WEBVTT 00:00.160 --> 00:04.928 Uwe Kranz jami'in 'yan sanda ne, tsohon babban mai ba da shawara na ma'aikata kuma tsohon shugaban 00:04.928 --> 00:08.160 Ofishin 'Yan Sanda na Binciken Laifuka na Jihar Thuringia. 00:08.160 --> 00:11.439 Shi ƙwararren ƙasa ne a Europol. 00:11.439 --> 00:14.933 A matsayinsa na ƙwararren masani kan batutuwan tsaro da ta'addanci, yana wallafa 00:14.933 --> 00:17.679 labarai akai-akai a kafofin watsa labarai da dama. 00:17.679 --> 00:26.199 Uwe Kranz ya dade yana yaki da laifukan tsari, tsattsauran ra'ayi da ta'addanci fiye da shekaru 50. 00:26.199 --> 00:30.359 A lokacin da yake kan mukami, ya kasance musamman mai himma wajen kare yara. 00:30.359 --> 00:34.920 Wannan ya bayyana idan ka duba fannoni na ayyuka a cikin aikinsa na ƙwararru: 00:34.920 --> 00:42.876 Shi wakili ne kan harkokin matasa, hana laifuka, yaki da tashin hankali na jima'i kan yara da safarar mutane 00:42.876 --> 00:50.399 da gabobin jiki a matakin ƙasa da ƙasa, kuma ya shiga aikin ƙungiyar manufofin laifuka. 00:50.399 --> 00:59.520 A shafinsa na yanar gizo, Uwe Kranz yana wallafa labarai kan batutuwa kamar "cin zarafin jima'i ga yara" da "sarrafa tunani". 00:59.520 --> 01:03.890 A matsayin mai binciken laifuka, yana ba da haske kan "deep state" kuma yana lura da abubuwan da 01:03.890 --> 01:07.120 ke faruwa a duniya a halin yanzu daga ritayarsa. 01:07.120 --> 01:12.474 Haka kuma yana ba da gudunmawar kwarewarsa da iliminsa a matsayin memba kuma mai jawabi a tarukan manema labarai da 01:12.474 --> 01:18.680 ƙungiyoyi mashahuri kamar Axion Resist da MWGFD e.V. (Masana Lafiya da Masana Kimiyya don Lafiya, Yanci da Dimokuradiyya). 01:18.680 --> 01:24.840 An kafa su da nufin kare jin daɗin yara da kuma kare 'yanci da mulkin doka. 01:24.840 --> 01:32.379 Anan, ya yi magana kan batutuwa ciki har da laifin masu cin zarafin yara, fara jima'i tun suna ƙanana da safarar yara. 01:36.439 --> 01:42.481 Girmamawa ta musamman ce a gare ni in yi maraba da wannan ƙwararren mai binciken 01:42.481 --> 01:46.480 laifuka, Uwe Kranz, a nan a taron AZK na 22. 01:46.480 --> 01:48.519 Girmamawa duk nawa ce. 01:48.519 --> 01:51.599 Yana da kyau ganin ka anan. 01:51.599 --> 01:59.239 Eh, kana da gogewar shekaru hamsin a binciken laifuka wajen yaki da cin zarafin jima'i kan yara. 01:59.239 --> 02:03.814 A matsayinka na jami'in 'yan sanda, har ma a matsayinka na babban mai ba da shawara na ma'aikatar kuma 02:03.814 --> 02:08.599 shugaban Sashen Binciken Laifuka na Thuringia, ka kasance a sahun gaba wajen waɗannan binciken. 