaman sauraro a 07:45.434 --> 07:49.395 Majalisar Dokoki ta Amurka da ƙarin rikice-rikicen shari'a. 07:49.395 --> 07:56.350 Tana fatan wannan zai dawo da 'yancin faɗin albarkacin baki domin masanan maganin kwakwalwa su iya yin aikinsu. 07:56.350 --> 08:05.216 An ma yi musu barazanar a soke lasisinsu idan suka bayyana ra'ayi da ya sha bamban da akidar WPATH da ake bi. 08:05.216 --> 08:11.253 Anderson ya ƙara jaddada cewa bayyana a fili da koyar da akidar transgender a makarantu 08:11.253 --> 08:15.008 ba daidai ba ne kuma yana da haɗari ga yara. 08:15.008 --> 08:19.066 Ba a kamata a gauraya fafutukar siyasa da aikin likitanci ba. 08:19.066 --> 08:26.092 Wata ƙungiya da ke bin manufofin siyasa ba ta damu da lafiyar marasa lafiya. 08:26.092 --> 08:33.849 A nan ma, a bayyane yake cewa fayilolin WPATH sun ƙunshi hujjoji masu yawa cewa 08:33.849 --> 08:38.402 ƙungiyar mai fafutuka ce, ba ƙungiya ta kimiyya ba. 08:38.402 --> 08:45.217 A cewar masanin halayyar ɗan adam Anderson, abin damuwa ne kuma cewa ana aiwatar da matakan sauyin rayuwa masu 08:45.217 --> 08:50.291 tsanani ga mutanen da ke da matsanancin matsalolin tunani. 08:50.291 --> 08:54.473 Ayyukan tiyata ba tare da la'akari da matsalolin tunani ba 08:54.473 --> 08:59.944 Lawyer Friday kuma yana suka kan cewa "likitocin tabbatar da jinsi" suna watsi da matsalolin lafiyar 08:59.944 --> 09:06.432 kwakwalwa na marasa lafiya, duk da cewa ka'idojin WPATH sun tanadi cewa ya kamata a magance su gaba ɗaya. 09:06.432 --> 09:13.301 Matsanancin cututtukan hankali, kamar matuƙar schizophrenia, damuwa ko cutar bipolar, ba za a 09:13.301 --> 09:17.468 magance su yadda ya kamata ba a cikin "magani". 09:17.468 --> 09:25.405 Juma'a ta ƙara bayyana cewa yara ba su da ikon yanke shawara bisa cikakken sani game da magungunan da suka shafi jinsi. 09:25.405 --> 09:34.194 Yawancin matasa masu jin rashin daidaito na jinsi a ƙarshe za su yarda da jikin halittarsu a wani lokaci na gaba. 09:34.194 --> 09:43.360 Anderson kuma yana ganin cewa ba a yi isasshen bincike kan tasirin tunani na dogon lokaci na irin waɗannan matakai ba. 09:43.360 --> 09:45.294 A kan hukuncin da ya fi kyau na mutum 09:45.294 --> 09:52.720 A wata hira tsakanin Jordan Peterson, fitaccen masanin halayyar ɗan adam na Kanada kuma marubuci, da Michael 09:52.720 --> 10:02.053 Shellenberger, wanda ya wallafa fayilolin WPATH da suka zubo, Shellenberger ya zargi likitocin WPATH da: 10:02.053 --> 10:09.562 Sannan sai su zauna kawai su ce, 'Muna da gaske ba mu san yadda za mu warware wannan matsala ba.' 10:09.562 --> 10:18.214 Me ya sa suke ƙarƙashin rinjayar wata akida har suna aikata waɗannan zalunci kuma ba sa taɓa tambayar kansu – maimakon su yi 10:18.214 --> 10:22.728 tunanin cewa watakila bai kamata su aikata su ba kwata-kwata? 10:22.728 --> 10:30.080 Nazarin da masanin halayyar ɗan adam Ken Zucker ya gudanar ya nuna cewa daga cikin yara maza da mata masu shekaru 2 zuwa 12 da 10:30.080 --> 10:37.431 aka ƙayyade a matsayin masu jin rashin daidaito na jinsi a cikin bincike biyu daban-daban amma ba su yi canjin zamantakewa ba, 10:37.431 --> 10:43.149 kashi 88 cikin ɗari daga baya, a matsayin matasa da manya, sun bayar da rahoton cewa ba sa fama da 10:43.149 --> 10:46.516 wannan yanayin kuma sun ji daɗin jinsinsu na asali. 