WEBVTT 00:00.462 --> 00:06.716 Wata mataimakiyar jinya daga Lower Saxony ta shigar da ƙara kan haramcin shiga da aiki da 00:06.716 --> 00:11.166 gundumar Osnabrück ta kakaba mata (a shekarar 2022). 00:11.166 --> 00:19.882 Ta karɓi wannan ne lokacin da ta kasa bin buƙatar allurar rigakafi ta cibiyar. NDR ta ruwaito: 00:19.882 --> 00:24.972 "Daga hangen alkalai na Osnabrück, tilastawar yin rigakafi ga ma'aikatan kula da lafiya ta karya hakkin 00:24.972 --> 00:27.925 asali na cikakken lafiyar jiki da 'yancin sana'a. " 00:27.925 --> 00:31.737 A bazarar shekarar 2022, Kotun Kasa ta Tarayya ta ayyana tilastawar yin rigakafi ga 00:31.737 --> 00:34.238 ma'aikatan kula da lafiya a matsayin abin doka. 00:34.238 --> 00:41.827 Sai dai Kotun Gudanarwa ta Osnabrück ta yanke hukunci yanzu cewa 'yancin tsarin yanke shawarar hukumomi abin tambaya ne. 00:41.827 --> 00:46.974 Kamar yadda mataimakiyar jinya mai kara ta jayayya, an riga an sani a lokacin cewa allurar 00:46.974 --> 00:50.020 rigakafin coronavirus ba ta hana kamuwa da cuta. 00:50.020 --> 00:54.606 Wannan ya bayyana daga ka'idojin RKI da aka wallafa a wannan bazara. 00:54.606 --> 01:04.174 Kotun ta ci gaba a cikin sanarwar manema labarai: "Dangane da mintuna na tawagar rikicin Covid-19 ta Robert Koch Institute 01:04.174 --> 01:12.565 (RKI) da yanzu ake da su da kuma shaidar da Farfesa Dr. Schaade, Shugaban RKI, ya bayar a yau, dole ne a yi 01:12.565 --> 01:16.480 tambaya kan 'yancin tsarin yanke shawara na hukuma." 01:16.480 --> 01:27.217 Kotun gudanarwa mai hurumi ta dakatar da shari'ar doka a ranar 3 ga Satumba, 2024, kuma ta tura al'amarin zuwa Kotun Kasa ta 01:27.217 --> 01:33.460 Tarayya, domin kotun gudanarwa kanta ba ta da ikon soke doka. 01:33.460 --> 01:41.957 Yanzu, Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya a Karlsruhe dole ta yanke shawara ko buƙatar yin allurar rigakafi a wurin 01:41.957 --> 01:50.343 aiki da haramcin aiki da ke tattare da shi sun keta hakkin asali na cikakken jiki da 'yancin sana'a. 01:50.343 --> 01:53.585 A lokacin, mun yi tambaya: 01:53.585 --> 01:58.806 "Shin Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya za ta ɗauki waɗanda ke da alhaki su ɗauki alhaki kuma ta amince 01:58.806 --> 02:02.310 da rashin adalcin da aka aikata a matsayin haka?" 02:02.310 --> 02:09.842 Kla.TV, tare da miliyoyin 'yan ƙasa da suka sha matsin lamba mai girma a lokacin annobar coronavirus, za su bi 02:09.842 --> 02:14.758 diddigin hukuncin da ke tafe na Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya! 02:14.758 --> 02:21.645 Yanzu Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya ta yanke hukunci kuma ta sanar a ranar 20 ga Fabrairu, 2025 cewa ba 02:21.645 --> 02:26.622 za a karɓi shigarwar Kotun Gudanarwa ta Osnabrück ba. 02:26.622 --> 02:31.081 Kotun Kasa ta Tsarin Mulki ba ta bayyana cewa buƙatar yin allurar rigakafi da ke da 02:31.081 --> 02:34.320 alaƙa da wurin aiki ta dace da tsarin mulki ba. 02:34.320 --> 02:38.984 Ba a taba maganar wannan tambayar ba kwata-kwata dangane da abun ciki. 02:38.984 --> 02:43.724 Maimakon haka, Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya ta riga ta ƙi tura ƙarar daga Kotun 02:43.724 --> 02:48.004 Gudanarwa ta Osnabrück bisa hujjojin tsari kawai. 02:48.004 --> 02:55.210 Daga cikin sauran abubuwa, Kotun Gudanarwa ta Osnabrück ba ta yi cikakken bayani game da hukuncin asali na Kotun Kasa 02:55.210 --> 03:02.952 ta Tarayya ba a cikin korafin kundin tsarin mulki da aka shigar kan buƙatar yin rigakafi a wuraren kulawa. 03:02.952 --> 03:11.105 A cikin hukuncinsa na Afrilu 2022, inda Kotun Kasa ta ɗauki buƙatar yin rigakafi a wuraren kiwon lafiya a matsayin abin da ya 03:11.105 --> 03:16.133 dace da kundin tsarin mulki, ba kawai ta bi ƙimantawa na RKI ba. 03:16.133 --> 03:26.716 Haka kuma an samu ra'ayoyi da kimantawa na ƙwararru da dama, waɗanda Kotun Gudanarwa ta Osnabrück ba ta yi la'akari da su ba. 03:26.716 --> 03:34.407 Ka yi hakuri? Wannan yana kama da uzuri mara inganci don kauce wa magance rashin adalcin annobar coronavirus. 