02:08.599 --> 02:15.240 Wannan yana nufin an ba ka rahoton wasu lamura, sai ka bincika su. Amma me ya faru daga nan? 02:15.240 --> 02:25.068 Matsalar ita ce dole ne a fara gabatar da hujjoji domin a iya tura shari'ar zuwa ofishin lauyan gwamnati, inda za a karɓe su a sake 02:25.068 --> 02:30.159 sarrafa su zuwa takardar tuhuma da za a gabatar a gaban kotu. 02:30.159 --> 02:33.919 Kuma abin takaici, akwai gazawa da yawa sosai a hanya. 02:33.919 --> 02:41.879 Yana da abin takaici idan ka kama wani da safe sannan ka sake ganinsa da rana. 02:41.879 --> 02:46.759 – Na yi bayani da wannan: an kama shi da safe, an saki shi da rana. 02:46.759 --> 03:01.599 Misali, sau da yawa muna fuskantar matsalar cewa 'yan sanda sukan iso wurin kisan kai sannan su fara bincikar kisan kai. 03:01.599 --> 03:06.080 Sannan, a kan hanyar zuwa ofishin lauyan gwamnati, kisan ya koma rauni mai haifar da mutuwa. 03:06.080 --> 03:12.280 Sa'an nan, a wasu yanayi, za ka iya ƙarewa da wani abu na doka gaba ɗaya daban da matsaloli gaba ɗaya daban. 03:12.280 --> 03:20.767 Ko kuma, kamar yadda ya faru a kwanan nan, masu fyade da suka yi fyade a rukuni suka fita daga kotu suna busa busa 03:20.767 --> 03:28.719 cikin murna saboda alkali bai tabbata kashi dari cikin dari ba cewa wataƙila yarinyar ba ta yarda ba. 03:28.719 --> 03:31.960 A nan ne duk abin ya fara zama ɗan abin shakka. 03:31.960 --> 03:36.733 Kuma akwai yiwuwar da yawa-da-yawa na dakatar da shari'a ko mayar da ita zuwa shigar majinyaci 03:36.733 --> 03:39.159 a asibitin kwakwalwa, da sauransu da sauransu. 03:39.159 --> 03:45.120 Don haka akwai sabani a wani wuri a cikin kasuwanci, kuma abin takaici haka yake. 03:45.120 --> 03:50.199 Dole ne a yi waɗannan hadaya kulawa sosai kuma da muhimmanci. 03:50.199 --> 03:56.199 Kana da cikakken haƙƙi a duniya baki ɗaya a yi maka mu'amala yadda ya kamata daga hannun 'yan sanda da tsarin shari'a. 03:56.199 --> 04:03.123 Na gode da bayaninka. Haka kuma kin ambaci abin da ake kira "laifin paedofiliya" da alaƙa da ake cewa sun kai har 04:03.123 --> 04:08.240 zuwa manyan gungu. Menene abin da kika lura a wannan fanni? 04:08.240 --> 04:14.840 Eh, to mu ɗauka haka: kullum ina haɗa shari'ar Dutroux a cikin gabatarwar PowerPoint dina. 04:14.840 --> 04:18.079 Tabbas kun san shari'ar Dutroux. 04:18.079 --> 04:22.305 Wani mai cin zarafin yara na Belgium wanda ya kashe yara goma sha ɗaya kuma ya yi wa biyu 04:22.305 --> 04:24.879 yunwa har lahira yayin da yake cikin gidan yari. 04:24.879 --> 04:30.560 Saboda bai bayyana komai ba yayin da yake cikin kurkuku, sai yaran suka yi yunwa har suka mutu. Lamarin mai ban tsoro ne kwarai. 04:30.560 --> 04:38.959 Duk jerin shaidu sun taɓa shiga haɗari ko kuma sun mutu a yanayi mai cike da shakku, ko duk abin da yake. 04:38.959 --> 04:49.279 Kuma shari'ar Dutroux ta riga ta tabbatar da cewa duk matakan al'umma sun shiga cikin waɗannan ƙungiyoyin cin zarafin yara. 04:49.279 --> 04:56.240 Don haka wannan ya kai kololuwa a siyasa, ya kai kololuwa a al'adu, talabijin da kafofin watsa labarai. 