10:46.516 --> 10:48.677 "Ku bar su su kasance kadai har sai sun cika shekaru 18." 10:48.677 --> 10:53.075 "Wannan shi ne shawarar Ken Zucker don magani, amma an tilasta masa ya bar kasuwanci saboda masu 10:53.075 --> 10:56.162 tsattsauran ra'ayi shekaru goma da suka wuce," in ji Peterson. 10:56.162 --> 11:00.644 Yanzu, a aikace ana yawan yin akasin haka. 11:04.949 --> 11:10.458 Ana ba da shawarar yin magunguna masu tsanani da ayyukan tiyata yanzu. 11:10.458 --> 11:15.498 Ana firgita iyaye su yi imani cewa 'ya'yansu na iya kashe kansu idan ba su bi umarninsu 11:15.498 --> 11:19.788 ba – magana ce marar hujja kuma ba gaskiya ba. 11:19.788 --> 11:26.647 Sai su miƙa wannan magani mai matuƙar muni da sakamako mai tsanani da ba za a iya tunani ba kuma 11:26.647 --> 11:31.171 su gaya musu cewa haka za su gano ainihin kansu. 11:31.171 --> 11:38.752 Wannan zai yi daidai da ɗaya daga cikin manyan skandalolin kiwon lafiya na Amurka: lobotomy. Ko ma ya fi shi. 11:38.752 --> 11:46.944 Ƙaramin tsokaci: A tsakiyar ƙarni na 20, lobotomy wata mummunar aikin tiyata ce inda ake saka kayan aiki 11:46.944 --> 11:52.230 masu kaifi cikin kwakwalwa don yanke haɗin lobes na gaba. 11:52.230 --> 12:00.397 Wani lokaci ana buga ice pick ta ramar ido har cikin kwakwalwa. Wannan ya haifar da raunuka da yawa da kuma mutuwa. 12:00.397 --> 12:04.508 A wannan lokaci, zai yi yawa a yi nazari sosai kan lobotomy. 12:04.508 --> 12:10.948 Shi ya sa muka shirya muku wani shiri na biyo baya, ku masu kallo, inda muke kwatanta lobotomy da 12:10.948 --> 12:15.240 tiyatar sauya jinsi , wanda ya kamata ku kalla tabbas. 12:15.240 --> 12:17.701 Amma "WPATH" yana yin hakan duk da haka 12:17.701 --> 12:26.732 Duk da duk waɗannan muryoyin gargaɗi, shugabar WPATH mai rikon mukami, Dr Marci Bowers, ta kare kanta da ƙungiyar, 12:26.732 --> 12:31.876 inda ta fitar da wannan sanarwa a ranar 5 ga Maris, 2024: 12:31.876 --> 12:42.663 WPATH ƙungiya ce da koyaushe take bisa kimiyya da hujjoji, kuma manyan ƙungiyoyin lafiya a duniya suna amincewa da shawarwarinta. 12:42.663 --> 12:50.288 Mu ne ƙwararru da suka fi kowa fahimtar bukatun lafiya na mutanen transgender da masu bambancin jinsi – kuma muna adawa da 12:50.288 --> 12:58.496 waɗanda ke ɓata suna da ƙaryata sahihancin bambancin ainihi da bukatun masu rikitarwa na wannan al'umma ta hanyar yada tsoro. 12:58.496 --> 13:07.377 'Yan kwanaki bayan Environmental Progress na Shellenberger ya wallafa fayilolin WPATH, har ma Hukumar Kula da Lafiya ta Ƙasa 13:07.377 --> 13:12.683 ta Birtaniya ta daina amfani da magungunan hana balaga ga yara. 13:12.683 --> 13:15.947 Watakila sun ji wani mummunan tunani game da shi. 13:15.947 --> 13:24.966 Yayinda wasu kasashen Turai a kalla ke suka yin tiyata ko maganin hormone ga yara ƙanana, ko ma suka haramta su, sauyin jinsi 13:24.966 --> 13:34.656 zuwa jinsi na adawa a Jamus za a sauƙaƙa shi gwargwadon iko ta Dokar Kainin Yanke Shawara da aka kwanan nan amince da ita. 13:34.656 --> 13:40.245 Babu wanda zai iya hango haɗarori da sakamakon dogon lokaci a halin yanzu, kamar yadda Ƙungiyar Likitocin Jamus ma ta tabbatar, 13:40.245 --> 13:43.941 watakila don ta cire kanta daga madaurin rataya a kan lokaci. 