03:34.407 --> 03:39.879 A cikin hukunci na baya-bayan nan kan matakan coronavirus, Kotun Kasa ta Tarayya ta ɗauki bayanan hukuma 03:39.879 --> 03:43.701 na RKI a matsayin dogmar da ba za a iya musantawa ba. 03:43.701 --> 03:50.904 Kotun ta dage wajen jaddada cewa RKI cibiyar binciken kimiyya ce wadda ba ta ƙarƙashin tasirin 03:50.904 --> 03:56.763 siyasa, don haka tana sadaukar da kanta ga gaskiya kaɗai. 03:56.763 --> 04:05.094 Duk da haka, bisa ga mintuna na RKI da shaidar Shugaban RKI Farfesa Dr. Schaade, Kotun Gudanarwa ta Osnabrück ta 04:05.094 --> 04:15.187 bayyana a fili cewa an karkatar da sakamakon binciken RKI, an kauce masa ko ma an juya shi ta hanyar umarnin siyasa. 04:15.187 --> 04:31.944 Dangane da ka'idojin RKI, an rubuta umarni sama da 2,600 daga Ma'aikatar Lafiya ta Tarayya zuwa RKI tsakanin 2020 da 2023. 04:31.944 --> 04:37.409 Rubutattun mintuna da aka bayyana na Cibiyar Robert Koch sun tabbatar a sarari kuma ba tare da wata shakka ba 04:37.409 --> 04:43.120 cewa ba wai kawai RKI ta san cewa allurar rigakafin coronavirus ba ta ba da kariya ga wasu ba. 04:43.120 --> 04:51.408 Sun kuma nuna cewa a kowane lokaci cikin annobar coronavirus ba a samu wata barazana mai tsanani ga jama'a ba, kuma 04:51.408 --> 04:59.415 matakan coronavirus da 'yan siyasa suka kakaba ba su taɓa zama dole a fannin likitanci ko kimiyya ba. 04:59.415 --> 05:04.762 Duk da haka, Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya ba ta ɗauki waɗannan sakamakon a matsayin dama don sake nazarin dacewar 05:04.762 --> 05:08.600 buƙatar yin rigakafi a cibiyoyi na kiwon lafiya da tsarin mulki. 05:08.600 --> 05:15.431 Maimakon haka, Kotun Kasa ta Tarayya na matuƙar riƙe da ra'ayin ƙarya da aka dade ana ƙaryatawa cewa alluran rigakafin coronavirus 05:15.431 --> 05:24.114 suna ba da kariya daga kamuwa da cuta daga wasu, tana ɓoye a bayan "kimiyyar ƙwararru" na manyan ƙungiyoyin ƙwararru na Jamus. 05:24.114 --> 05:34.012 Don haka Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya ta yi amfani da uzuri cewa wasu ƙungiyoyin ƙwararru sun ɗauki matsayi iri ɗaya da na RKI. 05:34.012 --> 05:42.767 Ta yin haka, sun kasa ambata cewa gwamnati – wadda ke da iko a kan RKI – tare da manyan kafofin watsa labarai, ta takaita 05:42.767 --> 05:49.771 tattaunawar da aka yarda da ita har zuwa matakin da kawai ake sa ran manyan ƙungiyoyin ƙwararru za 05:49.771 --> 05:55.071 su bi gwamnati saboda tsoron fuskantar sakamako. 05:55.071 --> 05:59.612 An watsar da duk wani karkata daga layin da siyasa ta tsara a matsayin mugunta, an yi masa tsanani, 05:59.612 --> 06:02.950 an kuma hukunta shi a lokacin annobar coronavirus. 06:02.950 --> 06:10.776 Sakamakon haka, sama da likitoci 1,000 da suka dogara ga ra'ayoyin wasu ƙwararru kuma suka kauce daga labarin siyasa an 06:10.776 --> 06:16.169 gurfanar da su a gaban kotu, kuma a wasu lokuta an yanke musu hukuncin zaman gidan 06:16.169 --> 06:20.240 yari, an hana su aikin sana'a, da sauran tarar. 06:20.240 --> 06:22.912 Karshe: 06:22.912 --> 06:30.644 Gaskiyar cewa Kotun Tsarin Mulki ta Tarayya har yanzu tana ƙin amincewa da rashin adalcin da aka yi a baya a matsayin haka kuma 06:30.644 --> 06:37.585 ba ta ɗora wa masu alhaki alhaki ba, sai dai ta koma amfani da hujjoji marasa ƙarfi, yana nuna cewa muna fuskantar 06:37.585 --> 06:42.500 al'adar cin hanci da rashawa a siyasa da ma'aikatar shari'a. 06:42.500 --> 06:50.107 Yanzu da ka'idojin RKI suka fallasa wannan manufar da ba ta daidaita ba, tsarin shari'a (da ba shi daidaita ba) yana ƙarfafa 06:50.107 --> 06:59.432 kansa da uzuri, yana kuma ɓoye a bayan ƙungiyoyin ƙwararru masu bin gwamnati, wato, ƙirƙirar kimiyya ta ƙarya da ake sarrafawa. 06:59.432 --> 07:04.668 Ya bayyana sosai cewa manufar annobar da aka shirya, wato annobar da aka tsara kuma aka yi ƙarya, 07:04.668 --> 07:09.002 ita ce a ɓoye ta ta kowace hanya da ake buƙata. 07:09.002 --> 07:14.338 Kawai mutane ne za su iya dakatar da wannan haɗin gwiwa tsakanin siyasa, abin da ake kira kimiyya da shari'a. 07:14.338 --> 07:22.014 Don haka ku zo ku yi aiki tare da mu – ku raba wannan watsa shirye-shirye a duk tashoshin kafofin sada zumunta da ake da su!