04:56.240 --> 05:01.879 Hanyar tana da ma'ana iri ɗaya da matsalar asali. 05:01.879 --> 05:05.079 Ko Epstein ne ko ba Epstein ba, abu ɗaya ne daidai. 05:05.079 --> 05:11.901 A Epstein's, suna da alaƙa har zuwa matakin kololuwa a harkokin siyasa, harkokin nishadi, masu gabatar da ƙara – 05:11.901 --> 05:15.839 wa ya san menene sauransu – manyan jami'ai da 'yan siyasa. 05:15.839 --> 05:24.160 Sun yi haka ma da "Diddy" Sean Combs, wanda shima sananne ne. Yanzu an daure shi na tsawon shekaru huɗu da watanni biyu. 05:24.160 --> 05:32.240 Wannan a zahiri hukunci ne mara illa, domin an cire gaba ɗaya fannin laifukan tsari. 05:32.240 --> 05:36.246 An ce za mu janye kara mu kuma yanke masa hukunci ne kawai kan wannan lokaci guda na 05:36.246 --> 05:38.959 cin zarafi da ya yi wa budurwarsa ko matarsa. 05:38.959 --> 05:44.160 Sai kuma an rage dukkan tsarin zuwa ƙaramin sashe. 05:44.160 --> 05:50.319 A lokuta da dama, ana tsara irin waɗannan matakai da gangan a yanka-yanka. 05:50.319 --> 05:55.179 A shekarar 1995, mun yi babban shari'a a Ingila. Haka kuma bankuna, 'yan siyasa, kafofin watsa labarai, 05:55.179 --> 05:58.040 manyan attajirai da kowa da kowa sun yi mata rahoto. 05:58.040 --> 06:03.560 A tsawon shekaru, tsarin ya kasance yana ƙara ƙanƙanta, har a ƙarshe babu komai da ya rage. 06:03.560 --> 06:10.091 A ƙarshe, waɗannan su ne ƙananan shari'o'i – ana yanka su, ana rarraba su zuwa kananan yanki-yanki, kamar yadda ake kira, 06:10.091 --> 06:14.040 zuwa kananan yankin doka, sannan ba a bar wani abu mai nauyi ba. 06:14.040 --> 06:23.759 Wannan a zahiri yana haifar da zargin cewa ana yin tasiri a nan. Ba za a iya watsi da shi ba kawai. 06:23.759 --> 06:34.319 Shin kun kuma lura da wannan ƙa'ida a yankinku, kamar yadda yanzu ya faru da Epstein, Dutroux, P. Diddy da sauransu? 06:34.319 --> 06:37.360 Ka'idoji suna daidai a ko'ina, ba tare da la'akari da ƙasa ba. 06:37.360 --> 06:47.712 Dole ne ku ɗauka cewa wannan cin zarafin jima'i da ake yi wa ƙananan yara, 'yan mata da matasa 06:47.712 --> 06:53.920 mata yana faruwa a duk Turai da a duk faɗin duniya. 06:53.920 --> 07:07.960 Idan ka duba NCMEC, misali – cibiyar Amurka ta bayar da rahoton yara da suka ɓace ko aka yi masu cin zarafi – shekaru 07:07.960 --> 07:15.079 huɗu ko biyar da suka wuce, har yanzu tana da shari'u 50,000. 07:15.079 --> 07:18.480 Yanzu muna samun rahoton shari'u 205,000 a kowace shekara. 07:18.480 --> 07:19.199 Abin mamaki! 07:19.199 --> 07:21.120 Amma mu ƙaramin haske ne. 07:21.120 --> 07:29.600 Idan ka kwatanta abin da NCMEC ke ba da rahoto a Asiya, a Indiya, a Pakistan, to muna kusan miliyoyi. 