13:43.941 --> 13:54.206 Ya yi magana a fili yana adawa da maganin toshe balaga ko hormones masu sauya jinsi ga matasa ba bisa ga binciken kimiyya ba. 13:54.206 --> 14:02.204 Bayar da magungunan hana balaga ko hormones na jinsi daban "wani nau'i ne na gwajin likitanci a kan yara, wanda, 14:02.204 --> 14:07.388 daga cikin sauran abubuwa, ke haifar da rasa ikon haihuwa." 14:07.388 --> 14:15.823 Magungunan sun haɗa da matakan da ba za a iya mayar da su ba a jikin ɗan adam na ƙanana waɗanda gabaɗaya lafiyar jikinsu 14:15.823 --> 14:20.542 ta dace. Dole ne a ba wa kulawa da jin daɗin yaron fifiko. 14:20.542 --> 14:31.651 Bugu da ƙari, wakilan Taron Lafiya sun kuma amince da ƙuduri da ke kiran gwamnatin tarayya da ta gyara Dokar Kanta Tsara Kanta. 14:31.651 --> 14:33.056 Don taƙaita: 14:33.056 --> 14:40.432 Duk da cewa a Jamus ba a yarda yara da matasa ƙasa da shekaru 18 su tuka mota ko su sha giya da kansu ba saboda ba su 14:40.432 --> 14:47.335 da hangen nesa na fahimtar yiwuwar sakamakon, ƙungiyar masu fafutukar jinsi na ƙarfafa sauyin jinsi ga ƙanana. 14:47.335 --> 14:53.378 Ana sa ran yara za su yanke shawara a duk tsawon rayuwarsu, shawara da ba za su iya fahimta ko kimantawa ba. 14:53.378 --> 15:00.217 Likitocin WPATH suna yankan jikin masu lafiya ba tare da sanin sakamakon dogon lokaci ba. 15:00.217 --> 15:06.920 Amma idan suka yi nazari sosai kan gaskiyoyin da suka wanzu, kamar ƙwayoyin sankara da ke bayyana bayan maganin hormone 15:06.920 --> 15:14.206 da nakasa da lalacewar jiki har abada bayan tiyata, dole ne su yarda da kansu cewa suna ɗauke da babban nauyin laifi. 15:14.206 --> 15:22.405 A cikin marasa lafiya maza, misali, mafi kyawun yanayi bayan yin tiyatar gina farji shi ne samun rami da dole ne a 15:22.405 --> 15:27.264 faɗaɗa shi har abada, tare da matuƙar raguwar aikin jima'i. 15:27.264 --> 15:31.586 Wasu kuma suna fama da matsaloli masu tsanani kamar kwanyar mahaifa cike da jini, 15:31.586 --> 15:35.247 matsalolin yin fitsari da ramukan haɗin fitsari. 15:35.247 --> 15:42.179 "Ba za ka iya rayuwa da mutunci irin wannan ba," in ji wata mai shekaru 32 wacce ta fuskanci kuskuren likita, tana fama da ciwo 15:42.179 --> 15:46.713 mai dindindin, rashin jin motsi da matsalolin hanyar fitsari. 15:46.713 --> 15:48.608 Rayuwa a cikin mafarki mai ban tsoro! 15:48.608 --> 15:53.522 Masana da za su iya taimakawa waɗanda ke fama ana hana su magana. 15:53.522 --> 15:59.273 Iyaye da ke son kare 'ya'yansu daga yanke shawara cikin gaggawa da ke da sakamako marasa tabbas 15:59.273 --> 16:02.816 na tsawon rai za a soke haƙƙinsu na kulawa da su. 16:02.816 --> 16:09.460 A ƙarshe, mun taƙaita madaidaicin furucin mashahurin mai jawabi Laura Aboli kamar haka. 16:09.460 --> 16:15.406 Motsin transgender ba motsin asali daga talakawa ba ne , sai dai ya fito ne daga "mafi kololuwa". 16:15.406 --> 16:19.025 Wannan sharri ne da ke matsowa zuwa ga transhumanism. 16:19.025 --> 16:27.199 Yana sa mu tambayi mafi muhimmin ra'ayi na ainihin mutum: jinsinmu. 16:27.199 --> 16:35.843 Abin baƙin ciki a nan shi ne cewa wannan ajandar ci gaba ta riga ta jawo lahani na jiki, na tunani da na halayyar zuciya ga 16:35.843 --> 16:40.292 yara da matasa masu ƙaruwa, kuma lamarin na ƙara tabarbarewa. 16:40.292 --> 16:41.892 Dole ne a dakatar da wannan!