07:29.600 --> 07:34.662 Wannan ya nuna a fili cewa matsala ce ta duniya baki ɗaya, ba matsalar Jamus kaɗai ba, ba 07:34.662 --> 07:38.120 matsalar Belgium kaɗai ba, ko wani abu daban. 07:38.120 --> 07:42.639 Na kuma ji cewa akwai bincike na hukuma da yawa kan cin zarafin kungiyoyin asiri. 07:42.639 --> 07:47.600 Za ka iya bayyana cikin jimloli kaɗan abin da sanarwar hukuma ta ce? 07:47.600 --> 07:55.360 Akwai bincike da yawa. Ka yarda da ni, akwai bincike marasa ƙidaya musamman a wannan fanni. 07:55.360 --> 08:04.040 Ni kaina na rubuta bincike biyu ga Majalisar Turai, a shekarar 2020 da 2021, inda na tattara duk wannan bayanin. 08:04.040 --> 08:09.160 Kuma na ce, "Toh, me za a iya yi mafi kyau? Me za mu iya sauƙaƙa? A ina za mu fara?" 08:09.160 --> 08:11.800 – Kuma a zahiri an yi akasin haka. 08:11.800 --> 08:17.519 An sake kafa wani cibiyar yaki da cin zarafin jima'i na yara. Boom. 08:17.519 --> 08:21.480 Yanzu muna da wani cibiya tare da Europol da sauransu da sauransu. 08:21.480 --> 08:25.439 Muna da wakilai a ko'ina kuma muna da bincike a ko'ina. 08:25.439 --> 08:35.919 An yi wani bincike mai ban sha'awa a shekarar 2011 kan gabatar da umarnin Tarayyar Turai don yaki da cin zarafin jima'i kan yara. 08:35.919 --> 08:39.559 Kuma an kimanta shi a shekarar 2016. Wani bincike ne mai kyau. 08:39.559 --> 08:42.600 An yi wani bincike na WeProtect. (https://www.weprotect.org/) 08:42.600 --> 08:47.799 Haka kuma binciken ya kasance mai kyau; sai dai kawai a ci gaba da aiwatar da shi. 08:47.799 --> 08:50.039 Abin kawai shi ne a yi masa wani amfani! 08:50.039 --> 08:54.861 An gudanar da wani bincike, an rubuta shi, kuma yana da daɗin karantawa, tare da kyawawan hotuna, 08:54.861 --> 08:57.279 kyawawan zane-zane da duk irin waɗannan abubuwa. 08:57.279 --> 09:00.039 Amma aiwatarwa gabaɗaya ba ta isa. 09:00.039 --> 09:04.897 Don haka, ba wai kawai babu bincike kan lamuran da ba a ba da rahoto ba ba, har ma babu niyyar 09:04.897 --> 09:07.039 siyasa don magance waɗannan matsalolin cikin zurfi. 09:07.039 --> 09:11.639 Ba wai rashin dokoki ne kawai ba, kuma tabbas babu karancin bincike. 09:11.639 --> 09:16.580 A'a, dole ne ka yi shi! Dole ne ka yi shi kuma kana so ka yi shi! 09:24.639 --> 09:32.799 Kuma kuna magana sosai game da ilimin jima'i na yara ƙanana a cibiyoyin kula da yara da makarantu. Me za ku ce game da hakan? 09:32.799 --> 09:43.937 Eh, ilimin jima'i na yara ƙanana fanni ne na musamman wanda ya ba ni mamaki sosai, domin WHO ce ta haɓaka shi tare 09:43.937 --> 09:49.840 da haɗin gwiwar Cibiyar Tarayya ta Jamus don Ilimin Lafiya. 09:49.840 --> 09:56.320 Tun daga 13 ga Fabrairu na wannan shekara (2025), an kira shi "Hukumar Tarayya ta Lafiyar Jama'a". 09:56.320 --> 10:02.600 Yana da ƙarin haƙƙoƙi, ƙarin damammaki, kuma zai iya yin ƙari sosai, musamman ma idan ya zo ga kariyar yanayi. 10:02.600 --> 10:10.120 Kuma waɗannan biyun sun haɗa waɗannan ƙa'idodin kan yadda za a "wayar da kan yara ƙanana game da jima'i". 10:10.120 --> 10:18.374 Babban ra'ayi a bayan wannan shi ne cewa yaro – bayan ana iya zubar da shi har sai haihuwa, wannan ɓangare ne na shi – 10:18.374 --> 10:26.600 ana nan take lakabtar da shi a matsayin halitta mai jima'i bayan haihuwa, wanda za a iya cin zarafi a kowane lokaci. 10:26.600 --> 10:33.679 Kuma abin ya yi matuƙar ban mamaki har ba za ka iya tunanin sa ba. 10:33.679 --> 10:42.200 Kuma abin da ya fi muni shi ne cewa waɗannan ƙa'idodin BZgA daga WHO sun dogara ne akan binciken kimiyya. 10:42.200 --> 10:49.039 Kuma yanzu don Allah duba binciken kimiyya ka ga daga ina hakan ya fito. Ya fito ne daga Kinsey. 10:49.039 --> 10:57.279 Mutumin da ya rubuta shahararren Rahoton Kinsey a shekarun 1960 kan 'yantar da maza da mata. 10:57.279 --> 11:02.679 Daga lokacin, a gaskiya komai ya fara sauka. 11:02.679 --> 11:07.440 A wancan lokacin, an riga an fara ƙirƙirar ra'ayin sassaucin jima'i. 11:07.440 --> 11:14.720 Rashin kulawa ga yara da jima'i da yara yana yiwuwa kuma gama gari ne, kuma ana yarda da shi. 11:14.720 --> 11:21.720 An gabatar da maganganun batsa. Kuma wannan mutumin, Kinsey, ya gudanar da jerin gwaje-gwaje. 11:21.720 --> 11:29.773 Kuma akwai jerin gwaje-gwaje da na gani inda aka yi wa yaro mai shekaru huɗu cin zarafi na 11:29.773 --> 11:33.440 tsawon sa'o'i 24 domin samun gamsuwa sau 27. 11:33.440 --> 11:40.132 Ka yi tunanin hakan kawai. Ya bayyana cewa duk lokacin da yaron ya yi ihu, ya yi kuka, ko ya yi girgiza jiki, sai ya ɗauka kamar 11:40.132 --> 11:45.883 samun gamsuwa ta jima'i – yana azabtar da yaron mai shekaru huɗu na tsawon sa'o'i ashirin da huɗu har sai wani 11:45.883 --> 11:51.639 irin martani na jiki ya faru – sannan ya bayyana wannan martanin na jiki a matsayin gamsuwa ta jima'i. 11:51.639 --> 11:56.853 Sannan kuma akwai waɗanda suka aikata haka, waɗanda suka yi cin zarafin yara. Wasu daga cikinsu 'yan 11:56.853 --> 12:00.080 pimp ne, wasu kuma tsofaffin fursunoni ne da aka saki. 12:00.080 --> 12:03.799 Dole ne ka yi bincike ka tace duk wannan. 12:03.799 --> 12:07.840 Sa'an nan ka ce wa kanka: "Sannu, menene wannan? Ilimin kimiyya?" 12:07.840 --> 12:15.840 Wannan cin zarafin yara ne na gaskiya, tashin hankali na jima'i ne na gaskiya kan yara a ƙarƙashin rufin bincike. 12:15.840 --> 12:18.960 Sannan sai ya sami ɗalibai masu dacewa. 12:18.960 --> 12:26.240 Sai Kinsey ya gabatar da Kentler na gaba. Akwai Rahoton Kentler. 12:26.240 --> 12:30.480 Sa'an nan akwai Sielert. Kuma daga baya akwai wani kuma, kwanan nan. 12:30.480 --> 12:34.200 Dukansu sun fito ne daga irin wannan tushen tunani. 12:34.200 --> 12:36.320 Dole ne ka yi la'akari. Kinsey ne ya fara shi. 12:36.320 --> 12:43.399 Sa'an nan suka "kwace" jami'o'i, kwalejojin fasaha da cibiyoyin horon kwararru. 12:43.399 --> 12:51.199 Yanzu ana samar da ƙarni-ƙarni na masana ilimin halayyar zamantakewa, masana ilimin al'adu da sauransu… Ana fitar da su 12:51.199 --> 12:56.705 ɗaya bayan ɗaya, suna mamaye ofisoshin jin daɗin jama'a da hukumomin ilimi a ko'ina, 12:56.705 --> 12:59.919 suna ci gaba da aiki bisa ruhin wannan horo. 12:59.919 --> 13:00.919 Abin mamaki! 13:00.919 --> 13:03.600 A ra'ayina, wannan ba shi da ma'ana kwata-kwata. 13:03.600 --> 13:10.356 Kuma idan ka duba abin da waɗannan ƙa'idoji ke buƙata – daga sifili zuwa shekaru huɗu, dole ne yaro ya 13:10.356 --> 13:13.600 koyi batsa da hannu. Daga sifili zuwa shekaru huɗu! 13:13.600 --> 13:17.759 Ina mamaki, tabbas, wane malami ne ke yin hakan kuma ta yaya yake yin hakan? 13:17.759 --> 13:25.723 Kuma yanzu muna da cibiyoyin kula da yara 17 a Schwäbisch Hall da ke kafa wuraren 13:25.723 --> 13:30.639 binciken jiki na kashin kai a cikin gine-ginensu. 13:30.639 --> 13:32.399 Iyaye suka yi matuƙar mamaki! 13:32.399 --> 13:36.200 Ba su san komai game da shi ba. Ba a sanar da su ba ma. 13:36.200 --> 13:44.960 Don haka, idan wannan shi ne ilimin jima'i na yara ƙanana, to a zahiri babu wani abu bane face rushewar iyali. 13:44.960 --> 13:46.600 Wannan rushewar iyali ce. 13:46.600 --> 13:53.399 Asalin jiha, tsakiyar jiha, shi ne kyakkyawar dangantakar iyali. 13:53.399 --> 13:56.360 Akwai uba, akwai uwa, akwai yaro, kuma haka kawai. 13:56.360 --> 14:02.200 Akwai jinsi biyu, kuma haka lamarin yake. Yanzu ni mai tsananin ra'ayin dama ne. 14:02.200 --> 14:07.399 Na sani. Akwai wani abu mafi kyau, kamar yadda Monika Gruber ta taba faɗa: 14:07.399 --> 14:15.419 Kuma idan muna da Uba na 1 da Uwa na 1, to ba da jimawa ba za mu sami Mayatacce na 1 da Mayatacce na 2 ga kakanni. 14:18.360 --> 14:27.279 Shin hakan ma zai faru? Wannan barkwanci ne, tabbas, amma gaskiyar ita ce hakan yana raina mutumci gaba ɗaya. 14:27.279 --> 14:28.320 Eh, daidai. 14:28.320 --> 14:32.960 Ba shi da jinƙai kuma babu mutunci – tabbas ba ga yaron ba. 14:32.960 --> 14:37.000 Yara ma suna da daraja. Dole ne a kare hakkokinsu ma. 14:37.000 --> 14:46.240 Kuma ya kamata a ɗauki yara a matsayin halittu na doka, ba a matsayin abubuwa da za a iya ɗauka kawai a jefar da su ba. 14:46.240 --> 14:48.320 Eh! Na gode da bayanin. 14:48.320 --> 14:53.279 Don haka akwai wani bangare mai kyau a cikin duk wannan al'amari. 14:53.279 --> 14:55.440 Wannan Jami'ar Bielefeld ce. 14:55.440 --> 15:02.347 Ta gudanar da wani babban bincike kan Kinsey, Kentler da Co. kuma ta gano cewa cin 15:02.347 --> 15:07.039 zarafin yara ne, cin zarafin jima'i ne, a ko'ina. 15:07.039 --> 15:14.493 Wannan wata ƙungiya ce ta laifi mai tsanani wadda yanzu ta bazu a duk faɗin cibiyar horo, inda ake horas da masana 15:14.493 --> 15:21.480 ilimin halayyar zamantakewa, masana ilimin halayya, shugabannin makaranta da sauran ƙwararru makamancinsu. 15:21.480 --> 15:24.519 Kuma haka yana ci gaba. Don haka yana ƙara yawaita. 15:24.519 --> 15:34.230 Don haka ba abin mamaki ba ne a karanta a mujallun kula da yara a yau cewa abu ne na al'ada a yi wa yara magani da ilimantar da 15:34.230 --> 15:39.240 su ta yadda dole ne su yi jima'i tsakanin shekaru shida da tara. 15:39.240 --> 15:43.979 Kuma suna taɓa juna da jiki cikin sha'awa, suna kuma ɓoye-ɓoye shirya ƙananan lunguna 15:43.979 --> 15:46.840 masu daɗi a ko'ina inda yara za su iya komawa. 15:46.840 --> 15:51.440 Duk wannan dai kawai yana taimaka wa masu aikata laifi. 15:51.440 --> 15:58.840 Eh... Ina baƙin ciki, ba ni da wata labari mai kyau. 15:58.840 --> 16:02.840 Wadannan dai su ne kawai munanan abubuwan da na fuskanta a can. 16:02.840 --> 16:12.399 Na yi yaƙi kusan duk tsawon rayuwata don sanya tashin hankali na jima'i kan yara zama laifi. 16:12.399 --> 16:21.440 Kuma a shekarar 2021, bayan shekaru na gwagwarmaya, a ƙarshe, a ƙarshe, a ƙarshe an aiwatar da wannan a Jamus har ya zama laifi. 16:21.440 --> 16:27.778 Kuma hakan ya kasance daga 2021 zuwa 2024. Sai Mista Buschmann, kamar yadda ake kiransa a wancan lokacin, 16:27.778 --> 16:31.320 Ministan Shari'a na jam'iyyar Liberal, ya zo ya juya shi. 16:31.320 --> 16:33.519 Yanzu laifi ne sake. 16:33.519 --> 16:36.600 Don haka wannan ma ba babban nasara ba ce. 16:36.600 --> 16:45.373 A ra'ayina, duk bayanan da Ma'aikatar Shari'a ta bayar don kare dalilin soke wannan laifi na 16:45.373 --> 16:50.039 laifi su ne hujja mai ƙarfi da ke nuna laifi. 16:50.039 --> 16:52.080 Eh, wannan hakika abin baƙin ciki ne game da yadda abubuwa suke. 16:52.080 --> 16:58.600 Na gode ƙwarai da gaske da jajircewarku wajen taimakon yara, kuma sama da komai, da kawo waɗannan batutuwa a gaban jama'a. 16:58.600 --> 17:01.159 Wannan yana da matuƙar muhimmanci. 17:01.159 --> 17:03.519 Dole ne a yi hakan. 17:03.519 --> 17:08.519 Na gode da ɗaukar lokaci, ko da yake kana kan motsi a yanzu. 17:08.519 --> 17:13.680 Bayanan ku sun taimaka mana sosai wajen samun hoto mai haske game da wannan batu. 17:13.680 --> 17:17.599 Muna yi maka fatan alheri a duk abubuwan da za ka yi nan gaba, ciki har da ritayarka. 17:17.599 --> 17:19.880 Har yanzu kana kan aiki! 17:19.880 --> 17:22.920 Na gode da kyakkyawan aikinku na ilimi. Muna son ku! 17:22.920 --> 17:25.519 Na gode.